119 pages • 3 hours read
Viet Thanh NguyenA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.
Arthur Arellano meets Louis Vu at Brodard’s Vietnamese restaurant in Orange County, California. Louis introduced Arthur to Vietnamese food, and Arthur has grown a real taste for it. Arthur allows Louis to stash his stock of bootleg, high-fashion products in his garage as a way of repaying a debt to Louis’s father. Arthur, however, feels conflicted about swindling people. As he listens to Louis’s philosophical justifications for his trade, he has the nagging feeling he is forgetting something.
Arthur’s life fell apart due to his gambling addiction. His wife, Norma, left him after he gambled away their bungalow in Huntington Beach. Shortly after, Arthur was diagnosed with autoimmune hepatitis, which meant he needed a liver transplant. His illness brought Norma back to him. Before his transplant, Arthur fantasized about being a better person after the surgery. He initially wanted to know about the person whose liver he would receive, but he ultimately decided to leave the air of mystery intact. A chance error by the hospital a year after Arthur’s life-saving surgery revealed that Arthur’s new liver came from Men Vu, an elderly Vietnamese man who was killed in a hit-and-run accident. Arthur, unaccustomed to Asian ethnic surnames, assumed Men must have been Chinese.
Arthur felt obligated to find and thank Men’s surviving family members. After attempting to contact the hundreds of people with the surname Vu in the Orange County phonebook, Arthur eventually found Louis, a man claiming to be Men’s son. They agreed to meet up in Fountain Valley, a nearby suburb that Arthur always admired.
Back in the present, Arthur remembers he forgot to bring home the dry cleaning. When Norma gets home, she is displeased. In bed that night, she chastises Arthur for his childish behavior and for never doing anything nice for her. Arthur tries to blame it on his liver. Norma sends him out to sleep on the couch.
After an uncomfortable night on the couch, Arthur takes his medications, including antidepressants, and calls his brother, Martin. He thinks of asking Martin if he can sleep at his house but changes his mind. Their father, Arturo (Big Art), started a landscaping company that Martin inherited once Arthur’s gambling addiction proved he was too unreliable. Arthur works as an accountant out of a home office in Martin’s backyard. Arthur is secretly jealous of Martin’s affluence. At work, Martin asks how things are between Arthur and Norma; Arthur lies and says that they are fine. Martin is concerned and tells Arthur, “You know Norma talks to her pedicurist, who talks to Elaine, who talks to her mother, who talks to me. I don’t even go looking for this, Artie. I just hear it because it’s out there” (65).
Arthur has dinner with Louis at Louis’s apartment, where he is staying the night; Louis has food delivered by the son of a Vietnamese widow who cooks for bachelors. Arthur says that even though he dislikes his brother, he would be willing to donate parts of himself to save him if he had the opportunity. Louis reminds him that this is impossible; the medications he takes to stop his body from rejecting the new liver make Arthur unsuitable as an organ donor. Arthur is secretly pleased by this fact, “feeling that his decision to donate, before he was told he could not, gave him a toehold on the moral high ground, the kind of real estate that Louis said could not be bought” (67). Louis owns several homes in Southern California, but he rents them out, preferring to live in a small apartment and plan his business ventures. Unlike Arthur, who fixates on his past, Louis ignores the past and fixes his eyes on the future. Arthur speculates that he is Louis’s only friend.
Arthur receives disturbing news the next day when he goes home to pick up clean clothes to take to Louis’s apartment after a frustrating day at work. Norma informs him that he had a call from a man named Minh. Arthur returns the call. Minh was Men’s son; the Vu family decided to contact the recipients of Men’s organs. Minh does not have a brother named Louis. Arthur is enraged. He drinks several shots of whiskey, the first alcohol he has had since the transplant. Norma says they need to go confront Louis; when Arthur remains adamant that he go alone, she calls him an idiot. He feels a jolt of pain in his liver as he goes to confront him.
Louis is surprisingly calm. Arthur accuses him of using Louis Vuitton, Louis’s favorite designer to pirate, as a pseudonym. Louis assures him that his real name is Louis Vu and that he is Chinese by ethnicity but Vietnamese by nationality. Arthur tells Louis to get his counterfeit goods out of his garage. Louis refuses, threatening to report Martin and his company for employing undocumented immigrants. Arthur leaves, frustrated, shaken, and saddened—he really did view Louis as a friend. When he gets back home, he stalls and looks at the illegal products crammed into his garage. Norma confronts him, and for once, he sees himself as she sees him: “offering nothing but empty hands” (74).
The “transplant” in this short story’s title can refer to several things. First and most obviously, it refers to Arthur’s liver transplant. Receiving Men Vu’s liver is not only an organ transplant for Arthur but a transplant of a new sense of responsibility and value into his life. Anticipating the transplant, he imagines “how he would be a new man; someone kinder, more reliable, harder-working; somebody to make Norma proud” (61). He fails to live up to these virtues, but he applies them to Men Vu, a man who he never met but to whom he now feels intimately close. This fills him with a sense of debt, which leads him to become friends with Louis Vu, who pretends to be Men’s son.
Louis is a “transplant” in that he embeds himself in a situation that has nothing to do with him to grift off Arthur’s ignorance. However, he ends up becoming friends with Arthur, indicated by his genuinely hurt feelings when Arthur breaks off their friendship when Louis’s lie is exposed. Arthur is also “transplanted” into Louis’s world of underhanded dealing, becoming a willing participant in a situation he does not fully understand or even morally agree with out of his sense of debt to Men. Louis’s justification for selling counterfeit goods satirizes the economic and materialistic aspects of the American dream. He tries to sell Arthur on the idea that the ability to own many counterfeit goods (“better than genuine” products) is more fulfilling than owning the real article, which emphasizes the American ideal of overconsumption.
Arthur’s consumption of Vietnamese food represents both his willingness to learn and accept Vietnamese culture and his ignorance in general. Arthur, like many Americans, defaults to labeling any Asian person he encounters as “Chinese,” an assumption and stereotype that diminishes the vastly diverse Asian population in Southern California. Many ethnicities have specific enclaves throughout the region, including the Little Saigon area of Westminster and Garden Grove in Orange County. Arthur’s misidentification of Men Vu’s name results from ignorance, not malice; he has simply not been exposed to Vietnamese culture despite living adjacent to Little Saigon. Louis introducing Vietnamese food to Arthur represents the way that food carries social value and serves as a sort of “ambassador” to different cultures.
By Viet Thanh Nguyen
Aging
View Collection
Asian American & Pacific Islander...
View Collection
Family
View Collection
Immigrants & Refugees
View Collection
Sexual Harassment & Violence
View Collection
The Best of "Best Book" Lists
View Collection
Vietnamese Studies
View Collection
Vietnam War
View Collection
War
View Collection