logo

66 pages 2 hours read

Sherwood Anderson

Winesburg, Ohio

Fiction | Short Story Collection | Adult | Published in 1919

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Stories 18-22Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Story 18 Summary: “The Untold Lie”

Hal Winters’ father, Windpeter Winters, was killed when he drunkenly collided with a passing train. Hal grows up to be an ill-tempered man who squanders money on cheap clothes and alcohol. Hal starts working as a farmhand to be close to a school teacher he likes named Nell Gunther.

The narrator clarifies that this story is not about Hal, but about his fellow farmhand, a middle-aged man named Ray Pearson. Ray and Hal have opposing personalities, though they get along fine. One afternoon, Ray wistfully beholds the beautiful fields, filled with memories of his idyllic youth and the early days of his marriage. He protests that life has made a fool out of him. Hal dismisses marriage as something men must go through, and admits he has gotten Nell pregnant. Hal challenges Ray to give him advice on whether he should marry Nell or reject her. Ray is moved to tears, though he cannot bring himself to give Hal the advice he feels he should.

Later that afternoon, Ray’s wife comes to call him from the barn. Still moved by the beauty of the countryside, Ray feels tempted to disrupt his marriage in some terrifying way. Ray’s wife asks him to buy groceries, urging him not to putter or dawdle. Ray collects money from home, and walks to town through the lush fields. When he beholds the beauty of the fields, he is filled once again with a spirit of protest. He resolves to tell Hal that he doesn’t have to be bound to Nell for the rest of his life.

Ray goes to catch Hal, all the while thinking of the things he wishes he had done with his life instead of starting a family. When he finds Hal, Hal is overjoyed. He reports that he has decided to settle down and marry Nell. Ray is content, realizing that whatever advice he would’ve given would’ve been untruthful.

Story 19 Summary: “Drink”

Tom Foster moves to Winesburg as a young man, accompanying his grandmother who wants to return to her hometown after many years of travel. When they arrive in Winesburg, Tom’s grandmother no longer recognizes it. They get jobs working for the Whites. Tom serves as a stable boy in the barn.

Tom is curious and gentle by nature, which endears many people to him. When he still lived in Cincinnati, he stole a small amount from a store cash register, which his grandmother settled on his behalf. Tom admits that he was ashamed of his actions, but in a way that taught him something new about the world. While working as a messenger in Cincinnati, Tom spent a lot of time among sex workers, who shaped his thoughts and feelings about women as he grew older.

Tom is a terrible stable boy, which earns the ire of Mrs. White. After he is fired, he rents a room and lives apart from his grandmother who still visits him regularly. Tom takes on a series of odd jobs at different households and farms. He comes to appreciate the little joys in life, such as the smell of coffee beans roasting in the grocery.

Motivated by a powerful crush on Helen White, Tom goes out into town one night. He buys a bottle of whiskey, gets drunk, and ends up splayed on a patch of grass, thinking about his life in Winesburg thus far. He continues walking and ends up sick. George finds him and helps him to recover. Tom claims that he and Helen have had a romantic affair, which confounds George. George tries to get Tom to stop slandering Helen’s name.

When Tom recovers, he declares that getting drunk taught him to think with greater clarity. Unsure what Tom means, George still feels angry at him for speaking falsehoods about Helen. Tom goes on to say that following the joy that Helen brought him, he got drunk to “suffer […] because every one suffers and does wrong” (180). He wishes he could drink without hurting anyone else. He compares getting drunk to sex, emphasizing the way alcohol makes him suffer and feel strange about himself. He explains that he got drunk out of curiosity.

Story 20 Summary: “Death”

Doctor Reefy and Elizabeth Willard become friends when George is still a boy. Elizabeth initially comes to consult the doctor about her health but starts exchanging details of her life with him. When his wife is dying, Doctor Reefy tells her that his friendship with Elizabeth is like finding someone who prays to the same gods as he does.

Elizabeth and Doctor Reefy talk about the people in Winesburg, sometimes waxing poetic and philosophical about life in the town. Elizabeth feels restored after each of their conversations. On one occasion, she returns to the hotel thinking about the doctor’s assertion that love must remain indefinite.

Growing up, Elizabeth always felt distant from her parents since her mother had died when she was young and her father was preoccupied with work. As a young woman, Elizabeth felt emboldened to live adventurously. Despite her many love affairs, she never felt like she got to experience a real adventure. She initially presumed that her marriage to Tom Willard would not only satisfy this desire but give her the satisfaction of going against her father’s wishes. Shortly before he died, Elizabeth’s father offered her $800 to forego the marriage. He made her promise not to tell Tom about the money if she married him anyway.

Elizabeth tells Doctor Reefy that her desire for adventure wasn’t satisfied by her marriage. She had acted out of a desire to get married, rather than a careful consideration of whether Tom was a good match for her. She once considered telling Tom about the money her father left her, but then she realized she did not like Tom enough to share it with him. Instead, she rode out on a pony in the middle of a storm, intending to run away to a preferable life.

Elizabeth weeps before Doctor Reefy. The doctor embraces Elizabeth and calls her a “lovely dear,” echoing one of the lovers Elizabeth had taken in her youth. Their passionate moment is interrupted by the arrival of a store clerk. Elizabeth leaves shortly after, shaken by the frustration of her intimate moment with Doctor Reefy, not knowing this will be the last time they see each other before she dies. On the eve of her death, Elizabeth tries but fails to tell George about her secret money.

George is 18 years old when Elizabeth dies. Having had very few experiences of death before, George feels sick with grief and goes for a walk. He feels frustrated that he must postpone his next meeting with Helen White. When George gets home, he finds Doctor Reefy sitting with his mother’s body. The doctor considers acknowledging the boy, but feels too self-conscious and runs off.

George resolves to leave Winesburg and work as a city journalist. He thinks again of Helen and feels so ashamed at the thought that he won’t be able to kiss her for some time that he begins weeping beside his mother’s body. George feels compelled to look at his mother’s corpse, but exits the room before he can do so. He tries to convince himself that the dead body is not his mother, but someone else. He finally admits the truth when he cries with Aunt Elizabeth Swift, who has come to look after the body. He calls his mother “[t]he dear, the dear, oh the lovely dear” (191).

Elizabeth’s money remains hidden in the wall behind her bed. She had hinted its location to Tom, ever hopeful that she could fulfill her aspiration for release. The narrator notes she only ever experienced release twice—when Doctor Reefy held her and when she died.

Story 21 Summary: “Sophistication”

Held in the fall, the Winesburg County Fair is well attended by people from town and country alike. George Willard has grown into a man and remains resolved to pursue a new life in the city. His last days in Winesburg are filled with a sense of nostalgia and exhaustion. He becomes conscious of his memories and the limited possibilities of the future. George believes he has been visited by “[t]he sadness of sophistication” (193). He comes to believe that the only thing that will assuage his uncertainty is companionship and understanding.

Still enamored with Helen White, who now attends college in Cleveland, George seeks her company when she returns to town for the fair. Helen wants to see George as well and get away from her visiting college instructor, who is a guest of her mother’s. Both Helen and George look idealistically upon an encounter they had in the summer, during which they went for a walk and George explained his aspirations. He encouraged Helen to be beautiful and distinguish herself from other women.

George becomes frustrated that Helen has not yet left her visitor to be with him. He decides to visit Helen at her house. Helen is annoyed by her instructor’s conversation with her mother, who asserts that no one in Winesburg is a suitable match for Helen. Helen leaves and goes looking for George. They find each other and run off toward the county fairgrounds.

George and Helen come upon the grandstand, which has been left abandoned after the end of the fair. Helen’s presence allays George’s sadness and loneliness. They briefly kiss, walking into a wild cornfield. When they reach a hilltop, they kiss again, their mutual respect turning excited and animalistic. They start rolling and running down the hill. When they reach the bottom, they get back on their feet and continue walking. Fully satisfied, they no longer feel the need to return to their youth.

Story 22 Summary: “Departure”

One early April morning, George Willard gets up early to prepare for his departure from Winesburg. He walks along Trunion Pike to behold the vastness of the open fields one last time. Store clerks on Main Street ask George how it feels to leave Winesburg.

Tom Willard brings George to the station to take the train that runs through the cities of Cleveland, Chicago, and New York. People come to wish George well. Helen White arrives late and fails to catch George boarding his train. The trainmaster, Tom Little, punches George’s ticket, having seen many like him go this way before. George makes the acquaintance of a man who invites him to go fishing at Sandusky Bay.

George counts his money and thinks about his father’s advice to be sharp and not to seem “green” to others. Before the train leaves Winesburg, George thinks not about the big moments in his life, but the small details of life in the village. In his reverie, he falls asleep. When he opens his eyes, the train has already departed the station and Winesburg has disappeared from his life.

Stories 18-22 Analysis

The final stories of Anderson’s book center characters who have one final encounter with youth that catalyzes their growth toward wisdom or maturity.

“The Untold Lie” and “Drink” both feature characters who straddle the threshold between ignorance and wisdom. After many years as a family man, Ray Pearson decides that he wants to spare Hal the headache of marriage. Anderson indicates Ray feels moved by the allure of the fields around him, compelled by the contrast between the mundane routine of his life with his wife and the sudden presence of natural beauty around him. He admonishes Hal to preserve his access to beauty, knowing his advice goes against conventional wisdom, hinting at the challenges of Individuality in a Small Town. In “Drink,” Tom Foster approaches wisdom from the opposite direction, beginning from a place of ignorance and naivete rather than age and experience. His curiosity angers George because he initially takes Tom’s stories about Helen White to be true. When it becomes clear that the stories are part of his drunken imaginings, George finds himself at a distance from the naïve Tom—a realization that pushes his arc forward and highlights The Tension of Youth and Experience, a theme Anderson develops further in the final three stories.

“Death,” “Sophistication,” and “Departure” comprise a narrative sequence that chronicles the end of George’s youth, the beginning of his adulthood, and his departure from Winesburg. “Death” draws thematic connections between George, Elizabeth, and Doctor Reefy by examining George’s place in the relationship between Elizabeth and Reefy. The story spends much of its narrative developing the friendship between the two older people into a romance, but Anderson emphasizes its significance to George’s story through two main elements: the motif of Elizabeth being called a “lovely dear” and the secret fortune that Elizabeth keeps. The motif of “lovely dear” serves as a direct link between all three characters. Reefy independently arrives at the phrase, signaling that his love for Elizabeth authentically harkens to the romances of her youth when she most craved adventure. George repeats the phrase when he acknowledges his mother’s death, indicating that he thinks of his mother with the same kind of authentic affection that characterizes Reefy’s love for her. Although the three characters never acknowledge this connection, Anderson provides the link to demonstrate how close people can get to overcoming The Loneliness of One’s Inner World through genuine, meaningful connection. Although George never inherits the material wealth that Elizabeth possesses, Anderson frames his inheritance as a spiritual legacy from Elizabeth, who bequeaths her sense of adventure to her son. As George confronts the reality of his mother’s death, he resolves to fulfill his aspirations to work in the city.

“Sophistication” suggests that the only thing standing in the way of George’s ability to embrace the adventure of his adulthood is his attachment to Winesburg, symbolically represented in his relationship with Helen. The tension Helen feels with her college instructor represents her remaining desire to cling to her youth and innocence and her reluctance to submit to maturity. She and George pursue a final, mutual desire to embrace their youth when they run off to the abandoned grandstand. Anderson uses the image of the grandstand to evoke the idea that memory can be a kind of ghost—in this case, the ghosts of the living—foreshadowing Winesburg’s continued existence in George’s mind after he leaves it. After George and Helen rush down the hill in a reenactment of a childhood game, they willingly bring their play to an end, fully accepting the spirit of sophistication and leaving nostalgia for youth behind. Without saying it, they both acknowledge that they have grown out of childhood games and that such behaviors tire them. In the absence of any desire to reenact their youth, George and Helen accept the lives that wait for them in the city.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text