logo

53 pages 1 hour read

George Eliot

Silas Marner

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 1861

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Symbols & Motifs

The Stone Pit

Content Warning: This guide discusses addiction and depression, which feature in Silas Marner.

The stone pit is a quarry located near Silas’s house. When Silas first moves to the area, the pit is filled with water. Over time, the local farmers decide to drain the pit to irrigate their fields. In doing so, they reveal the skeleton of Dunsey Cass and the gold that he stole from Silas’s house. The stone pit becomes an important symbol in the novel due to the effect that it has on Godfrey. After the skeleton is revealed, Godfrey returns home and tells his wife that his brother’s remains have been found. Beyond the practical implications of what this means, Godfrey has chosen to interpret events on a symbolic level. For him, this is evidence that the secrets of the past cannot be hidden forever. Dunsey’s disappearance was a mystery that has now been solved. In a similar way, the death of Molly and the parentage of Eppie are mysteries that are now part of the local folklore. Godfrey has convinced himself that these mysteries will inevitably be solved, just as the mystery about his brother has been solved. The skeletons of Godfrey’s own past will be revealed, he believes, so he has decided to tell the truth. He tells Nancy that Eppie is his daughter and that Molly was his wife. Rather than feel anger and shame, Nancy feels only regret. This shocks Godfrey, who then convinces her that they should go to Silas’s house and announce their desire to adopt Eppie. Godfrey is influenced by the symbolism of the draining of the stone pit. When Eppie refuses his offer, however, he returns home. He decides against making his secrets public knowledge. The moment of inspiration caused by the discovery of Dunsey’s skeleton is short lived. Godfrey may have feared that the stone pit was a symbol for his own secrets, but his cowardice is more powerful than any symbolism. He buries his secrets even further, ignoring the symbolic lessons of the stone pit once and for all.

At the same time, the stone pit offers a subtler symbolism concerning the arrival of modernity. Silas Marner is set during the early 1800s. During this time, weavers like Silas still worked with their hands. Trades such as his were artisanal and in high demand. This equilibrium was about to be upset by the arrival of the Industrial Revolution. The preponderance of machines and factories had a seismic effect on the status quo of England. The old methods of manufacture were no longer viable as science, technology, and innovation changed the way the manufacturing process worked. Silas, a weaver, watches the draining of the stone pit. The pit is being drained as a part of the industrialization process, as a way to irrigate previously unfarmable land that has been made viable thanks to new technology. The changing shape of Silas’s physical environment represents an imminent change in his life. For a long time, the pit has been filled with water. Now, the pit will be emptied to make way for something new. The world is changing around Silas, and he is powerless to stop it. He is growing old, and he cannot match his pace with the rest of the world as his eyesight diminishes. The draining of the stone pit is a symbolic moment, encapsulating the passage from one era into the next. Silas understands this on a fundamental level, taking Eppie to the pit to watch the world change before them. The draining of the stone pit not only reveals the truth about Dunsey’s fate and Silas’s gold, but also the truth about the future. 

Lantern Yard

The small religious community in Lantern Yard practices a strict, austere form of Calvinist Protestant Christianity that demands a great deal of the members of the congregation. Silas is raised in this environment, and the practices of the chapel leave a lasting impression on his character. When Silas is betrayed by his best friend, he is also framed for theft and forced to leave Lantern Yard. His departure is a symbolic moment. Silas physically leaves Lantern Yard and, at the same time, he leaves his religious inclinations behind as well. The physical departure is symbolically a philosophical exit, demonstrating the severance between Silas and everything he knows. Lantern Yard becomes a fixed point in Silas’s psyche, a symbol of the moment of significant change and suffering in his life. He can sort his existence into the time at Lantern Yard and the time after Lantern Yard, which extents to his time with and without religion, as well as his time in and out of the north of England.

When Silas leaves Lantern Yard, he travels south to Raveloe. The contrast in cultures is stark. As the narrator notes, Raveloe is a plentiful place where the people do not need to work nearly as much in order to survive. They have a local church, but it preaches a more traditional form of Anglican Protestant Christianity, an interpretation of the religion that does not demand nearly as much of its congregation as Silas’s former chapel. Even after moving further south, Silas cannot leave Lantern Yard behind him. Lantern Yard travels with him, pressing down on his thoughts and driving him into solitude. Lantern Yard becomes a personal symbol to Silas, reminding him of the dangers of trusting others. He was exiled from Lantern Yard by the duplicitous congregation, but he drives himself further into exile because he cannot bring himself to trust again. Silas does not want to be hurt and, whenever he considers whether he should integrate himself into the local community, he turns to the symbol of Lantern Yard as a reminder of how much he can be hurt. Silas conceptualizes Lantern Yard as a symbol of all the pain he has suffered. Lantern Yard was everything he knew, right up until it was forcibly taken away from him. In Raveloe, he finds himself in a strange and foreign land. The local religious practices are nothing like what he has known, and the people are very different, yet the symbol of Lantern Yard looms large in his mind.

Silas gradually comes to terms with his exile and—through the love of Eppie and his neighbors—becomes a part of the Raveloe community. He attends the church in Raveloe after rediscovering his religion. In doing so, he learns to let go of his past. Once he feels better about his life, Silas announces his plan to travel north and return to Lantern Yard. He wants answers about his past, and he believes that the only place where he can get these answers is Lantern Yard. When he returns to the chapel, however, the building has been turned into a factory. None of the local people remember the religious group that once met there. The memories that have haunted Silas for so long have been erased from the world. The chapel has not just been destroyed; it has been forgotten. The replacement of the chapel with a factory is a symbol of the imminent Industrial Revolution, but it is also a message to Silas. The chapel is not just destroyed; it is erased from the local memory. This erasure gives Silas permission to leave his memories behind too. He realizes that he must do the same, allowing his memories of Lantern Yard to be replaced by something more modern and productive. Silas leaves Lantern Yard in his past, achieving catharsis by addressing the symbolic meaning of the destruction of the old chapel.

Gold

Gold is valuable in a material and symbolic sense. When Silas moves to Raveloe and dedicates himself full time to weaving, he begins to accumulate gold. The nature of his work means that he is rejecting society. He works long hours and refuses to engage with his community, allowing him more free time to dedicate to the accumulation of wealth. The gold becomes an important way for Silas to measure his worth. Since leaving Lantern Yard, he has rejected religion. This has left a large hole in his life that he needs to fill. Gold provides him with a physical way in which to fill this void. The more he works, the more gold he earns. The more gold he earns, the more he validates his lifestyle. Each night, Silas counts his coins as a way to assure himself that he has made the right decisions. This is a symbolic act, as Silas is measuring the worth of his behavior in the coins. He does not spend money on anything and he does not covet anything, so the coins have little value to him beyond this form of personal validation. Silas does not need money to increase his wealth or to buy anything. Instead, he needs money as a replacement for the direction and purpose that was once given to him by religion. In a symbolic sense, gold represents Silas’s need for validation and purpose.

Dunsey steals Silas’s gold. To a wealth man like Dunsey, the bags of gold are not worth much. The gold is equivalent to several months’ rent from one of the many tenants who occupy the land owned by the Cass family. As such, Dunsey steals the gold more for the thrill of the act than the actual financial reward. He steals the gold as a symbolic demonstration of his privilege. He feels entitled to any money that is not his own, and this sense of entitlement pushes him into committing a crime. To Silas, the theft is a devasting moment that robs him of his life’s purpose. To Dunsey, the theft is an impulsive act that does little to increase his material wealth. Silas loses everything, and Dunsey gains little; the difference is a symbolic illustration of the wealth inequality in 19th-century England.

When Eppie first ventures into Silas’s house, he mistakes her golden hair for his missing gold. On a symbolic level, Silas is not necessarily mistaken. As he gradually comes to love his adoptive daughter, she provides him with the sense of purpose that has been missing from his life. Silas’s gold is stolen, but it is replaced by a golden-haired child who teaches him to rediscover his faith and his sense of community. Eppie is worth more to Silas than any amount of gold. In effect, she becomes a metaphorical fortune that wanders into his life by chance or luck or both. The fickle nature of fortune means that Silas can lose his material wealth due to Dunsey’s impetuous impulse and then discover something far more symbolically valuable. In a symbolic sense, Eppie becomes the gold that Silas always desired. She fills the void in his life that, at one time, he tried to fill with money. 

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text