68 pages • 2 hours read
Marianne CroninA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
General anesthesia always gives Lenni vivid dreams. This time, she dreams that she’s the “fiercest of friends” with a purple octopus and that she can hear “the most wonderful music” (121).
Margot shares a memory from February 1959. At age 28, Margot decides to leave Glasgow. Her mother died two years ago, and her father remained distant because of post-traumatic stress disorder. Margot found her isolated status as a “childless mother and a husbandless wife, a parentless daughter” both freeing and saddening (123). She journeyed to London in search of Johnny. At the police station, she struggled to fill out a missing person’s report because her husband was by then a virtual stranger to her. A lively blond woman named Meena sat beside Margot, listened to her story, and encouraged her not to let her husband define her any longer. She offered Margot a place to stay and then tossed the report in a rubbish bin.
The narrative returns to 2014. Upon reuniting with her friend in the Rose Room, Margot hugs Lenni tight. Lenni swears when she sees the quantity and excellence of the sketches and paintings that Margot has made in her absence. Pippa welcomes Lenni back, but Lenni finds it irritating when the art teacher, like other people she has encountered, wants “to know all the surgical details. Exactly how much you’re dying” (129). Lenni doesn’t describe the paintings and stories that she and Margot share that day because those creations are “secondary” in importance to the friends simply being side by side again (129).
Lenni views the patients as prisoners and the hospital staff as jailers, but New Nurse is an exception. Lenni reads an article about a harvest festival in a Christian magazine and decides to help Arthur with the hospital’s festival. When she asks Jacky to let her go to the chapel, however, the head nurse refuses. Lenni repeatedly reminds Jacky that she’s dying and starts crying, but Jacky retorts that Lenni creates more trouble than any other patient and calls security. A security guard named Sunny offers to take Lenni to the chapel, but Jacky insists that she return to her bed instead. Sunny lets Lenni lead the way and then informs Father Arthur that Lenni wants to see him. Arthur goes to Lenni. When she tells him about the article, he gently explains that the festival is in September and has already passed. Lenni thanks him for visiting her, and he replies, “[T]hat’s what friends are for” (139).
In March 1960, 29-year-old Margot lived with Meena in a dilapidated one-room apartment. Her father had died that winter, but every day felt like summer since she met Meena. Meena worked as a typist for a professor and claimed that the position allowed her to gather information about animal testing at the university. A friend of Meena’s helped Margot find work at the London Library. One evening, Margot smeared her mascara while preparing for a party, and Meena redid their makeup, painting flowers on both their faces, and shared a vibrant green bottle of pear liqueur with Margot. On the bus, an elderly woman tried to shame them for their whimsical makeup, but Meena laughed it off. At the party, Margot felt as though she was swimming, pleasantly buoyed by the alcohol. The women found an abused dog and set it free before stumbling home. Feeling sick, Meena hurried to the bathroom and asked Margot to distract her by telling her something that she didn’t know. In response, Margot told Meena that she loved her.
Back in 2014, New Nurse talks to Lenni about what happened with Jacky. When Lenni confirms that her interaction with Jacky made her cry, New Nurse looks as though she might cry because she has never seen Lenni shed tears before. Lenni asks New Nurse whether she yelled at Jacky. When New Nurse dodges the question, Lenni is annoyed and feigns exhaustion so that New Nurse will leave.
The next morning, Margot visits Lenni and, “since [they] tell each other everything” (151), confides that she’s in the hospital because something’s wrong with her heart. Lenni is surprised because she thinks Margot has “the nicest heart” (151). Margot is calm despite her terminal prognosis and gives Lenni a bright smile.
In 2013, 16-year-old Lenni and her father visited a consultant at Princess Royal Hospital while her father’s girlfriend, Agnieszka, sat in the waiting room. The consultant’s office overlooked a parking lot, and Lenni watched the cars rather than listening to the doctor’s explanations of “surgeries and stages and bones” (154). Lenni’s father listened to every word and went so gray and still that Lenni thought he wasn’t breathing.
In July 1964, Meena and a 33-year-old Margot were arrested in London after a failed attempt to free the lab mice at the medical school where Meena worked. Although Margot was seven years older than Meena, she looked up to the younger woman, considering Meena her “guide through London and through life” (155). However, Meena seemed out of her depth at the police station. She gave her name as Catherine Amelia Houghton, which Margot thought was an alias. The women were placed in separate cells, and Margot paced while pondering what the people back home would think of her current life. She suspected that they’d condemn her for making friends and having fun when she was “supposed to be in Scotland, grieving” (158). Meena’s employer dropped the charges, and the women were released. Margot asked Meena about her name. Meena laughed, surprised that Margot thought Meena Star was her birth name. The women had lived together for five years, and Margot asked what else she didn’t know about her. In response, Meena playfully called her an “idiot,” grabbed her shoulders, and kissed her. A man shoved past them, muttering an anti-gay slur.
Back in 2014. Lenni and Margot are a quarter of the way to their goal. Lenni feels a little daunted about whether she and Margot will have enough time and memories to complete another 75 pictures. All the same, reaching a total of 25 paintings seems “deliciously real” and [h]opeful” (164) to Lenni even though the paintings portray some of the most painful memories in their lives, such as the day Lenni received her terminal diagnosis and the beach where Johnny left Margot. Margot gently touches the painting of the pear liqueur Meena gave her and asks Lenni what’s next for them.
Lenni admires how peaceful Margot looks when she paints and waits patiently for her to share the memory she’s drawing since she “could wait for Margot’s stories forever” (166).
Margot recalls a sweltering August day in 1965. After the arrest, 34-year-old Margot changed her last name back to Macrae and stopped participating in activism with Meena and her friends, staying behind while the others went to free the animals at a farm near Sussex. Margot felt herself becoming “the old Margot, [...] pale, self-conscious” (167), fearful of participating in Meena’s cause. Margot closed her eyes and stuck a pin in a map. The pin landed on Henley-in-Arden, and she decided to go there when she must leave London one day.
In this section, suspense mounts as Lenni’s health continues to decline and Margot unfolds the story of her and Meena’s star-crossed love. In Chapter 29, Lenni recovers from emergency surgery. Her anesthetized dreams connect to the theme of The Power of Friendship. The purple octopus represents Margot, who is Lenni’s closest friend and usually wears purple. The music alludes to Father Arthur because she recently discussed the piano with him. Lenni’s friends are a comforting presence in her mind even when she’s unconscious. Margot’s joy at reuniting with Lenni in Chapter 31 demonstrates the strength of their friendship. Even the stories they share and the paintings they create together are less important than simply being in each other’s presence. Chapter 31 adds nuance to the theme of The Importance of Sharing Stories by raising the question of who deserves to hear a story. Pippa means well, but her questions about Lenni’s health suggest a sense of entitlement and ignorance. The art teacher doesn’t understand what it’s like to live with a terminal condition and be badgered by good-intentioned people who want to know about “all the surgical details. Exactly how much you’re dying” (129). Margot, on the other hand, understands her friend well enough not to ply her with questions about the operation or her absent parents.
In Chapter 32, a rare crack appears in Lenni’s exuberant armor, and strangers and friends alike rally to her aid. Lenni compares herself and her fellow patients to inmates and the nurses to jailers. Extending this metaphor, Jacky is the warden. The stern, unyielding head nurse is the closest character to an antagonist in Lenni’s story. Jacky refuses to see Lenni as exceptional and emphasizes that Lenni isn’t exempt from the rules because of her prognosis. Jacky’s refusal to let Lenni see Father Arthur makes Lenni cry in part because she lives in “a place where dying doesn’t make you special” (137). Unlike Jacky, Sunny the security guard focuses on Lenni’s needs rather than protocol and does what he can to help her. He lets her lead the way back to her bed so that she can keep some dignity and then tells Arthur what happened. Sunny’s compassion prompts Lenni to observe, “The cruelty of strangers never usually upsets me, but the kindness of strangers is oddly devastating” (137). The lonely Lenni is accustomed to harshness and callousness and struggles to accept unexpected gentleness. The chapter closes on a warm note when Father Arthur visits Lenni and reminds her that helping one another is what friends are for.
Lenni’s relationship with Margot further develops the theme of friendship in this section. The teen greatly values honesty, especially in her friendships. In Chapter 34, she feels irritated when New Nurse withholds information about her actions and feelings while wanting to know all about Lenni’s. Margot appears, unprompted, the very next morning and tells Lenni the truth about her heart condition, underscoring the strength of their friendship. In Chapter 35, Lenni entrusts Margot with something deeply personal in return by telling the story of the day she received her diagnosis. Lenni draws a connection between her father and Johnny. Both men were in a painful situation, and Lenni thinks it was better for her and Margot to set them free. These insightful parallels show that Lenni not only enjoys listening to her friend’s stories but gains wisdom and consolation from them.
On the subject of storytelling, Chapter 37 reveals that Lenni and Margot have completed a quarter of their goal of 100 paintings. By sharing their memories and turning them into art, the friends create beauty from their pain. The paintings are “real” and “hopeful,” granting Lenni the permanence she desires and the self-belief she needs as she copes with her declining health. Lenni still feels self-conscious about the gap between her artistic skills and Margot’s, and she’s understandably concerned about their ability to finish the project because they both have limited time. Margot, as a good friend, is steady and encouraging for Lenni, already looking ahead to what’s next for them both.
Margot’s stories in this section focus on her complex relationship with Meena. Margot’s experiences reveal a great deal of loneliness. In Chapter 31, her solitude became something positive, a fresh start. Having lost her parents, husband, and child, Margot’s obligations to the traditional roles of daughter, wife, and mother were gone—and Meena encouraged Margot to liberate herself from tradition and societal expectations by figuratively and literally tossing Margot’s attempt to find her husband in the garbage. In Chapter 33, Meena tried to unfetter Margot from others’ expectations just like she freed the abused dog. The dingy bathroom made a rather unromantic setting for Margot’s love confession, but it was nonetheless a vital moment in their relationship.
The suspense increases in Chapter 36, which explores the concepts of love and identity. Wanting to be like Meena, Margot participated in her animal rights activism. As a result, Meena and Margot returned to the police station where they first met, but this time they were under arrest. While pacing in her cell, Margot thought that, according to societal expectations, she should be grieving her son’s death and her failed marriage in Scotland instead of making friends and having adventures. Even behind bars, however, Margot found her life in London far better than the existence she would have had back home. Meena’s birth name came as a revelation to Margot. Meena had reinvented herself, and Margot was working to do the same, so this brought them closer together. They shared their first kiss after the charges were dropped, emphasizing the freedom of that moment. However, discrimination and societal pressures immediately rear their heads in the form of the stranger’s anti-gay slur.
Chapter 38 continues the exploration of love, identity, and suspense. Margot asserted her sense of self by no longer using Johnny’s last name, but the 34-year-old felt herself receding into her old identity. She thought she’d need to leave London one day since she was too afraid to follow Meena the way she used to—and even selected a location for her eventual move. Margot and Meena’s time together hadn’t ended yet, but their parting seemed inevitable. As the novel continues, Margot reveals that there was more to their love story, and likewise, there’s more to Lenni’s brief, impactful life.
Art
View Collection
Books About Art
View Collection
Community
View Collection
Fear
View Collection
Forgiveness
View Collection
Friendship
View Collection
Guilt
View Collection
Health & Medicine
View Collection
LGBTQ Literature
View Collection
Memory
View Collection
Mental Illness
View Collection
Mortality & Death
View Collection
Popular Book Club Picks
View Collection
Religion & Spirituality
View Collection
Romance
View Collection
Truth & Lies
View Collection
Valentine's Day Reads: The Theme of Love
View Collection