The Cop and the Anthem

Analyze the ways in which O. Henry characterizes Soapy (his name, his nonviolent nature, his sense of himself as a “gentleman,” etc.). Why is this important in conveying O. Henry’s message?

How does O. Henry use imagery to convey the realities of life as an unhoused person in turn-of-the-century New York City?

What underlying social commentary is O. Henry making about the lower class/underprivileged? Explain with textual support.

Several of the people Soapy interacts with, including the man from whom he steals the umbrella and the woman he propositions, are implied to be on the “wrong” side of the law as well. What is the story’s overall message about the nature of crime and “criminals”?

“The Cop and the Anthem” has been made into various plays, movies, and skits. Watch some clips based on this story and compare and contrast the directors’/actors’ portrayals of Soapy with O. Henry’s.

Is the “cop” in the title referring to the final cop who arrests Soapy or the proverbial “cop” Soapy chases throughout the story? What is the overall significance of the title? Explain your reasoning.

Discuss this story’s connection to the “American dream.” Does the story suggest this dream is attainable for Soapy? Why or why not?

Compare “The Cop and the Anthem” to another O. Henry story with an ironic ending (e.g., “The Gift of the Magi”). What purpose does irony serve in each story?