logo

49 pages 1 hour read

Margaret Atwood

The Heart Goes Last

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2015

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 12-15Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 12 Summary: “Escort”

Stan hangs around the Elvisorium playing poker and talking to the other guys. With one of the regulars out, he gets assigned an escort job that evening. He is told it involves going to dinner and a show, and if the client wants more, they send in an Elvis possibilibot.

While Stan is out exploring the town, four bald men come looking for him at the Elvisorium. Stan believes they must have been sent by Ed, and that the safest thing for him to do is remain in crowds with lots of other people. The client for his escort job is Lucinda Quant, who is in town for a broadcast convention. He meets her at her hotel and then the two take a taxi to the show. Lucinda immediately likes Stan, and they exchange small talk. They arrive at the show and there is no sign of the bald men that were looking for him earlier.

Ed has still not returned to work and Charmaine has very little to do. Aurora stays with her for the weekend and the two bond over several drinks. Aurora reveals that the reason she came to Consilience was because her face got scraped off in an accident and they offered to give her an experimental face transplant. Charmaine realizes they must have gotten the face from one of the procedure victims. Aurora also reveals that they no longer use the procedure much anymore, and instead perform the neurosurgery that makes them imprint on people. Jocelyn has promised Aurora that she can have one of these people, once they find the right match.

The next day, Jocelyn informs Charmaine that things are moving forward. Ed plans to take her with him on a trip to Las Vegas, with Jocelyn accompanying them as security. She shows Charmaine footage from a recent boardroom meeting, where Ed pitches his investors on the neurosurgical procedure as a solution to the fact that the possibilibots can never fully replicate a real human being. He uses the term “requisition” to describe the process of kidnapping desirable targets for the procedure. Jocelyn believes that Ed is taking Charmaine to Las Vegas because he plans to have the procedure done on her.

Chapter 13 Summary: “Green Man”

The show Stan and Lucinda go to see is the Green Man Group—an eco-themed spinoff of the Blue Man Group. During the show, they do a rendition of “Tiptoe Through the Tulips,” which catches Stan’s attention because that was the password for his contact in the possibilibots facility. However, he brushes it off as a coincidence. After the show, while Lucinda is in the bathroom, Veronica shows up dressed as Marilyn Monroe. She takes him backstage to the Green Man Group dressing room and tells him to wait there for the contact and handover.

After a few minutes, there is a knock at the door, and Lucinda walks in. She demands his belt buckle and tells Stan that breaking this story is going to be her big comeback. She quickly leaves and Stan is left wondering what he is supposed to do next when four green bald men file in. They reveal themselves as Conor and Budge and explain that they went looking for him earlier to save some time. Conor has been working with Jocelyn since before Stan signed up at Consilience—she even saw Stan at Conor’s trailer and knew the two were related. Conor explains that Stan is to join them on a job the next day: They are going into Ruby Slippers Retirement Home with the Green Man Group as their cover, and while they put on a fake show, they are going to snatch somebody.

Charmaine is relieved she is not asked to fly in Business beside Ed. She does not feel like she could hide her anger and disgust at him anymore, knowing his plan. Jocelyn is beside her and works for most of the flight. When they are nearly in Las Vegas, Charmaine asks for the details of Ed’s plan. Jocelyn orders them food and drinks before explaining everything: Jocelyn would slip a sedative into Charmaine’s drink, and then tell the flight attendant to call an ambulance claiming she had fainted. The ambulance would then take her to the clinic at Ruby Slippers, where they would perform the neurosurgery on her. Ed would be there when she wakes up so that she imprints on him. Charmaine begins to feel woozy during the explanation and realizes that she has been drugged.

Chapter 14 Summary: “Snatch”

Conor’s Green Man Group have the necessary passes to get into the Ruby Slippers Retirement Home. They start a rambunctious show in the atrium and wait for the moment to act. When they hear an ambulance coming up the driveway, Budge and Conor’s henchmen sneak off while Stan hits the gong. A few moments later, Conor and Stan bow and leave the atrium. They make their way to the ambulance, which is parked near the clinic, passing several incapacitated security guards and employees. Jocelyn, Phil, and Aurora are in the ambulance, along with Ed, who is slumped on the ground. Stan finally notices that Charmaine is there too, unconscious on a stretcher.

While this is happening, Lucinda breaks the story on the six o’ clock news. She has extensive evidence and expertly lays out what is happening inside the Positron Project. Social media is set ablaze, and every news and talk show on TV discusses the leak, with people arguing for both sides.

Stan waits for Charmaine to wake from the anesthesia. She has had the neurosurgical procedure done, so that when she wakes, she and Stan can have a fresh start. Jocelyn explains that it is her gift to the two of them for all the help they provided in leaking the story. Phil also undergoes the procedure, as he and Jocelyn are getting a divorce. He imprints on Aurora, who is thrilled.

With the story out, some of the culprits start getting rounded up. Ed’s arrest is imminent, but the media is told that Ed has had a stroke and is undergoing emergency brain surgery. In reality, Ed is undergoing the neurosurgical procedure, with Lucinda ready to pounce when he wakes up. Jocelyn explains that she cannot afford to have him arrested, because that would bring her and a number of prominent political figures down, too. Instead, she is sending him to Dubai, where he cannot be extradited. Lucinda, who worries her cancer could come back any day, just wants to live whatever time she has left to the fullest and can do this with Ed as her devoted boy toy.

The UR-ELF Elvises host a double wedding for Aurora and Max, and Stan and Charmaine (to renew their vows). Charmaine cannot believe her luck and is incredibly happy to have Stan back. However, she does have some doubts: She questions if it is right that her happiness comes from a medical procedure she did not agree to have, and if her love counts if she cannot help it. Jocelyn does not attend the wedding, but she shows up to the reception with Conor. She tells Charmaine she has a wedding gift for her, but that it will not be ready for another year, so she will drop by again at that point to give it to her. Charmaine wonders whether Jocelyn and Conor are an item, but Stan is sure that they must be.

Chapter 15 Summary: “There”

Stan has a new job working at a possibilibots production facility in Las Vegas. His current task is to perfect the grin on the line of Elvis bots. He and Charmaine have a three-month-old baby named Winnie, after Charmaine’s Grandma Win. They are happily married, and Stan has never been more satisfied with his sex life.

A year after the wedding, Jocelyn shows up to deliver her promised gift. She tells Charmaine the gift is a piece of information about her, but that she can choose not to hear it if she does not want to, as hearing it will make her freer, but less secure. She decides she wants to hear it, and Jocelyn reveals that she never had the procedure done to her, and that she is not compelled to love Stan. The revelation upsets Charmaine, as it upsets the life she has settled into. For a moment, she considers finding a Max-like person in the future, but quickly brushes the thought aside.

Chapters 12-15 Analysis

The Elvisorium exists as a kind of photo-negative version of the dystopia that is Consilience. While not traditionally utopian—its conditions are far from perfect—the ideals it embodies are utopian in the sense that it is a community striving to be the best it can be for all its members. While there is a CEO, Rob, the business is run in a much more egalitarian way: jobs are shared around, employees help coach one another in areas they are less confident in, and the primary goal is ensuring everyone makes enough money to get by. This also makes UR-ELF a more sustainable business, thus avoiding The Pitfalls of Capitalism. Pete, the man that handles the books, explains that “UR-ELF is making a profit […] because they keep overheads low” (543). They do not live lavishly—they eat cheap meals and sleep in small cots, but they get by.

This is in stark contrast to Consilience, where Ed and his investors essentially initiate the project's downfall by pursuing more and more profit, despite the fact they were already “raking it in” (578). The juxtaposition goes beyond power structures and money, however. Where Consilience is “relentlessly hetero,” sexuality at the Elvisorium exists on a spectrum, with gay, straight, bi, and asexual members (426). Perhaps most importantly, the collective is always put first. This is best exemplified in the fact that when they gamble, they do not play for real money. Living in Las Vegas means they have all seen people lose everything at the casinos. Gambling addiction is not an affliction that affects everyone, so their choice to collectively abstain from gambling for the sake of those it might, demonstrates an awareness and consideration for other people that is completely absent in Consilience.

By this point in the text, Atwood has firmly established that the society in the novel is segregated based on wealth. The depiction of Ed and his investors in their board meeting is particularly disagreeable, underscoring the effect of this segregation: They are so divorced from the reality that Ed’s pitch for kidnapping and enslaving people generates questions about its efficacy rather than any moral objections. To them, everything is a resource to be exploited and turned into profit. Individuals with memories, relationships, and dreams for the future become entities to be targeted and requisitioned to satisfy someone's power fantasy while making the rich even richer.

Most disturbing is the revelation that even after the Positron Project is brought down, Ed and everyone else responsible for the harm it caused evade legal consequence. In this wealth-segregated society, the poor go to prison, while the atrocity-committing rich go free with impunity. While Ed’s fate of becoming the hapless sex toy for the aging Lucinda is ironically fitting, the idea that he will otherwise live a life of luxury in Dubai rings a little too close to reality to be comical.

As the novel winds down, there is increasing talk of the fairy-tale endings that will result from the neurosurgical procedure that forces the patient to imprint on someone, revisiting the theme of The Tension Between Love and Passion. This suggestion sets up what initially appears to be a fairy tale for the protagonists: Stan rescues Charmaine from the grasp of Ed, she undergoes the procedure, and all past mistakes are forgiven. They even magically escape the financial apocalypse that had previously ensnared them: They move to Las Vegas, Stan gets a new job, they have a home and a baby, and both of them are ostensibly happier than they have ever been.

However, things are literally too good to be true, and Atwood is merely toying with the idea of happy endings. Jocelyn’s revelation that Charmaine did not actually undergo the procedure is her way of finally giving Charmaine agency—something she is reluctant to accept because it also comes with a heavy dose of responsibility. By taking away Charmaine’s “fairy-tale” ending in this way, Atwood highlights the way these types of endings often rob female characters of agency. In a text that has consistently presented the characters with the choice between freedom and security, ending with an open question, rather than closure, suggests which of the two Atwood ultimately endorses. 

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text