logo

36 pages 1 hour read

Margaret Atwood

Stone Mattress

Fiction | Short Story Collection | Adult | Published in 2014

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Story 3Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Story 3 Summary: “Dark Lady”

The final story in the Alphinland trilogy is “Dark Lady.” It introduces readers to aging twins Jorrie and Tin Maeve. Like an old married couple, Jorrie and Tim live together and bicker incessantly, although it is obvious that they love and depend on each other: “Because they’re twins, they can be who they really are with each other, a thing they haven’t managed very well with anyone else” (78).

Jorrie and Tin shared a dark childhood. Their father was killed in war and their mother drank, entertaining a range of men in the home in which she raised her children. Mother Maeve, as the twins called her, died when a bus hit her as she crossed the street coming home from a bar.

Jorrie reads obituaries daily. She calls out the printed euphemisms. “Peacefully, at home, of natural causes,” she reads. “I doubt that very much! I bet it was an overdose” (75). She enjoys going to funerals whether she knew the person before their death or not. One morning, Jorrie reads about the death of an old lover: Gavin Putnam, the poet. Jorrie knew Gavin when they were younger, and she always believed that Gavin’s most celebrated poem, “Dark Lady,” was about her.

Tin accompanies Jorrie to Gavin’s funeral, where they see Gavin’s widow, Reynolds. Of Reynolds, Jorrie says, “She looks about twelve. Gav was such a perv” (105). During the services, Tin and Jorrie look for Constance Starr, Gavin’s former girlfriend who dumped the poet when she found him in bed with Jorrie. They know Constance is the author of Alphinland, a bestselling fantasy series written under the pseudonym C.W. Starr. Although the twins assume she is not going to show up, Constance arrives to pay her respects: “Constance W. Starr is clutching an egg salad sandwich in one hand and a glass of water in the other. She looks beleaguered and wary” (112).

Jorrie and Tin watch as Naveena approaches Constance with an onslaught of questions about Alphinland. Unsure if Constance will recognize her, Jorrie joins the women. At first, Constance addresses Jorrie sternly. Yet when she finds out that Gavin left Jorrie and that Jorrie didn’t steal Gavin away from her, Constance embraces her, both physically and emotionally.

“Dark Lady” Analysis

The loss of their father impacted Tin and Jorrie’s life, influencing the way Jorrie relates to men. When thinking of their father, the twins think of a photo of him taken before he died: “Behind them is a man’s body in a uniform, it being the war: their father with the top part of his head cut off, which was shortly to happen to him in reality” (82). Not only was their father killed in a fatal explosion, showing that this photo predicted the future, but even when he was alive, Dad was never fully a part of the family.

“Dark Lady” is the culminating story of the collection’s Alphinland trilogy. When Constance finds out that Jorrie was hurt by Gavin and didn’t steal the poet away from her, she decides she must release Jorrie from her imprisonment in Alphinland. Tin thinks the scenario of the women interacting at Gavin’s service is ridiculous and hopes Jorrie will return home with them and laugh at the whole thing. Jorrie believes that the unhappiness she felt over the years is because she was imprisoned by Constance, and now Constance has set her free.

“We live in two places,” says Constance, “There isn’t any past in Alphinland. There isn’t any time. But there’s time here, where we are now. We still have a little time left” (115). Here, Constance admits that she lives in both a reality world and a fantasy world, and that others like Jorrie do, too. The women are hopeful knowing that while they are aging, there is still time left. Tin thinks, “What sort of female weirdness is going on” (116). On one hand, a reader can perceive this quote as his ability to see through the meeting of the female minds around him and thereby show that Tin is the only sane person in this group gathered at Gavin Putnam’s funeral. On the other hand, Tin, due to his gender, may be missing out on what the trio of women understand.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text