70 pages • 2 hours read
Edith WhartonA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Selden’s library is unchanged since that September day two years earlier, but the shaded lamps and little fire on the hearth give it a sweeter intimacy in the early evening. Lily tells a surprised Selden that she was sorry for how they had parted that day at Mrs. Hatch’s. Lily explains that she left Mrs. Hatch soon afterward but she had not admitted to Selden that she understood what he meant about the unsuitability of the situation.
Selden gently offers her tea, seeing Lily’s tiredness. Lily sheds a few tears, but refuses the tea, saying she must leave in a moment. Lily notices a constraint in Selden and views herself as forever shut out from his innermost feelings. However, she feels that “whether he wished it or not, he must see her wholly for once before they parted” (324). Lily tells him that she has never forgotten the things he said to her at Bellomont and that his comments had kept her from mistakes—from becoming what many people thought her to be. Lily reveals to Selden that she knows that once or twice he gave her the chance to escape from her life, but that she refused because of cowardice. When she realized her error, it was too late. Lily needed the help of Selden’s belief in her—that she would never be satisfied with a mercenary life—to be able to resist temptation. Lily thanks him and tell him that she has tried hard, but “what can one do when one finds that one only fits into one hole?” (325).
Selden abruptly asks if Lily intends to marry. She answers that she will have to do it soon, but first she must say goodbye to the Lily Selden knew and leave her with him. Selden asks if he can help Lily. Lily responds that he helped her by loving her for a moment, but that she let that moment go. Although Lily killed the love in him, her love for him was kindled by it. She realizes that she cannot proceed and leave her old self with him. Concerned, Selden asks her what is going to happen. Her tone changes and Lily tells him that she is very cold. He tosses more wood upon the fire and realizes how thin she looks. He hardly notices when Lily takes something from her dress and drops it into the fire. He is groping for the right word to speak when Lily says goodbye to him and kisses his forehead.
Lily walks on until she rests on a bench, exhausted. Lily is troubled by the fact that the bottle of choral she uses to induce sleep at night is diminishing in power. She recalls the chemist’s warning against taking too much of the drug, yet she dreads another sleepless night. A young woman, Nettie Struther, passes by the bench and recognizes Lily. While helping Gerty’s charity for working girls, Lily provided the money to send Nettie to a sanitorium in the mountains when she had a lung illness. Nettie greatly admires Lily and was worried about not seeing Lily’s name in the newspapers for a long time. Now the previously frail Nettie is healthy and hopeful.
Nettie is concerned that Lily is sick. Nettie persuades Lily to come to her warm kitchen while she prepares supper for her baby. After being abandoned by a man, Nettie married George whom she had grown up with; she is thriving because of his love. Lily enjoys holding Nettie’s baby before promising to visit again.
Lily feels that the time with Nettie has done her good. In her own room, Lily decides to examine her remaining dresses, recalling the pleasant associations they evoked—she was “like some rare flower grown for exhibition, a flower from which every bud had been nipped except the crowning blossom of her beauty” (334). When Lily views the dress that she wore for the Bry tableaux, she recalls a fateful moment with Selden. She puts the clothing away in her trunk.
A business letter arrives from her aunt’s executors containing her legacy, a $10,000 check, paid earlier than expected. When Lily figures up her unpaid debts, she will barely have enough to live on for the next few months after settling her bills. In addition to her material impoverishment, Lily has a deeper sense of destitution, “the feeling of being something rootless and ephemeral” (336). She was raised without any place being dearer to her than another and without any inherited traditions from which to draw strength. For Lily, Nettie Struther grasped the central truth, building a life that “had the frail audacious permanence of a bird’s nest built on the edge of a cliff” (337). Two built the nest: Nettie’s husband had faith in her and that gave Nettie courage. Lily felt that Selden twice offered his faith in her, but the third trial was too difficult for him.
Afraid of the temptation of tolerating Gus’s debt, Lily writes the check to repay Gus before she goes to bed. She encloses the executors’ check in another envelope to her bank. When Lily wearily tries to sleep, her entire past is reenacting itself. She yearns for relief and increases the dose of the drug. Her unhappiness leaves and she senses the warmth of Nettie Struther’s child lying on her arm. Lily feels that there is a word she must tell Selden to make life clear between them, but sleep enfolds her.
Selden joyfully hastens to Lily’s boarding house at nine o’clock in the morning. The hour is early for a visit, but Selden needs to see Lily at once because he has found “the word” (342) he wants to say to her. He was unable to speak it the night before, but now he has “cut loose from the familiar shores of habit and launched himself on uncharted seas of emotion; all the old tests and measures were left behind, and his course was to be shaped by new stars” (342). Surprisingly, his cousin Gerty opens the boarding house door. Gerty exclaims in a strange voice when she sees Selden, asking how he could arrive so quickly. Selden notices fear on people’s faces and hears someone speak about the doctor returning at any minute. Gerty gently takes Selden’s hand and leads him up three flights of stairs to Lily’s room.
Lily is dead in her narrow bed. Gerty tells the shocked Selden that Lily was having trouble sleeping for a long time and that she must have mistakenly taken an overdose of the sedative, chloral. Selden feels that the real Lily is still there yet inaccessible to him behind an invisible barrier. Recognizing Selden’s love for Lily, Gerty tenderly leaves him alone with her, telling him that the doctor will return in a half hour to complete the formalities.
Although his impulse is to kneel next to Lily’s bed, Selden realizes that he must go through Lily’s effects. He finds two letters on her desk. One stamped, sealed letter is addressed to her bank. The other letter, not yet sealed, is addressed to Gus Trenor. The sight of the second letter’s address throws Selden back into doubts about Lily. Tempted to read the letter, Selden decides against it. When Selden opens Lily’s desk, he sees that Lily preserved the note Selden wrote to her. He realizes that his own cowardice caused him to flee from her when they might have come together. Selden is surprised to discover that Lily settled all her bills. In Lily’s checkbook, he finds that she received her aunt’s legacy, but that Lily used almost all of it in a check to Gus Trenor. Selden finally understands that Lily received money from Trenor. This debt was intolerable to her, and she freed herself from it as soon as possible, even though this action left her in poverty.
Selden comprehends that his detachment from the external influences that affected Lily made him more critical of her. They loved each other even if the moment passed before they could unite. Selden’s faith in Lily is still alive and he penitently kisses her, conveying the love that clarifies everything.
In striking contrast to the novel’s opening chapter, when Selden and Lily enjoyed witty banter in his apartment, Lily’s second visit to his rooms in Chapter 12 is marked by her wish to be fully understood by Selden and avoid such wordplay and emotional evasion. Selden is unprepared for this evolution of Lily’s spirit; he does not notice her decision to burn Bertha’s letters rather than use them, nor does he fully appreciate the depth of her confession when Lily states that she has realized her mistakes and values his criticisms that helped her avoid making more errors. The pair stand solemnly as if in the presence of death and it appears as if Lily’s previous rebuffs have killed Selden’s love for her. Selden is still groping for the right word to say when Lily departs.
A moment of hope is provided when the exhausted Lily sits on a bench and attracts the attention of Nettie Struther, a poor working girl who benefited from Lily’s brief act of charity in the past. The young women’s positions have reversed: the once frail and despairing Nettie is now alive with hope and energy, although poor. Ironically, Nettie’s admiration for the beautiful Lily in the former society pages had given her a sense that there was a kind of justice somewhere. When Nettie takes the ailing Lily to her warm, clean tenement, Lily discovers that the love of a husband and a baby renewed Nettie’s life. While Lily is temporarily cheered by the sense of human fellowship, she experiences a deeper sense of inner impoverishment when she returns to her boarding house room. Images of rootlessness and spinning atoms convey Lily’s sense of disconnection. For Lily, the example of Nettie’s creation of a family is like a bird’s nest built on a cliff’s edge—frail, but safely sheltering against life’s hardships. However, Lily notes it took both a woman’s courage and a man’s faith in her. Lily believes that Selden’s faith in her has been forever shattered and she sees a future of emptiness before her.
When the $10,000 legacy from her aunt’s estate unexpectedly arrives, Lily quickly writes a check to repay Gus, terrified of giving into the temptation of old habits. Lily wishes her life to end while she is acting as her noblest self. Ambiguous language is deliberately used when portraying Lily’s final use of the drug chloral, so it cannot be ascertained whether Lily intended only to sleep or to commit suicide. As Lily drifts into sleep, she no longer feels alone as she experiences the illusion that she is holding Nettie’s baby in the way that Gerty once held Lily to comfort her. This image represents Lily comforting her own core self as a child. As Lily passes into unconsciousness, she recalls that she must tell Selden some word to make life clear between them.
Selden’s evolution is sparked by Lily’s evolution: The next morning he has found the word he meant to say to Lily. However, he arrives at her boarding house too late. The novel’s tragic effect is heightened with Selden’s observation of Lily’s orderly settlement of bills in the face of her certain destitution. The knowledge that Lily tried hard to have integrity despite her hereditary and environmental influences, with her gender’s limited resources in the business world, makes her a heroic figure. In the final chapters, realism is combined with romance as Lily’s harsh decline in an unjust society is paired with Selden’s love for Lily and hers for him is portrayed as triumphant over death.
By Edith Wharton
American Literature
View Collection
Appearance Versus Reality
View Collection
Art
View Collection
Beauty
View Collection
Books that Feature the Theme of...
View Collection
Challenging Authority
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Community
View Collection
Equality
View Collection
Friendship
View Collection
Historical Fiction
View Collection
Marriage
View Collection
Naturalism
View Collection
Nature Versus Nurture
View Collection
Power
View Collection
Pride & Shame
View Collection
Required Reading Lists
View Collection
Satire
View Collection
School Book List Titles
View Collection
Trust & Doubt
View Collection
Truth & Lies
View Collection
Valentine's Day Reads: The Theme of Love
View Collection