69 pages • 2 hours read
Shelby MahurinA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summary
Background
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Character Analysis
Themes
Symbols & Motifs
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Tools
Lou’s act knocks her out for three days. When she wakes, Reid is sleeping beside her, having previously been holding her hand. He explains that she collapsed and that Ansel ran to Brie Perrot (Coco) for help. He doesn’t understand why the execution so overwhelmed Lou since Estelle was only a witch. He insists witches aren’t people and get what they deserve for being evil. She asks him what she would deserve if she were a witch, and he says she’d be treated the same.
After Reid leaves her, Lou wonders if she has made a mistake not doing what her mother wanted. If the sacrifice had succeeded, all the king’s descendants would have died as well, ending the witches’ persecution. Lou has told herself that she resisted the sacrifice in part because of the loss of innocent life, but she recognizes that witches are now dying because of her actions and wonders if she was simply too cowardly to face her own death.
A short while later, a visiting Coco reassures Lou that she did what she had to do to protect herself. She urges Lou to move forward, and Ansel agrees. Lou realizes Ansel now knows she’s a witch but remains her friend—a fact that moves her to tears. Ansel tells Lou to try and understand that Reid thought he was protecting her from a demon. He explains that no one can force Reid to change his mind—he must learn on his own—but he hopes she and Reid can find a way forward because they are both good people.
Later, Lou heeds Ansel’s words and goes to the cellar library to borrow a Bible so she can learn Reid’s ideology. She discovers the Archbishop secretly eating a sticky bun. He gives her a Bible, and she notes the irony of her interest in scripture coupled with the Archbishop’s clandestine indulgence.
That night, Reid is surprised to find Lou awake in their bedroom, as she is obviously still weak and ill. He helps her braid her hair, and she asks him about how he became captain of the Chasseurs. He describes killing a pack of werewolves. Lou tenses, and Reid seems remorseful for upsetting her.
Reid decides to honor Lou’s request to go somewhere outside the church. Father Orville is worried that Monsieur Bernard’s inevitable death will upset her, and he thinks some time away would be good. Lou makes Reid leave behind his Chasseur coat, and they head out into the blustery winter’s day to Pan’s patisserie. Reid is cold without his coat, so he huddles under her cloak, which quickly becomes comical. Lou and Reid stuff themselves with buns and engage in a game of questions to learn more about each other. A dove coos above them, and Lou begins to dance in the snow, catching snowflakes on her tongue. On their return to the cathedral, Coco informs them that Monsieur Bernard has escaped, to Lou’s distress. Reid comforts Lou and is surprised when Lou looks at him with hope.
Estelle’s death is an emotional low point for Lou. Reid’s response to the execution and Lou’s own guilt make her wonder if she should have let her mother kill her. Any compromise between the witches and the Church seems impossible, given the history of hatred and persecution. The event also affects Lou’s growing closeness with Reid, as she is devastated when Reid tells her that any witch deserves to burn.
Coco and Ansel form an unlikely alliance to help Lou. While Coco has always shown Loyalty Within Friendship, Ansel now reveals that he doesn’t condemn Lou for being a witch. He points out that only a good person would take on another’s suffering and makes it clear that he looks at the circumstances before passing judgment. His new understanding helps Lou to mitigate some of her previous self-doubt over not choosing a side. Because Ansel shows himself capable of change, tolerating aspects of both the Church and witches, Lou has renewed hope that Reid may be able to as well. Further, she follows Ansel’s example herself, determining to study Reid’s religion so she can reasonably discuss his beliefs.
Although Reid can’t understand Lou’s depression over the death of a witch, the fact that he attempts to mitigate it highlights his growing feelings for her. He takes her to Pan’s for a bun to make her happy, leaving behind his Chasseur coat at her request; although Lou is still concealing her true nature, the pair interact more or less as themselves—individuals rather than representatives of a particular ideology. A dove flitters above Reid and Lou as they flirt in the snow, symbolizing their romance. Upon learning Monsieur Bernard is missing, Reid responds thoughtfully, noting, “I think there are few absolutes in this world. Just because the Church believes Monsieur Bernard will suffer eternally for his mental illness […] doesn’t mean he will” (271). Reid’s rejection of the Church’s absolutism gives Lou hope that he maybe will be able to grow beyond his bias after all.