68 pages • 2 hours read
Liane MoriartyA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Alice goes to Family Talent Night at Frannie’s retirement village with Nick, Madison, Tom, and Olivia. Nick’s sister, Ella, and Ella’s son, Billy, are also present. Ella’s coldness surprises Alice because it is not the way Alice remembers her. During the performance, children perform poems, songs, and dances. Olivia performs a cute dance routine, pretending to be a butterfly emerging from a cocoon. Alice is suffused with pride and sees that Nick feels the same way.
Roger and Barb perform a salsa routine. Nick and Alice are embarrassed when they’re chosen to come onto the stage to illustrate how easy it is to learn to salsa. Alice reflects that there is still clearly chemistry between them.
Ben and Elisabeth are on their way to the Family Talent Night when Elisabeth suddenly decides that she wants to return home and watch television.
Ella stares, confused, as Alice treats Nick lovingly. Alice returns Granny Love’s ring to Nick, and Nick and Ella are surprised and grateful. Ella tells Alice that she’s being a cow about the custody battle. Alice responds, unexpectedly, with a memory: a line from a nursery rhyme or picture book about a cow saying moo. Nick asks Alice about the custody arrangement, and Alice agrees that they can share custody of the children 50/50. Hearing this, Nick is shocked and excited.
They discuss some of Nick’s memories from the last 10 years, including the birth of the children. Nick angrily reminds Alice of the time she lost Olivia at the beach. Alice wonders when their relationship became so prickly. She asks where George and Mildred are (the sandstone lions which used to be on display at the front of their home). Nick doesn’t know.
Alice discovers that she is part of a residents’ committee lobbying the council to allow the building of five-story apartment buildings. She is shocked to read her own words in favor of the construction; she agrees instead with Mrs. Bergen (her neighbor who features in the same article) who argues that it will ruin the character of the street. Alice makes brownies and goes to Mrs. Bergen’s house to apologize and tell her that she has changed her position.
Alice comes to watch one of Elisabeth’s seminars, and Elisabeth is surprised and grateful. Elisabeth reflects on the changes in Alice since her injury; Alice wears less makeup and seems more carefree. Elisabeth explains her decision not to let Alice in on the ‘truth.’ She would prefer to “pretend it's not happening and wait for the inevitable” (356).
Frannie believes she saw a spark between Alice and Nick while they were dancing but still thinks that their reconciliation is unlikely. She is grateful that Xavier spends a long time talking to Madison. Xavier asks Frannie out to dinner at the local Chinese restaurant.
Alice constantly has confusing flashes of recollection. She still hasn’t discussed Elisabeth’s next round of IVF with her. Alice considers how tiring life is as a separated mother of three.
Elisabeth reflects on the most recent embryo transfer, which took place one week ago. She considers how she and Ben used to be hopeful and excited, whereas now they are jaded and believe success is unlikely.
Alice is at the school to assist in the library when she is approached by Dominick, who says that Nick has been called as well, and that there has been a problem.
Ben calls Elisabeth, asking why she didn’t tell him; she hangs up on him.
Dominick explains that Madison bullied a girl named Chloe and that this isn’t the first time this has happened. Nick arrives. Dominick explains that Madison cut a classmate’s hair off, threatened to stab her, and pushed her face into a cake. Following the incident, Madison is suspended. Alice suggests that Nick, Alice, and Madison go for a drive somewhere to talk and work out what the problem is. Both Nick and Madison are shocked by the suggestion.
Ben continues to ask Elisabeth to turn off the television, but she refuses. He turns it off, and she begins screaming, so he turns it on again.
Alice, Nick, and Madison go to the beach. On the way, Alice observes Nick taking calls, negotiating and organizing with his colleagues. He says that he loves work. Nick goes to buy ice cream as Alice and Madison sit on a blanket on the beach. Madison reveals Chloe’s comments that caused Madison’s angry retaliation; Chloe told Madison that Alice and Mr. Gordon (Dominick) probably “did sex in his office. Like, a hundred times” (275). Chloe also told Madison that she is the ugliest girl in school. Madison insists that Chloe made up the part about Madison threatening to stab her, and Alice believes her. Alice discusses Madison’s need to manage her anger. Madison reminds Alice and Nick (who returns with ice cream) about their tendency to yell aggressively at each other.
Alice, Nick, and Madison are thrilled when they spot a whale and its calf out at sea. The mother whale jumps spectacularly.
Elisabeth journals that Ben is threatening to call Dr. Hodges to tell him about Elisabeth’s erratic behavior.
Frannie writes to Phil that something extraordinary happened to her.
Alice and Nick discuss the problems that led to their divorce. Nick explains that Alice made him feel like an idiot at home; Alice treated him with irritation and contempt. Nick says Alice she felt abandoned because of his demanding work schedule. Mike and Gina’s divorce became a contentious issue; Alice and Gina felt like Nick should no longer be friends with Mike after his infidelity. Nick suspected Alice envied Gina’s lifestyle as a single woman. Nick explains the circumstances of Gina’s death: a tree crushed Gina in her car as Alice and Madison drove behind her.
Alice finds George and Mildred, the stone lions which used to sit at the front of their home. She scrubs them clean and replaces them.
Ben calls Alice, explaining that Elisabeth has been sitting in bed watching television for 48 hours. Alice assumed that the IVF cycle failed. Ben explains that it in fact did not fail; she’s pregnant.
Elisabeth hears Ben calling Alice. She feels hateful toward everyone and everything, particularly toward herself for hoping that the pregnancy will last when she feels that a miscarriage is inevitable.
Alice arrives at Elisabeth and Ben’s place and gets into bed with Elisabeth. She gives Elisabeth the fertility doll that Dino gave her. Elisabeth explains that she feels so angry that she and Ben have given so much of their life to trying to get pregnant and that she’s so scared that she’ll lose the baby. Stress is bad for the baby, so she knows she shouldn’t worry, but she finds it impossible not to. Elisabeth eventually turns off the television and begins to cry.
Frannie tells Phil that Xavier kissed her in the back of a cab, and she kissed him back.
Alice reflects on her and Nick’s life as parents. She umpired Olivia’s netball game that day; she knew how to do it though she didn’t remember learning how to umpire. She watches as Nick referees Tom’s soccer game and thinks about everything that has happened in the 10 years she doesn’t remember. Later, Dominick comes to visit Alice, bringing flowers, chocolates, and a bottle of liqueur. Tomorrow (Sunday) is Mega Meringue Mother’s Day, the day for which Alice has been preparing.
On Sunday, Dominick arrives with flowers, biscuits, and a bottle of liqueur. Nick arrives with a bottle of wine and a spread of cheese and biscuits. Dominick gives Alice encouragement before he leaves, and Nick and Alice sit down to discuss their relationship. Alice sits on Nick’s lap, and they kiss. Olivia appears and asks, happily, “do you love Mummy again?” (398).
Frannie describes Xavier’s insistence on meeting and congratulating the chefs at the Chinese restaurant where they ate dinner. She admits that the kiss they shared in the cab was “heavenly” (299) but wonders if Phil would mind.
Alice is overwhelmed at Mega Meringue Mother’s Day as people pull her in different directions. They fire questions at her about new crews, ingredients, and procedures. Industrial equipment, including a forklift, a concrete mixer, a cane, and a specially created pie dish and oven have been brought in. A large table is set up with 100 mixing bowls and ingredients.
Barb and Roger arrive. Frannie and Xavier, as well as Elisabeth and Ben, are also visible in the stands. Barb tells Alice how happy she is that Frannie has finally found love after “holding a candle for her silly dead fiancé” for “all these years” (405). Alice is surprised to learn about Phil and Frannie’s habit of writing to him.
Nora begins MC-ing the event on Alice’s behalf. She says that Alice’s head injury is preventing her from speaking herself and describes Alice’s determination to pull off the event. Nora says that the day is dedicated to Gina.
Elisabeth's narrative arc develops with the discovery of her pregnancy. She hides it at first, explaining to Alice that she would prefer to “pretend it's not happening and wait for the inevitable” because she cannot bear to go through the trauma of a miscarriage again (356). Elisabeth’s pregnancy is also initially hidden from the reader; Moriarty positions the reader to assume (as Elisabeth’s family does), given Elisabeth’s depression and anger after the blood test, that the IVF cycle failed and that she is not pregnant. Her distress at being pregnant illustrates the trauma inherent in miscarriages; Elisabeth even contemplates suicide rather than experiencing the trauma of losing another child.
Alice’s loving and supportive response to Elisabeth’s television binge illustrates the role of Alice’s head injury in repairing their relationship. When Elisabeth explains that if she turns the television off, she will worry about the baby, but that worrying is bad for the baby, Alice suggests “maybe you could delegate the worrying to me” (391). Elisabeth explains that she and Alice had drifted apart before Alice’s injury, so Alice suggests “let’s drift back” (391). It is telling that at this, Elisabeth turns off the television and begins to cry. Alice’s loving support allows her and Elisabeth to face the stress of her pregnancy together.
Madison’s behavioral problems are revealed to be rooted in her distress at Alice and Nick’s divorce. Madison tells her parents that if Nick would “come home now and be Mum’s husband again … I’m pretty sure then I would stop being angry” (378). When Alice and Nick discuss more appropriate ways of dealing with anger (after Madison cuts Chloe’s braid off and throws her cake at her), Madison points out that, rather than counting to 10 and responding calmly, as Nick suggests she should, Madison should “just yell straightaway.” (377). Alice considers that they haven’t set a good example of appropriate behavior by being passive-aggressive and vindictive toward one another.
The sighting of the fantastic and otherworldly whales leaping from the water signifies hope in the midst of sadness. Madison says, dejectedly, when the whales fail to resurface, “they’re gone … we’ve missed them. Typical” (379). When the whales jump again, Madison is “euphoric. Skipping. Jumping. Swinging on Nick’s hand, then Alice’s, then both” (380). Madison’s joy seems out of character and illustrates her unhappiness after her parents separation and her trauma after witnessing Gina’s death.
The differences between Dominick and Nick exemplify the changes that have taken place in Alice. Nick drives a “shiny car” and spends time talking on his “hands-free mobile” (374). He belongs to the corporate world, is suave and upper-class, and comes to Alice’s home bearing wine and cheese. On the other hand, Dominick’s choice to bring chocolate biscuits characterizes him as more down-to-earth. Alice, first seeing Dominick again after her injury, notes that he has “the unassuming face of a friendly newsagent who chatted to you about the weather” (194). Dominick reminds Alice of the person Nick used to be before life transformed him into the current version of himself.
Alice considers, once again, the immense change in her personality and manner in the last 10 years. Nora, referring to Alice’s determination to make Mega Meringue Mother’s Day a reality, says affectionately on the loudspeaker: “[Y]ou all know Alice. She’s like a bull terrier when she gets an idea in her head.” Alice ponders Nora’s words: “A bull terrier? How had she changed so much in just 10 years? She was more like a labrador. Anxious to please and overexcited” (408). The demands of motherhood, as well as the stress and grief of losing a friend and experiencing a marriage breakdown, changed Alice enormously.
This change in Alice is also evident in Nick and Ella’s reaction to Ella at the Family Talent Show at Frannie’s retirement village. Ella angrily asks Alice, “why are you being such a cow over the custody,” to which Alice, inexplicably, responds “who says ‘moo’? A cow says moo!’” and smiles (344). It is clear that this response is extremely atypical for Alice; “Ella and Nick seemed lost for words” (344). Furthermore, at this event, Alice returns Granny Love’s ring to Nick. This had been a contentious issue that had created bitter arguments in the proceeding months. Alice’s nonchalant returning of the ring illustrates the enormous change Alice has undergone in returning to the mindset of her 29-year-old self: the trials of the last 10 years made her stronger, but they also hardened her emotionally. Now, she has a chance to claim the best of both worlds.
These chapters get to the root of the bitterness that now typifies Nick and Alice’s relationship. The changes are obvious to Alice since she has no context for the marriage breakdown and only remembers their blissful relationship of 10 years earlier. Alice’s openness after her injury allows Nick to voice his feelings about their relationship. She is no longer on the offensive, which means that he does not have to be on the defensive. It takes Nick a while to let his guard down because he believes that Alice is setting a trap for him, but as soon as he becomes comfortable expressing his feelings, they have a real conversation about their marital issues. This paves the way for their reconciliation.
The sandstone lions, George and Mildred, who used to sit at the front of Alice and Nick’s home, are symbolic of the restoration of their relationship. Alice notices that the two lions, whom they had personified affectionately and used to joke about, are absent from the front of the home. She finds them, discarded, in the garage: “George was lying on his side, as if he’d been kicked over. His once dignified lion’s face was now stained a moldy green, which made him look ashamed, as if he were an old man with food all over his face” (384). Alice scrubs the lions clean. As she does, she wonders if they will ever be the same or if they are “too scarred by the years of neglect?” (385). The lions’ neglected and damaged state symbolizes the damage that has occurred in Nick and Alice’s relationship. Alice decides that, like the lions, “they would just have to chip away at it until it was gone” (385). Her determination to save her marriage is represented in her determination to return the lions to their former glory: “she scrubbed so vigorously at Mildred’s mane that her teeth chattered” (385).
By Liane Moriarty