74 pages • 2 hours read
Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, John JayA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summary
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Key Figures
Themes
Index of Terms
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Tools
Born circa 1757 on the Caribbean island of Nevis, Alexander Hamilton was a lawyer, military commander, and statesman who was instrumental in convincing the Congress of the Confederation to draft a new Constitution. After serving as one of 55 delegates at the 1787 Constitutional Convention, Hamilton wrote 51 of the 85 installments of what would become known as The Federalist Papers.
While scholars consistently look to The Federalist Papers to divine Hamilton’s personal and political views on a wide range of subjects, his beliefs and philosophy are not easily reducible. At times, Hamilton speaks at great length about the people’s capacity to be led astray by their passions, spurred toward factionalist infighting or dangerous and tyrannical demagogues. This, combined with Hamilton’s dismissive attitude toward the inclusion of a bill of rights in the Constitution, has led some observers to describe Hamilton as anti-egalitarian or even anti-democratic. Yet he also wholeheartedly supported the direct election of House representatives by the people, a cornerstone of representative democracy. Hamilton also faced charges by his contemporaries and later historians of being a monarchist, given his support of a strong federal executive branch led by an “energetic” individual person. Yet his devotion to republicanism is seen in the checks he supports on the executive branch, which limit the powers of the President compared to those belonging to contemporary European monarchs. Hamilton’s least ambiguous views concern his steadfast beliefs in a central government strong enough to protect the nation from foreign and domestic threats, and a method of collecting federal revenue that allows the government to fulfill those duties.
After the ratification of the Constitution, Hamilton served under President George Washington as the United States’ first Secretary of the Treasury. In that role, he established the first de facto national bank, advantageous trade agreements with Great Britain, and a system for collecting tariffs. His hopes of someday becoming President himself were severely curtailed when he became embroiled in the 1797 Reynolds affair, which scholars point to as the first political sex scandal in American history.
By 1800, national politics had become dominated by two major parties: the Federalist Party, to which Hamilton belonged, and the Democratic-Republican Party, which arose in large part as a response to Hamilton’s increasingly centralized policies and perceived aristocracy. Yet despite the fact that Thomas Jefferson was one of the founders—along with Madison—of the Democratic-Republican Party, Hamilton devoted considerable political capital toward ensuring Jefferson’s election over second-place finisher Aaron Burr. This deepened a rift between Hamilton and Burr which culminated in an 1804 duel, in which Burr shot and killed Hamilton before he reached the age of 50.
Born in 1751 in the Colony of Virginia, James Madison was a lawyer and slaveholder who played an extraordinarily pivotal role in drafting the US Constitution. In addition to his serving as one of the 55 delegates to the Constitutional Convention, Madison’s Virginia Plan set the agenda for the Convention’s deliberations, in that it proposed three branches of government, a bicameral legislature, and proportional representation of the states based on population. Madison wrote 29 essays in The Federalist Papers, including Federalist No. 10, a forceful and persuasive condemnation of factionalism; and Federalist No. 51, which elegantly lays out the system of checks and balances between the three branches of government.
Based on a comparison between his essays and Hamilton’s, the two were largely unified in their political and philosophical views at the time of the Constitution’s proposed ratification. The biggest ideological differences between the two men can be found in Madison’s less positive appraisal of a standing army during peacetime. Moreover, Hamilton left Madison to represent the slaveholders’ interest in The Federalist Papers, given that Hamilton opposed slavery—albeit not in any way that was central to his political philosophy. Madison’s views on slavery, meanwhile, were contradictory. Although he describes the slave trade as “barbarism” in Federalist No. 42 and elsewhere acknowledges that slavery is inconsistent with republican principles, he owned enslaved people most of his life as the scion of a prominent Virginia planter family.
While serving in Washington’s administration as a close advisor, a rift developed between Madison and Hamilton over the latter’s efforts to increase the power of the federal government through the founding of a national bank. Along with Thomas Jefferson, Madison founded the Democratic-Republican Party in opposition to Hamilton’s Federalist Party. Madison went on to serve as President Jefferson’s Secretary of State from 1801 until 1808 before becoming President himself in 1809. That same year, friendly relations with Great Britain collapsed, leading to the War of 1812. As America emerged from that conflict victorious but far from unscathed, Madison ushered in “The Era of Good Feelings,” during which Madison achieved a detente with the Federalist Party. For the rest of his presidency, Madison took on many initiatives—including the reestablishment of the national bank—that caused Virginia politician John Randolph to observe that Madison “out-Hamiltons Alexander Hamilton.”
After his Presidency, Madison remained only tangentially involved in national politics. He died in 1836 at the age of 85.
John Jay was a lawyer and diplomat who, at the time of The Federalist Papers’ writing, served as the Secretary of Foreign Affairs of the Articles of Confederation. Born in 1745 to a prominent family of New York merchants, Jay was very active in organizing opposition against oppressive British policies in the years and months prior to the Revolutionary War.
Although he was not a delegate to the Constitutional Convention, Jay brought his firsthand experience serving in various diplomatic roles to the task of writing five essays in The Federalist Papers. Four of the essays concern the “dangers of foreign force and influence.” Jay also contributed an essay on the Senate’s role in making treaties.
Jay went on to serve as the first Chief Justice of the Supreme Court and later as the second Governor of New York. He died in 1829 at the age of 83.