logo

34 pages 1 hour read

Fiona Hill

There Is Nothing for You Here: Finding Opportunity in the Twenty-First Century

Nonfiction | Autobiography / Memoir | Adult | Published in 2021

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 4Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 4: “Our House”

Part 4, Chapter 14 Summary: “The Great Reckoning”

Hill asserts that we don’t need to “build back better” as President Joe Biden’s campaign slogan suggested, but to “build forward together” (286). America’s political divisions are the greatest threat to democracy because they allow foreign actors, like Russia, to exploit weak points and turn citizens against each other. Major demographic shifts, coupled with the lack of opportunity, make frustrated people blame anyone they perceive as other while clinging to what they know. Trump played on this cultural tendency to polarize the country further. Now, the inability of the US to deal with problems at home has made it an even weaker player abroad.

Hill calls out several accelerants of national divisions. COVID-19 had terrible economic impacts, making the poorest even poorer and enriching the ultra-wealthy. Algorithms further drive bias and create cycles of poverty. For instance, the UK Ofqual’s standardized statistical model, which was supposed to make A-level test scores (comparable to AP exams in the US) fair during COVID-19, instead based final scores on data sets that skewed in favor of privileged children who attended private schools and penalized students from lower income areas. The UK had to rescind this algorithm’s results due to protests.

Hill identifies ways to rectify these issues before it’s too late. The federal government can take action on education. However, since the US is so vast and contains so many different issues, state and community level people-centered action is also essential.

Part 4, Chapter 15 Summary: “No More Forgotten People”

Rather than feeling powerless, everyone can improve the infrastructure of society. In a democracy, citizens have the power to affect systemic change. Average people can make a big difference by calling out inequities, reflecting on and resolving to change bias, and offering a helping hand when possible. While the UK doesn’t have the same racial barriers as the US, Hill suggests that both countries could benefit from a less rigid social hierarchy.

In the US in particular, the education system must be reformed to make room for more diverse voices and ensure the success of all. Affluent white Americans should push back on the idea of more competition. For instance, one of Hill’s friends started a science club for a high-needs school, free for kids, and supported by private donations—an admirable idea, but one that should get public funding like similar programs in the UK. Since networking is of great importance to future success, and people who live in poverty have less social capital, Hill makes a case for school exchange programs. There is room for everyone to contribute: Philanthropists can offer financial support, senior citizens and those with free time can volunteer, companies can offer internships for school kids, schools can partner with each other to give students different experiences and possibilities. All these actions open doors to communication, understanding, and growth.

Part 4, Chapter 16 Summary: “No More Forgotten Places”

Hill endorses “transformative placemaking” (337), which allows states and localities to address regional issues with federal support. Hill believes that there should be no wrong place to live. In a more inclusive society that offers access to opportunities for all people, polarization would give way to understanding. The government has a vital role to play in easing mobility—for instance, by offering funding for relocation to prevent geographic immobility. The US also needs healthcare reform: Even though this field is a reliable source of employment, the industry is riddled with problems, such as lack of access and rising costs. Co-ops could be community solutions to financial and social improvement.

Right now, areas that are struggling look to the presidency to change their day-to-day lives, but regardless of who is in power, things more or less stay the same, increasing frustration. However, a new domestic initiative modeled on the Marshall Plan, a US program to bolster the economies of European countries after WWII, would give communities the agency they need to improve the lives of average Americans, creating larger positive change.

Part 4, Conclusion and Afterword Summary

Hill recaps her main point: the need to make mobility more feasible by opening the door to more opportunities through educational reform that ensures quality education and equips students with the skills needed to weather rapidly changing technological and economic circumstances. Hill addresses J.D. Vance’s Hillbilly Elegy and Tara Westover’s Educated, both of which tell remarkable stories of talented children from poor backgrounds triumphing over extraordinary obstacles. Hill wants readers to see Vance and Westover’s lives as exceptions rather than blueprints to follow—just as she sees herself.

Hill ends the book by stressing that helping others is not just nice but necessary—it’s imperative to address the needs of people forgotten and locked out due to race, class, geography, and gender, before populism overwhelms democracy.

In her Afterword, Hill offers a guide for specific actions different groups of people can take to improve their communities. Whether someone is a CEO or a college student, she suggests getting involved and extending a hand wherever possible.

Part 4 Analysis

Hill’s work can feel like a depressing reality check as she tracks the decline of the US haunted by the specter of Russia. However, she ends the book with a call to action, proposing federal initiatives, community efforts, and individual agency.

While programs like school exchanges and internships can seem like ideals rather than practical solutions, Hill argues that “opportunities such as these show aspiring but disadvantaged people that there is a world beyond their immediate horizons. They give people hope, and permission to dream” (327). Horizon-widening experiences often have a lasting impact—after all, a person cannot dream about something if they don’t know it exists, nor can they see a clear path to a hazy aspiration. Hill credits her own success to the fact that she saw extended family members achieve upward mobility by going to college, and that every step of the way, she had mentors who helped shape her goals. Hill argues that broadened opportunities are essential if the US and UK are to avoid dire consequences.

Hill ends by calling not only on US and UK governments to respond to the needs of their citizens, but also on everyone else to enable “this infrastructure, even at the individual level. We all have agency and the power to do something to make a difference in the lives of other people” (305). 

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text