Scar Island

Scar Island has been compared to William Golding’s Lord of the Flies. What are some similarities between this story and Lord of the Flies? How are the two stories different?

How does the revelation of Jonathan’s secret affect the power struggle between Jonathan and Sebastian? How does the slow unveiling of the secret change Jonathan’s character as the story progresses?

Which specific events in the story alter the boys’ alliances? In other words, which events strengthen Sebastian’s influence, and which make the boys favor Jonathan?

How does the author use metaphors and similes to reveal the characters’ personalities? Give specific examples based on at least two characters.

Does Sebastian redeem himself at the end of the novel? Does his character repair itself as much as Jonathan’s does, or is his redemption of a lesser degree?

How does the story change when a secret is revealed? Identify at least two of the secrets and explain how the story changes when they are revealed.

How is symbolism demonstrated in the boys burning the files of their juvenile crimes to light the lighthouse? What do you think their burning the files represents?

Benny is a key ally of Sebastian, and Colin is Jonathan’s close ally and friend. How are the characters of Benny and Colin similar and different? How do these two friendships differ?