94 pages • 3 hours read
J. R. R. TolkienA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.
Summary
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Character Analysis
Themes
Symbols & Motifs
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Tools
In Dorthonion, Melkor kills all but 12 of Barahir’s companions. They are attacked again and only Beren, Barahir’s son, is left alive. After avenging his father and recovering the ring of Felagund, he flees and spends years as an outlaw before he arrives in the Elvish realm of Doriath, where he meets Lúthien, the only daughter of Thingol and Melian. Lúthien is dancing and singing in a glade and Beren falls in love at first sight. She grows to fall in love with him as well, but Thingol dislikes Beren and is “filled with anger” (80), as believes Beren to be unworthy of his daughter. Thingol gives Beren a seemingly impossible task to achieve before he could marry Lúthien, asking Beren to bring him one of the Silmarils that Melkor stole long ago.
Beren travels through difficult terrain toward Angband, receiving help from Finrod Felagund after presenting his father’s ring. Fearing retaliation from the sons of Fëanor, Finrod decides to join Beren on his quest and leave his brother to govern in his stead. Should anyone other than Fëanor’s sons possess a Silmaril, the sons will be sworn to kill them and take it back. Finrod and Beren travel to Angband with ten companions. They find and kill an enemy encampment, Finrod using his magic to disguise the party as Orcs. Nonetheless, Sauron spots them from his tower and demands that they are brought before him. After a lengthy magical duel with Finrod, Sauron strips away their disguises and imprisons the companions, threatening to kill them one-by-one “unless one would betray the truth to him” (83). A werewolf eats the prisoners one at a time, but no one betrays the truth.
When Lúthien learns of Beren’s peril, she tries to sneak out of her home and chases after him. She is caught and imprisoned, though eventually escapes and befriends a giant wolf named Huan. According to prophecy, Huan could only be killed by the greatest werewolf ever.
When Finrod and Beren are the only two left alive, the werewolf comes again. Finrod wrestles with it, though the fight kills them both. Lúthien arrives at the castle, communicates with Beren, and Sauron sends wolves to capture her, all of which are killed by Huan. Sauron transforms himself into a werewolf and fights Huan. Huan wins, though Sauron escapes. Beren and Lúthien reunite and they bury Finrod Felagund.
Celegorm and Curufin, the sons of Fëanor, are shamed in the wake of Finrod’s death. They try to gather support for a renewed quest for the Silmarils but are ignored. They come across Beren and Lúthien, attacking the couple. Beren emerges victorious but is injured. As the brothers are chased away by Huan, Lúthien heals Beren. They decide to try again for the Silmarils. Lúthien transforms herself into the bat, Thuringwethil, and Beren into the sire of werewolves, Draugluin.
Melkor has been breeding a horrific werewolf named Carcharoth to kill Huan. It guards the gates to Angband, but Lúthien’s magic allows them to slip past. Entering Melkor’s throne room, Lúthien’s disguise vanishes and she offers to sing before Melkor. As she does so, the court is caught in a sleeping spell. Beren steals a Silmaril but before he can steal the others, his knife snaps and cuts the face of Melkor. Beren and Lúthien flee before the court wakes. At the gate, Carcharoth has awoken. The wolf bites off Beren’s hand that contains the Silmaril, but the jewel begins to sear his flesh from the inside, and he runs away in the direction of Beleriand. Lúthien heals Beren as the court wakes, but Beren and Lúthien are saved by the Eagles and carried back to Doriath. Returning to Thingol, Beren says that his quest is complete and that “even now a Silmaril is in my hand” (90), though the hand itself is still inside the wolf. Thingol is pleased and accepts Beren and Lúthien, though his kingdom is being ravaged by Carcharoth. Beren goes to hunt the wolf, along with Huan, Thingol, and others. There is fight: Huan kills Carcharoth but is mortally wounded; Beren is also hurt, though the Silmaril is recovered. It is handed to Beren, who can die knowing that his quest is complete. Beren later dies in Lúthien’s arms. Lúthien dies of heartbreak. Mandos is so moved by her song that he goes to Manwë and, together, they resurrect both Lúthien and Beren, giving the former a mortal life so that the two may grow old and die together.
The story of Lúthien and Beren gives Maedhros hope that an attack against Melkor could succeed. He tries to rally the other Elves, but many do not trust a son of Fëanor, and Thingol refuses to give up his Silmaril. The Dwarves do help and make many weapons, as do various groups of Men. Maedhros concocts a plan and, though he is slightly delayed, is joined by Fingon and Turgon. Melkor’s spies have revealed Maedhros’ plan, however, and his Orcs tempt Fingon’s forces to attack too soon, though they manage to fight their way almost into Angband. They find themselves overstretched and trapped. Fingon’s forces are beaten back before Maedhros has even arrived. Fingon and Turgon join forces during battle and then are joined by Maedhros. Melkor sends his full army into the field, including balrogs and dragons. The Elves would have won, but they were betrayed by Men. The sons of Ulfang switch sides, though many of them perish in the fight.
Maedhros’ army breaks; of the sons of Fëanor, “all were wounded none were slain” (94). They escape with the help of the Dwarves. Fingon is killed by Gothmog, Lord of Balrogs, while Turgon is encouraged by Húrin and Huor to flee back to Gondolin and rebuild the Elvish forces. He does so and Húrin and Huor mount a heroic last stand; Huor is killed, but Húrin is captured alive.
By the end of the battle, “the realm of Fingon was no more; and the sons of Fëanor wandered as leaves before the wind” (95). Melkor takes control of vast swaths of land. Turgon, now technically King of the Noldor, thinks only of Melkor. Húrin is dragged before Melkor, who forces him to sit in a stone chair high up in Thangorodrim and watch as all of the lands below are destroyed.
Túrin is the son of Morwen and Húrin. He has a sister, Lalaith, who died of sickness at a young age. After Nirnaeth Arnoediad, Húrin’s people are subjugated by the Men from the east. Without her husband and still with child, Morwen is forced send Túrin away to stay with Thingol. After Thingol accepts the request, he calls for Morwen to join her son. She refuses, sending back with them the “Dragon-helm of Dor-lómin, greatest of the heirlooms of the house of Hador” (98).
Túrin grows up as Thingol’s foster son. He has a good but lonely upbringing. After a disagreement, an accident causes the death of an Elf and Túrin refuses to subject himself to Thingol’s judgement. He joins a band of roving outlaws. In Túrin’s absence, Thingol pardons him and Beleg promises to bring Túrin back. He happens across Túrin a year later and the outlaws capture Beleg. When Túrin sees how badly his gang have treated Beleg, he swears to only attack “the servants of Angband” (99) but refuses to return with Beleg. After speaking to Thingol, Beleg promises to protect Túrin and, with the king’s blessing, takes a sword named Anglachel and a “store of lembas” (99).
Túrin and his gang, while searching for a camp, capture a dwarf named Mîm. In exchange for sparing his life, Mîm offers to lead his captors to his home. There, it is revealed that Túrin’s outlaws have killed Mîm’s son. Shamed by this, Túrin promises a ransom to Mîm. Túrin learns about Dwarves while staying in the home. Beleg joins them and they stay the winter with the Dwarves, after which Melkor’s forces begin to move again. Túrin begins to build his gang into an army. Mîm is captured and leads Orcs to his house, where they kill many and capture Túrin.
Beleg survives and tracks the Orcs. On his journey, he encounters Gwindor, who had been captured during the Nirnaeth Arnoediad and had escaped. After catching up to the Orcs, Beleg and Gwindor sneak into the camp at night and free Túrin. When they wake the unconscious prisoner, Túrin thinks he is under attack and mistakenly kills Beleg. He is horrified by his actions. The next morning, Túrin and Gwindor bury Beleg, taking his sword and his lembas. They travel together to Nargothrond. Gwindor is not recognized at first by his people. He is soon accepted, as is Túrin, who becomes friends with Orodreth. Túrin and Gwindor argue over Finduilas, who switches her affections from the latter to the former and back again. Túrin convinces Orodreth to fight more against Melkor’s forces.
At this time, Morwen finally flees Dor-lómin with Nienor, her daughter, only for Thingol to tell her that her son has left. Ulmo sends Thingol a warning, telling him to pass the warning along to Orodreth. Túrin advises Orodreth not to listen and this ends in tragedy: Glaurung the dragon kills many Men and Elves. Túrin leads an army against Melkor’s forces but is pushed back. Orodreth and Gwindor are both killed; with his dying breath, Gwindor tells Túrin to return to Nargothrond to protect Finduilas, but Túrin arrives too late. The city is sacked. Glaurung spots Túrin and challenges him. Túrin fights the dragon but is caught in Glaurung’s spell and freezes. Glaurung taunts Túrin, mocking his pride, his family’s fortunes, and his failure to defend Nargothrond. Finduilas passes over the bridge before Túrin, captured and enslaved. Túrin breaks the spell and manages to escape, though has been tricked into believing that his mother and sister are in danger and still in Dor-lómin. He rushes to find them but finds only an empty home.
In Dor-lómin, he visits the home of Brodda the Easterling, who has taken Aerin for his wife. Aerin is “Húrin’s kinswoman” (106) and has been abused by Brodda. Túrin hears that his mother and sister traveled west; he kills Brodda and his underlings, then he flees. Regretting his decisions, he chooses to search for Finduilas but hears a rumor that she has been brutally murdered by the Orcs. Túrin spends the winter grieving, given shelter by woodsmen. He appreciates their gesture and names himself Turambar and promises to protect them.
Morwen hears news of her son’s death and searches for him. Nienor, her daughter, disguises herself and joins the party of Elves who chase after Morwen. They are attacked by Glaurung, who bewitches Nienor with such bad amnesia that she forgets her own identity. She flees in a “madness of fear” (108); she is found again, naked and lost, by Turambar (really Túrin) near the burial mound of Finduilas and is taken in. He has no idea who she really is and Túrin falls in love with his sister. They eventually marry and she becomes pregnant. Glaurung is plotting an attack on the woodsmen so Túrin gathers the forces and attempts to surprise the dragon. Nienor follows after him. Túrin tries to ambush Glaurung but fails; his friends die. Túrin manages to stab the dragon. Glaurung dies, though his blood burns Túrin and the dragon’s final stare casts a spell over Túrin that makes him appear dead. Nienor views the destruction from afar and runs to the scene; she finds Túrin’s body and presumes him to be dead. Glaurung, with his dying breath, reveals Nienor’s true identity and her relation to Túrin: “Distraught with horror and anguish” (110), she kills herself.
As the true story reaches the woodsmen’s community, Túrin returns to them. He is told what happened but does not believe it to be true. Killing a man, he flees into the woods. As he mourns, he is found by Mablung, one of Thingol’s people. Mablung affirms the story Túrin has heard. Túrin flees and talks to his sword; the sword says it will take his life gladly for “the blood of Beleg my master, and the blood of Brandir slain unjustly” (111). He throws himself on his sword. The Elves write a lament for the dead and bury Túrin.
The story of Beren and Lúthien is one of the most complete stories in the novel. Though it ties into the larger narrative, it functions as a tragic love story in its own right. It has a beginning, a middle, and an end, fitting the mold of traditional romances such as Romeo and Juliet or Tristan and Isolde. The romance between the two lovers burns incredibly brightly, sprung from an initial moment of infatuation. After a quest, Beren earns the right to marry Lúthien, though loses his hand and his life in the pursuit of the Silmaril. While many tragic love stories end with the death of the protagonists, Tolkien adds another dimension. Lúthien is given the choice of giving up her immortality in exchange for more time with Beren. She chooses to do so, sacrificing the chance to live forever in exchange for a short period with the man she loves. She is the only character in the text who makes a decision that is equally romantic and tragic (in that it will inevitably lead to her death). It is an act of infatuated suicide, but her love for Beren justifies the decision and undermines the clichéd and tragic ending that accompanies most love stories.
If the story of Beren and Lúthien is a tragic love story, the story of Túrin is pure tragedy. Túrin struggles over the course of many years. He loses family members, friends, and lovers, often due to his own actions. He attempts to offer his military advice, but this only encourages Melkor to attack and destroy the castle where Túrin and his loved ones have lived for many years. He is unable to contain his rage and his need for revenge, to the extent where his own sword wishes to take his life and tells him as much. However, the true story of Túrin is that he faces consequences.
While many characters make poor or ill-informed decisions, few are quite so frequently punished for these decisions. Túrin faces the consequences of his actions every single time and, every single time, he suffers accordingly. Túrin lives the opposite of a charmed life: For all his skill, wit, and determination, he marries and impregnates his own sister before causing her suicide, right after losing everything he has ever loved. Suicide, for Túrin, is the final consequence and the product of every decision he has ever made. In that respect, it is a release. While Túrin’s life story is the most tragic of all, his untimely death is actually an escape from a life in which he has been punished far more than anyone else in the novel.
By J. R. R. Tolkien