logo

51 pages 1 hour read

David Grann

The Lost City of Z: A Tale of Deadly Obsession in the Amazon

Nonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 2009

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 22-25Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 22 Summary: “Dead or Alive”

Fawcett, Jack, and Raleigh have disappeared. Several years pass. Family and friends remain hopeful, but many fear the worst. Charlatans emerge with phony reports of the expedition’s fate. In February 1928, George Dyott of the RGS leads a search party consisting of 26 members. Sending updates via radio, Dyott keeps the world informed of his progress. In June he arrives at Bakairi Post and meets Bernardino, a native who claims to have guided Fawcett. A month later, the Dyott party arrives at the village of Nahukwa. Dyott meets chief Aloique and notices several items in the village that might have belonged to Fawcett. Dyott concludes that Aloique and the Nahukwa had killed Fawcett, Jack, and Raleigh. After he emerges from the jungle, Dyott writes a book and stars in a movie about his rescue effort. Brian Fawcett, however, questions Dyott’s story on multiple fronts, noting, for instance, that the Fawcett expedition never included a guide named Bernardino.

Purported sightings and rescue efforts continue. In 1932, Stefan Rattin, a Swiss explorer, claims to have seen and spoken with Fawcett, who is being held captive by hostile natives. Citing a promise to Colonel Fawcett, Rattin organizes his own rescue mission. The Rattin party leaves in May and, like Fawcett seven years earlier, disappears without a trace. Rescue efforts continue, most of them unauthorized or prohibited by the Brazilian government. In a Kuikuro village, missionaries discover a white child named Dulipe, whom they insist is the son of Jack Fawcett and a native woman, but the boy turns out to be an albino. Finally, in 1951, a Brazilian government official named Orlando Villas Boas announces that members of the Kalapalos tribe had killed Fawcett, Jack, and Raleigh, and Boas presents Colonel Fawcett’s bones as evidence.

Chapter 23 Summary: “The Colonel’s Bones”

In 2005, Grann and Pinage meet Vajuvi, chief of the Kalapalos. Vajuvi guides Grann and Penage into the Xingu National Park, where they travel by boat down the Kuluene River and arrive at the Kalapalo village, where ancient and modern appear to meet. Some Kalapalos walk naked through the village’s “circular plaza,” wearing only “monkey-tooth necklaces” and other ornaments (285). Other villagers watch television. While fishing, Vajuve explains that the bones Orlando Villas Boas claimed were Fawcett’s in 1951 actually belonged to Vajuvi’s grandfather. Boas had suggested the ruse in hopes of protecting Indigenous tribes from the continual encroachments of white explorers searching for Fawcett. Vajuvi also reports what he heard from his parents. In 1925, the Fawcett party had indeed been in the Kalapalo village. Fawcett, Jack, and Raleigh presented gifts, received food, and left the village to continue eastward. The Kalapalos tried to warn Fawcett that only hostile tribes lay to the east, but Fawcett insisted on continuing in that direction. After five days, the Kalapalos no longer saw smoke rising from Fawcett’s campfires. A few Kalapalos searched the area but found no trace of Fawcett. Vajuvi concludes: “People always say that the Kalapalos killed the Englishmen. But we did not. We tried to save them” (293).

Chapter 24 Summary: “The Other World”

As years pass, Nina consults psychics in hopes of learning what happened to her husband and son. Others do likewise. Brian Fawcett sinks into a deep depression. Nina gives Brian a trunk full of Fawcett’s diaries and logbooks. A childless, middle-aged man stuck in a job he despises, Brian finds purpose and exhilaration as he traces his father’s steps. Like many others, Brian is now drawn into the legend of Z. He publishes Exploration Fawcett in 1953. Shortly before her death at eighty-four, Nina reads the manuscript with great enthusiasm. Brian organizes his own expedition into the Amazon via airplane. He even comes to believe that his brother Jack might have survived. Brian’s venture, however, yields no clues. He begins to question whether Z ever existed. In fact, Brian reflects on some of his father’s occult-related writings and wonders if Z amounts to little more than a spiritual allegory.

Chapter 25 Summary: “Z”

In 2005, Grann encounters Brazilians and others who believe that Fawcett disappeared into another dimension. Grann considers ending his own search. Instead, Grann, Pinage, and Vajuvi head north to the Kuikuro village, where Grann hopes to meet with the archaeologist Michael Heckenberger. Although he is briefly separated from the group, Grann finds his way to the village, where he meets the Kuikuro chief Afukaka. After a few moments, Heckenberger appears. Afukaka has adopted Heckenberger into the tribe. Heckenberger shares his own fascination with Fawcett, whom the archaeologist describes as “one of those larger-than-life figures,” a man who, for all his quirks and deficiencies, saw things that others did not (310).

Finally, Heckenberger takes Grann and the others to the nearest archaeological site, where Heckenberger points to sloping ground that once served as a moat surrounding a walled city. The moat dates to 1200 A.D. Heckenberger continues into the jungle, pointing out “the remains of a massive man-made landscape” featuring a “giant circular plaza” that once had contained a “sprawling neighborhood of dwellings” (312). A closer look reveals ancient roads, canals, and evidence of wooden bridges. Heckenberger has found twenty such settlements in the Xingu region, exactly where Fawcett expected to find Z.

Chapters 22-25 Analysis

The Lost City of Z reaches no definitive conclusions about Fawcett’s fate, but Stefan Rattin’s 1932 report merits close attention. Rattin’s description of Fawcett being held captive by natives seems credible to both Nina Fawcett and Elsie Rimell. Others are skeptical, but Rattin seeks no reward for his rescue effort, which only enhances his credibility in the eyes of those who want to believe the best. Furthermore, Britain’s consul-general to Brazil, Arthur Abbott, wrote that Rattin had described details about Fawcett “only known to me and a few personal friends” (271). Rattin’s own disappearance in 1932, however, precludes further speculation about his veracity or his role in illuminating Fawcett’s fate.

As the book nears its conclusion, Grann shifts his focus from Fawcett to the Indigenous Amazonians. Instead of serving as a curious footnote to the Fawcett story, for instance, the albino native Dulipe becomes an object of sympathy. Described as a “freak” by Time magazine, Fawcett’s reputed grandson is “paraded around Brazil like a carnival attraction” (277). Afterward, when the world’s curiosity wanes, Dulipe is “abandoned on the streets of Cuiaba,” where he succumbs to alcoholism (278). Meanwhile, in the Kalapalo village, Vanite Kalapalo informs Vajuvi that workers constructing a hydroelectric dam have blown up a sacred waterfall. Vanite fears that the project will destroy the river and the Kalapalos along with it. Grann notes that his “search for Fawcett and the City of Z suddenly felt trivial” (288).

Fawcett’s story and the story of Indigenous Amazonia converge in the person of Michael Heckenberger. An accomplished archaeologist so sympathetic to the Kuikuros that he has been adopted into their tribe, Heckenberger serves as a scholarly counterweight to John Hemming, Grann’s fiercest critic. Heckenberger admits to being “fascinated” by Fawcett (310). Furthermore, Heckenberger’s work confirms that Fawcett, whatever his shortcomings, had read the evidence correctly. Pinage summarizes: “Poor Fawcett—he was so close” (312). Finally, Heckenberger’s discovery of 20 pre-Columbian settlements, laid out in geometric patterns, connected by the kind of roads Fawcett envisioned, has settled the debate about ancient Amazonia and demolished the environmental-determinist argument that no advanced civilization could have existed in the jungle. This, Grann suggests, is the real Z.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text