logo

53 pages 1 hour read

Jane Goodall, Douglas Abrams

The Book of Hope: A Survival Guide for Trying Times

Nonfiction | Autobiography / Memoir | Adult | Published in 2021

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 2, Chapters 4-5Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 2: “Jane’s Four Reasons for Hope”

Part 2, Chapter 4 Summary: “Reason 3: The Power of Young People”

Content Warning: This section of the guide discusses rape, genocide, child soldiers, abuse, and animal abuse.

Jane talks about how she began to work with young people. When she started traveling around talking about her work, she met disillusioned young people who felt—rightly, she thought—that their future was stolen by previous generations’ disregard for the planet. Jane wanted to help them understand that there is something they can do, if people act within a certain window of time.

She started Roots and Shoots with 12 local Tanzanian children who came to her with concerns about their local communities and environments. With her help, they set up groups, who each made three projects—to benefit people, animals, and environment. They were mocked at first but the grassroots movement spread. Roots and Shoots became a global movement active in 86 countries. 

Jane thinks all children can be motivated and passionate about environmental activism. Especially in impoverished communities, Jane finds that encouraging disadvantaged children to exercise the power of their voice and telling them that their opinion matters has been effective.

Love in a Hopeless Place

Jane tells a story about an encounter with a man named Robert White Mountain in 2005, after she spoke in New York. Robert’s son died by suicide; they live in an area with high rates of death by suicide in Indigenous communities. Jane visits their reservation community and is shocked by the immense income inequality and unemployment. Since then, she’s tried to establish programs on reservations. 

So far, she’s only succeeded in setting up one, at Pine Ridge Reservation, on Oglala Lakota land, where youth are regrowing the “three sister” crops: squash, corn, and beans. Youth who joined Roots and Shoots largely graduated high school and went to university. At another Roots and Shoots group at a Tanzanian refugee camp for Congolese people, the hens, roosters, and gardens Roots and Shoots provided completely altered the morale of refugees.

“I Don’t Want Your Hope”

Doug asks Jane what she thinks about a speech Greta Thunberg gave critiquing hope and demanding action. Jane agrees with Greta’s assessment about the direness of the environmental crisis, but thinks we need hope, anger, and fear all together to act. While Jane gets angry when people put the responsibility solely on future generations, she thinks kids can inspire their parents and grandparents to embrace climate activism.

She recalls a letter from a mother of a young girl from Chengdu who heard Jane speak and was motivated to start a local Roots and Shoots group. The girl, Joy, learned English to communicate with Jane and they stayed in contact. Joy is 18 and works on environmental causes in local government.

Millions of Drops Make an Ocean

Doug asks what it is about young people that gives Jane hope. Jane thinks young people in the 21st century are more educated and engaged about these issues than ever before. Doug is skeptical that youth activism can change things when most people in power are older; Jane hopes that the power of voting will change the balance of power. She lists some Roots and Shoots alumni who are going on to work as government officials, journalists, teachers, and business people.

Doug asks Jane what her message is to youth who live in countries where they aren’t free to demonstrate against their government; she asks those people to hold onto hope for a better future even if it can’t be realized at this moment.

Nurturing the Future

Doug can’t help but think about the world’s social bias, hierarchy, and oppression. He asks Jane how we can change entrenched views. Jane is honest about not knowing, though she targets the support of parents as an important aspect for raising children who are mindful of others and the surrounding world. Jane “learned from the chimps” (135) about the importance of early childhood and supportive parental figures in determining future success and confidence. 

She recalls a letter she received from a teen girl in juvenile detention, who had a substance abuse problem and no support. The girl found one of Jane’s books in the facility’s library and thought “Jane can be my mother” (137) because of the support she felt from the pages. Doug tells a story of a hope researcher named Chan Hellman who, as a child, was neglected and contemplated death by suicide until he thought about the one teacher who supported him. Doug sees that hope might be a survival trait, but it must be nurtured. 

Jane tells a story about a Roots and Shoots group in Burundi, which experienced a genocide at the same time as Rwanda but received no resources. The group was started by a group of ex-child soldiers and women who had been raped; they all wanted to help their community heal from trauma. Jane still receives letters from the community telling her how the program brought people together in cooperation and rewilded the areas with trees.

Part 2, Chapter 5 Summary: “Reason 4: The Indomitable Human Spirit”

The next morning, Jane and Doug meet to discuss her final reason for hope. First, Doug wants to know how she defines “spirit.” She says it will differ for everyone, but for her it’s a connection she feels to “great spiritual power” when in nature (143). Next, he asks what she means by humanity’s “indomitable” spirit. Jane says this references our perseverance in tackling goals that seem impossible, without giving up. She lists Martin Luther King Jr., Nelson Mandela, Ken Saro-Wiwa, Winston Churchill, and Mahatma Gandhi as examples. There are many more lesser-known people who persevere through adversity daily.

When I Decide to Climb Everest

Jane notes that animals also have a will to live in life-threatening situations. In humans, this spirit involves human intellect, imagination, hope, determination, and resilience. Doug tells a story about his grandfather, who lost his leg as a boy. He went on to be a ballroom dancer, tennis player, neurosurgeon, and educated World War II amputees on living full lives. Jane tells a story of her late husband Derek, who was partially paralyzed in World War II but learned to walk again through “sheer willpower.”

Doug thinks we can take traumatic incidents and use them as “curriculum” to grow. They talk about several more examples, including Doug’s son and Jane’s friend Chris Koch.

The Spirit That Never Surrenders

Jane talks about living through World War II. She recalls Churchill’s speeches as a source of hope for the British people during the Battle of Britain. Jane and Doug recall instances of how disaster brings out the heroic, self-sacrificing sides of people.

They then recall examples of people who have stood up to their own governments about the unjust circumstances they live under, like citizens in Tiananmen Square, early suffragettes in England, and Standing Rock Sioux protesting the construction of a pipeline on their land. Jane thinks people could take this spirit and apply it to fighting climate change, if they realized the seriousness of the problem.

Nurturing the Indomitable Spirit in Children

Jane and Doug begin to discuss how resilience affects the human spirit, especially when nurtured by parental figures. Jane recalls how this affects chimps as well. Chimps who are abused when young and deprived of love are often traumatized and untrusting for the rest of their lives, while ones who experience support subsequent to trauma recover. 

How the Indomitable Human Spirit Helps Us Heal

Jane finds that many people turn to her for hope and inspiration. Jane recounts an experience with someone she calls “Anne.” Anne and Jane began to write letters about Anne’s sister, who’d gone missing more than 30 years prior. They struck up a series of phone conversations and Jane began to suspect Anne had “developed multiple personalities” to deal with the extreme trauma of a childhood of sexual abuse and the disappearance of her sister (164). Jane wrote to a doctor qualified to treat Anne and together they helped Anne, who is now in recovery. Doug thinks Jane gave Anne hope in her future.

We Need Each Other

Jane talks about how support systems can help us maintain hope. She tells a story of two young men in rural China, both of whom had disabilities. One had lost both arms and the other was blind. They decided to rewild their area, while serving as each other’s “arms” and “eyes.” They’ve now planted over 10,000 trees.

Jane also thinks we can turn to fictional stories for examples of indomitable spirit, like that of the characters Sam and Frodo in The Lord of the Rings. Sam worked to restore the environments of Middle-earth after they were “polluted by destructive industry” (170).

They part in December 2019, with plans for one more meeting and no knowledge of the approaching global pandemic.

Part 2, Chapters 4-5 Analysis

Jane and Doug continue to discuss Jane’s reasons for hope. These last two reasons revolve around empowering young people and fostering supportive community, which reflects the theme of The Significance of Youth Activism and Education. Jane’s optimism about saving environments lives alongside frustration, especially when it comes to how people treat youth. She says it “makes [her] angry when people say it will be up to young people to solve” the climate crisis (127). Jane’s mission is to “support them, encourage them, empower them, listen to them, and educate them” (127). Rather than displacing responsibility for addressing the climate crisis onto future generations entirely, Jane shows up for young people in tangible ways: She provides them with material support like resources and intangible support like education. She empowers them to realize that they matter and embraces her role as a supportive parent-like figure, especially in the lives of disadvantaged children.

Jane thinks that “hope” is not an isolated emotion, and it is not mutually exclusive from emotions like eco-grief—especially for young people. They discuss Greta Thunberg, the young climate activist from Sweden who said, “I don’t want your hope. I don’t want you to feel hopeful. I want you to panic. I want you to feel the fear I feel every day, and then I want you to act” (127). Jane’s takeaway from Greta’s words is, “we do need to respond with fear and anger about what is happening […] our house is on fire” (127). However, she differs from Greta in that she thinks hope, fear, and anger can all co-exist and motivate people to work against the climate crisis. Jane acknowledges the bleak circumstances Doug’s realism focuses on, but she continues to have an optimistic view of what humans are willing to do to save the planet.

However, she acknowledges that children—who often embody hope better than adults—do not always have the resources they need to create change. Jane uses her relative privilege to provide all types of communities with tangible and intangible resources they need to apply their hope and turn it into action. Jane provides help to young people via her youth program, Roots and Shoots. One story she tells takes place in a section of the Bronx. Most students’ families were involved in gang and drug violence. It was the first time Jane presented Roots and Shoots outside of Africa and she didn’t know if it could resonate in a non-rural area. She told them about the plight of chimps and the environment more broadly. She told them that “they can make a difference. That the world needs them. Above all, that they matter” (116). They were so inspired they invited Jane back the next year to show her a presentation on banning Styrofoam in their schools, an initiative they later succeeded in. Jane sees how her education, inspiration, and support changed these children’s’ lives, and how the children began changing their community.

A story she tells about how her tangible support helped a youth community takes place in a Congolese refugee camp in Tanzania. Roots and Shoots provided resources for “organic vegetable gardening, hairdressing, cooking, and raising chickens” (124). A later visitor to the refugee camp commented on its “depressing” atmosphere, with “children sitting listlessly” and people with “vacant” and hollow expressions (125). When the visitor got to the sections of the camp which had opted to partner with Roots and Shoots, “the atmosphere changed” (125): Children ran and laughed, teens worked in garden beds and hens foraged bugs from patches of grass. This anecdote shows how Jane’s initiative provided physical resources for a community, who showed initiative in using those resources to drastically improve their quality of life while living under terrible circumstances.

Jane tells Doug that many youths she works with experience similar hardship and have been “horribly abused” (162), which it is difficult for either Jane or Doug to personally relate to. Jane uses her research on the similarity between humans and chimps to contextualize her approach to support. She says that infant chimps who experience trauma and were subsequently deprived of love never recovered, while infants who are “immediately given love and care” bounce back and live full, happy lives (162). She thinks the “indominable human spirit” can allow humans to heal in the same way if they have “social support in times of trouble” (166). Jane knows that she can provide this type of support to youth. This makes her optimistic about how she can set youth up with tangible and intangible support, so they retain hope about the future.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text