53 pages • 1 hour read
Pete HautmanA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Narrator and protagonist David Miller’s interest in competitive eating is central to the novel, and his interest guides his decision-making at every turn, from his disastrous accidental $2,000 bid on the Jooky dog to his decision to enter two eating competitions to pay off this monstrous debt. Although David succumbs to the temptation to conceal his initial mistake, he does show perseverance and dedication to his craft as he masters the sport of competitive eating and wins a $5,000 cash prize to repay his parents.
Alongside his competitive eating trials and triumphs, David’s story focuses on familial conflicts and the inner turmoil he feels about his place in as the middle child. David feels less important than his siblings because his older sister Bridgette is a perfectionist with many achievements, and his younger brother Mal has autism and requires extra attention from the family. David feels that he is “always stuck in the middle” (154), and his feelings of envy and frustration boil over when his secret $2,000 charge is brought to light in Chapter 38. David declares that he is “just here to babysit Mal” and “just this thing that happened to show up between Bridgette and Mal” (207). David’s feelings of neglect are validated by his parents after he wins Pigorino’s eating contest final and secures the money he needs to pay his parents back. David’s parents admit that he is “stuck in the middle” and “the easy one [who] never demanded much” (250). By acknowledging David’s feelings and reinforcing their love for him, David’s parents help David to work through his feelings and adopt a more mature outlook about his family dynamics.
David also has a complicated relationship with his brother, Mal. As he admits in a moment of frustration, “Sometimes Mal feels like a huge ball and chain. Sometimes I wish he didn’t exist” (68). David’s harsh feelings about Mal are a result of the responsibility that he feels to take care of his brother and the reality of the hard work involved. In the latter half of the book, when David becomes fully responsible for Mal on most days, David begins to work with Mal and starts to understand him better. As a result, Mal learns to like new foods, enjoy new experiences, and say new words. In the novel’s climax, as David competes for $5,000, Mal cheers David on, using two words he’s never used before. David comes out victorious with the support of his family, particularly Mal. David and Mal’s relationship grows stronger by the end of the novel, and David accepts that Mal holds the family together.
Mal is David’s younger brother. He is 10 years old and has autism. At the beginning of the novel, Mal can only say one word, okay, which he has been using for a year. Mal has occasional meltdowns and will begin shrieking and sometimes fighting against himself or those around him. One of the primary ways that the family helps Mal through these meltdowns is to wrap him in his favorite rug, a long scrap of commercial carpet.
David and Mal’s bond as brothers is one of the main focal points in the second half of the novel. Mal has very specific needs that David is usually happy to accommodate. For example, when they go for a walk, Mal requires a specific hoodie and wants Cheerios in the pockets. He also needs to listen to the Disney song “Let It Go” on his headphones, and his shoes must be “tied just right—if they’re too tight or too loose he won’t go” (164). Despite David’s efforts to carefully accommodate Mal’s needs, their first walk ends in a meltdown because the battery in Mal’s headphones dies. David calms Mal down by singing “Let It Go.” David remains persistent with Mal and eventually realizes that Mal likes the music because it provides “a filter between him and the noisiness of the outside world” (176). Using this logic, David introduces Mal to sunglasses, which help Mal to deal with his visual sensory issues. David also figures out that Mal only likes certain food colors and textures, so he helps Mal to find more foods to eat, like toaster waffles.
Mal shows his support for David in return. When David is training for his first eating contest, Mal watches, “silently mouthing the word ‘Okay’” (49) and getting louder as David improves. As David continues to train, he observes, “Mal loves to watch me eat” (161). Mal’s support of David ultimately allows him to enter the final competition. When Dad tries to stop David from competing, Mal “started screaming ‘Go, David, Go!’ over and over” (254). Mal’s ability to use new words is such an important event to the family that David’s parents decide to bring Mal to the competition and show their support for David. Through his time with David, Mal makes significant progress in his interactions with the world around him. This process shows The Importance of a Family Support System.
David’s parents are one of the main sources of conflict for David. Mom is the primary caretaker for David and Mal while Dad works a full-time job. David feels that he gets little attention from his parents, who are often busy with their other responsibilities and children. Throughout most of the novel, David feels like he is at odds with his parents because of the responsibility they expect from him and the lack of support he feels from them. When David begins his competitive eating training, Mom expresses her disapproval by declaring that eating contests “are a disgusting display of excess and gluttony” (82). In Chapter 20, both Mom and Dad confront David about his new hobby, concerned about the dangers and long-term health risks involved. In the same talk, they also set David up with the official paid responsibility of watching Mal while Mom works a six-week summer job.
With Mom away, David finds support in Dad, who talks with David more candidly about Mal’s autism and discusses ways to better support him. Dad also talks to David about competitive eating, telling a story about his experience as an excellent skateboarder—at least until he broke both ankles and lost his touch. He understands what it’s like to want to focus on one’s talents and nothing else. However, Dad’s efforts aren’t enough to help the tension between David and his parents. When David’s auction mistake comes out in Chapter 38, David unloads his frustration and feelings of neglect, and when he rebels against their ban on the eating contest and sneaks out, this leads to a pivotal moment for David’s parents. Rather than pulling him off the stage in the middle of the contest, David’s parents show up to cheer him on to victory, showing support for his interests for the first time in the novel. After the contest, David’s parents admit that they’re not perfect and reassure him that they love him.
David’s two best friends are Cyn and HeyMan (short for Hayden Mankowski). David has been friends with Cyn since they were in first grade, several years before HeyMan moved to their school. HeyMan is described as being exceptionally hairy for a 14-year-old, while Cyn, a Korean American, is described as being tall and slender. HeyMan and Cyn give David moral and financial support throughout his competitive eating training. Additionally, Cyn provides essential information to David, helping him track down Jooky and prove that The Gurge scammed him.
However, in the background, HeyMan and Cyn begin to develop a romantic relationship. Whereas before the three friends were a platonic group, HeyMan and Cyn start to see each other without David, causing complex feelings for David. David eventually has separate conversations with both Cyn and HeyMan and realizes that although some dynamics may change, the three of them will always remain good friends.