The Well of Ascension

Fiction | Novel | YA | Published in 2007

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Download PDF

Summary

Background

Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 1

Part 2

Part 3

Part 4

Part 5

Part 6-Epilogue

Character Analysis

Themes

Symbols & Motifs

Important Quotes

Essay Topics

Tools

Beta

Discussion Questions

Themes

The Tension Between Idealism and Pragmatism in Leadership

In The Well of Ascension, the main characters and their companions face the burdens of leadership (especially leadership imposed on them suddenly), and the novel reveals how difficult it can be to combine ethical leadership with the exigencies of politics. Kelsier secretly arranged for his crew to take on positions of leadership in a world that he envisioned would be run by the skaa rather than the mostly corrupt noblemen. None of the crew members have prior experience leading a nation, but Kelsier’s final wishes in The Final Empire made clear for them the skills he saw as essential to leading the people amid a power vacuum. The crew members all face the difficulties of leadership with varying levels of willingness and hope, and by the time of Well of Ascension, the pressures of leadership during a crisis are wearing them down.

Vin observes that the crew misses Kelsier not only as a friend but also as a skilled leader. Elend, the man who became king after the Lord Ruler’s death, believes that the crew compares him unfavorably to Kelsier. Elend’s struggles with leadership take on a primary role in the novel as he becomes a protagonist rather than the deuteragonist he was in The Final Empire. His conversations with the others and his lessons in kingship with Tindwyl reveal how Elend struggles to reconcile his desire to be an ethical leader with the people’s need for strength. Tindwyl’s consistent argument to Elend is that the people need a powerful leader like those of history—one who will not allow himself to be overthrown because he knows he is the leader they need. This insistence on maintaining power at all costs conflicts with Elend’s ideals of ethical leadership and just treatment of the people, built through passionate study and dissatisfaction with the Lord Ruler’s despotic reign. Though he personally benefitted from the Lord Ruler’s unequal society, Elend understands how wrong that society’s treatment of the skaa was, and he fights to ensure that the skaa will never suffer under oppressive legal systems again, even if that means he must follow his own rules and step down when asked.

Elend’s struggle to balance his ideals with political reality is made even more difficult by the fact that his people are in a state of crisis, facing invasion, economic struggles, and shortages of food and other necessities. He slowly accepts Tindwyl’s suggestions for his bearing and behavior while maintaining his principles, but eventually, he realizes that the nation’s dire situation calls for a beneficent emperor who will take control of the situation. Unwillingly, he accepts the power that Vin takes back for him and decides to do what he must to save his people while still giving them as many rights as possible.

The dilemmas that Elend faces reflect the challenges of rebuilding a society in a power vacuum left by the death of the Lord Ruler. With the fall of the oppressive regime, Luthadel faces political, social, and economic instability. The struggle to fill the void left by the Lord Ruler is central to the story, illustrating the difficulty of rebuilding a society in the aftermath of years of tyranny. Sanderson highlights the fragility of power structures and the moral complexities of leadership during a time of upheaval, as Elend is caught between his idealism and the harsh realities of governance. The death of the Lord Ruler has caused many factions to rise in the power vacuum. The noble houses, once subject to the Lord Ruler’s control, now vie for power through manipulation, force, and political alliances. This creates a fragmented society in which individuals struggle with shifting power dynamics and the fear of chaos. The novel underscores that societal reconstruction isn’t just about filling the void left by a dictator but about redefining the principles by which society operates.

The external threats facing Luthadel further complicate efforts at reconstruction. Rebel armies, including those led by Elend’s father, Straff Venture, exacerbate the political instability. Straff’s authoritarian approach to power contrasts sharply with Elend’s egalitarian ideals, highlighting the difficulty of establishing a government that is both effective and morally sound.

Vin’s internal conflict also mirrors the broader theme of power in the novel. Having suffered under the Lord Ruler’s regime, she is wary of absolute power but understands the necessity of strength in the face of enemies. Her struggle—whether to accept a role as a ruler alongside Elend or remain a pawn in the power competitions of others—reflects the tension between authority and freedom. Vin’s dilemma raises questions about leadership and the ethics of governance in a world with no clear moral compass.

Ultimately, The Well of Ascension presents societal reconstruction as a fraught and complicated process. The characters grapple with the challenges of rebuilding a new order in a world where trust, loyalty, and power are in constant flux. Sanderson illustrates that creating a just world in the power vacuum left by the Lord Ruler requires not just the removal of a tyrant but a careful balance between idealism and pragmatism.

The Need to Define One’s Own Identity

In The Well of Ascension, Sanderson explores the development of identity and self-worth through the character development of Vin and Elend. Both struggle with their sense of self, especially under the heavy burdens of leadership. The novel delves into how identity is shaped not just by others’ perceptions but by how individuals respond to challenges and define themselves in the face of adversity.

Vin’s sense of identity has been fluid since The Final Empire, where her “street urchin” upbringing left her with a fractured self-image. Initially hiding in the shadows, she found a brief sense of freedom and enjoyment in her role as a noblewoman spy. By The Well of Ascension, however, she has reverted to her old habits, even as she retains elements of her former nobility. As a Mistborn, her power is so great that it risks becoming her entire identity. Vin grapples with reconciling her humble beginnings with her emerging leadership potential, and she wonders who she is outside the context of her remarkable abilities. Her self-worth is influenced by her relationships, particularly with Elend, who sees her as more than just a weapon, and Tindwyl, who encourages her to accept herself. As she steps into a leadership role, Vin learns that her value lies not in her strength but in her compassion, choices, and ability to trust others. Her journey highlights the internal conflict between her survival instincts and her growing sense of responsibility.

Elend’s struggle with identity revolves more around leadership. Raised in privilege, he rejected his noble upbringing after witnessing its cruelty, seeking instead to create a more just society. By The Well of Ascension, he has become a king, but his ideals are increasingly challenged by the pragmatic demands of leadership. Elend’s self-worth is tied to his vision of democracy and freedom, but as external threats and political pressures mount, he begins to doubt his ability to lead. His identity is also shaped by his relationship with Vin, whose support and love give him strength. However, as he faces moments of failure, he wonders if he is sacrificing his ideals for political stability.

Both characters ultimately realize that identity and self-worth are not fixed; they evolve through choices and relationships. For Vin, self-worth grows as she embraces her role, balancing strength and empathy. For Elend, it stems from persevering through failure while staying true to his principles. In the end, both characters learn that true worth is not defined by power or external recognition but by their actions and inherent humanity.

The Power of Hope

Hope plays a powerful role in Well of Ascension, continuing the theme that originated in The Final Empire. The crew’s leadership often relies on hope’s motivating power, but they are beginning to lose faith as their people struggle financially, lose access to essential resources, and face potentially violent invasion and a loss of their rights under one of the two tyrants outside the city.

Elend is one of the only characters who truly attempts to live with a sense of hope for much of the novel. He repeatedly insists that he will find solutions to their political, economic, and social problems, despite his insecurities. Tindwyl coaches Elend in part to show him how to serve as a source of hope for his people. Like Kelsier before him, Elend becomes a symbol of hope by embodying kingly traits in his appearance, posture, and speech. The novel reveals the power of perception as a means of building hope and inspiring faith in one’s leaders; Tindwyl seems to suggest that the change in Elend’s image is good but is too little too late. Despite her pessimism, Elend and Vin use the perception of their (particularly Vin’s) power to reassert control and work toward saving their people.

Some of the crew members resist the hope that Elend tries to revive. For some of them, it is difficult to face such demoralizing crises and maintain hope; for others, like Dockson, the very fact that they put a nobleman on the throne after overthrowing the Lord Ruler feels demoralizing. Dockson attempts to work with Elend, but Vin notes how different he is since Kelsier’s death and Elend’s ascent to the throne. Their loss of faith over the course of the novel affects their ability to see a solution to the city’s problems, leading them to concede defeat prematurely in the face of an impending invasion.

Sazed’s character arc is emblematic of the way hope fluctuates in the face of changing circumstances. As a scholar, he studies and preserves the world’s religions, and he believes that all of them contain essential truths about the human experience. As Luthadel’s overthrow becomes increasingly certain, however, he gradually loses his faith, eventually deciding that religion offers only false hope. Despite this despair, Sazed ultimately revives a new kind of hope, not only for himself but also for others. He shows the crew that hope can take on different forms; instead of hoping for their own salvation, they can hope for the future of their people by sending Vin, Elend, and Spook away from the invasion. They give themselves hope for their world rather than themselves by tricking the three young people into saving themselves so that they can start anew elsewhere. When Vin returns to help save Luthadel despite all odds, she helps renew the city’s hope even as they face death and destruction from the koloss attack. Vin’s intervention in this final battle demonstrates the power of appearances once again: The spectacle of her power boosts the people’s morale and appears to confirm their religious veneration of her as the city’s savior—a mythology she has previously rejected. At the same time, her actions here go beyond mere spectacle: She puts herself at genuine risk and succeeds in turning the tide of the battle.