logo

52 pages 1 hour read

Marianne Wiggins

Properties of Thirst

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2022

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 8-11Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 8 Summary: “The Eighth Property of Thirst Is Reinvention”

Schiff is initially stationed in Honolulu, where he gathers data and writes reports concerning the former commanders of both the Army and Navy on their culpability in the Pearl Harbor attacks. He and Sunny write letters. Schiff is certain that he’ll be sent to Japan when the war ends to draft its new constitution, but he hasn’t revealed this to Sunny.

One evening, Schiff is summoned by the Navy commander. He questions Schiff about a flyer he has put into circulation seeking information on the whereabouts of Stryker’s wife, Suzy, and their children. The commander’s daughter was a friend of Suzy’s in high school. He informs Schiff that Stryker wasn’t stationed on any ship on the day of the bombing. The commander’s wife explains that she herself flew to San Francisco on December 7, 1941, with Suzy and the twins; Suzy had an aunt who lived in the city. When the plane landed in San Francisco, Suzy was immediately taken away, still carrying one of the babies. The commander’s wife explains that she left the other twin with Suzy’s aunt at the airport. The commander states that Stryker indicated he was going aboard the ship The Arizona that day to play cards. Schiff asks permission to search Stryker’s living quarters, which the commander arranges.

Schiff searches Stryker’s room but finds no information to help him in the search for Suzy. Instead, he finds a vial of dirt. When the naval officer overseeing Schiff’s search explains the superstitious practice of a sailor carrying dirt from his home to ensure that he returns from water safely, Schiff knows that the soil is from Three Chairs. He asks permission to keep it.

Chapter 9 Summary: “The Ninth Property of Thirst Is Submersion”

The chapter opens from the point of view of Snow, one of the Los Angeles Department of Water agents. He thinks back to his childhood. He was labeled unintelligent at a young age and never learned to read. He was skilled, however, at shooting and, by age 10, was earning money from local farmers by killing birds that damaged their crops. Secretly, Snow did trick shooting at fairs and carnivals but kept this—and the fact that he had a kind of ghost or spirit around him—a secret from his father and grandfather. Later, his grandfather taught him to read Braille. He had a brief stint in a Hollywood film—hired by Bobby Kaye for his marksmanship abilities—but was fired when he refused to aim the gun at people. It was there that one of the Pinkertons witnessed Snow’s skills and suggested that he pursue a security job with Los Angeles Department of Water.

Snow worked the night shift watch as the facility was constructed; he was told that certain citizens opposed the undertaking, especially Rocky Rhodes. One night, Snow caught Rocky preparing to light dynamite. Snow moved to fire at Rocky, but the dynamite detonated, knocking Snow down and removing most of Rocky’s hand. Later, Snow found and kept Rocky’s wedding ring.

After the aqueduct was built, Los Angeles Department of Water hired Snow to police it. On one occasion when he and an agent named McCloud were collecting water samples, a raccoon attacked Snow. McCloud took him to the Three Chairs clinic, where Lou tended to his arm, stitched it, and then inoculated him against rabies. Later, Snow met Lou in town and returned Rocky’s ring to her.

He recalls, too, the incident with the elephant, though the attack occurred so quickly that the details are vague. Snow sustained cracked and broken ribs, a perforated lung, and a cracked jaw. When he awakened in a Los Angeles hospital, he learned that McCloud was killed by the elephant and that Stryker and Hace escaped punishment. He vowed to see that justice was carried out.

When the war broke out, Snow made plans to visit Stryker’s father. He first took a solitary trek into the mountains on the pretense of strengthening his lungs. He scouted Three Chairs from a distance and then got Rocky in his gun sight, planning to shoot off his hat. However, Rocky moved, and Snow’s shot hit a tree instead.

Chapter 10 Summary: “The Tenth Property of Thirst Is the Taste of the Inevitable”

Just before the war ends, Schiff receives a telegram from Sunny asking him to come to Three Chairs because Rocky has died. He can’t leave and thus doesn’t know how to respond to her and never does. Four years later, after the war is over, Schiff arrives at Three Chairs to discover that it has become the property of the Los Angeles Department of Water. An agent informs him that Rocky died by suicide and that Sunny had to sell the estate. Schiff phones Cas, who is living with Lyndon. She informs him that Sunny has adopted an orphan from Manzanar and has opened a restaurant in a town north of San Francisco.

Driving north, Schiff recalls his final days in Japan and then thinks of the letter he received from Cas and Rocky while he was in Hawaii. Rocky let him know that Dr. Arakawa’s data from Manzanar pointed to an increase in the incidence of pulmonary illnesses. Schiff sleeps in his car and arrives the next morning in the town where Sunny now lives. He fears that Sunny may refuse to speak to him but goes to her restaurant anyway. Three chairs are on the porch, and one of them is the rocking chair that Rocky made for him. A boy of Japanese descent exits a school bus: Sunny’s adopted son, Emerson. Soon, Sunny arrives. Schiff tries to speak to her, but she puts him to work preparing for the dinner service.

After the restaurant closes, Sunny offers Schiff some wine, and they talk. She’s still upset that Schiff didn’t respond or come when she needed him. He tells Sunny about searching Stryker’s living quarters.

Sunny recounts how Rocky went missing: A forest ranger heard a shot and then discovered Rocky’s boat in the middle of the lake. They searched for him for three days. In time, Lyndon suggested that they go through Rocky’s papers. He had 12 active lawsuits against Los Angeles Department of Water. That night, Sunny couldn’t sleep and has a sudden thought: She entered her parents’ former bedroom, where she discovered more of Lou’s cooking notebooks.

Chapter 11 Summary: “The Final Property of Thirst Is Evaporation”

This chapter recounts Rocky’s final hours from his perspective. In the boat on the lake, he fingers his knife and studies the sunset. He contemplates several things: the landscape, Lou, Stryker, and fishing. He debates his legacy and whether it’s acceptable for him to ultimately lose the battle against Los Angeles Department of Water. He recounts specific memories of Stryker, Lou, and Punch.

As Rocky peers into the water, he loses his balance and falls into the lake.

Chapters 8-11 Analysis

The closing section unfolds as the war ends, bringing with it the end of Rocky’s life and the Three Chairs estate. In addition, the text provides revelations about Stryker. Learning that Stryker planned to play cards aboard The Arizona on the day it was bombed provides the confirmation the Rhodes family has longed for concerning his death. Schiff’s searching his barracks echoes Rocky’s search of the casita where Stryker resided. Both men find evidence that Stryker loved his family and valued his home. Schiff knows that this information will be consoling to Sunny. That Stryker’s wife and sons arrived in California on the day of the bombing is unexpected news. Although it’s highly likely that Suzy and one of the twins were subsequently placed in an internment camp, the Rhodes family holds out hope that they may be able to contact Suzy’s aunt and learn the whereabouts of the remaining twin. The novel never resolves this plot point but arguably allows for the possibility of a remaining son surviving to carry on the Rhodes’s legacy.

The devotion of Chapter 9 to Snow’s point of view provides a rare look into the antagonist’s perspective. The text depicts Snow, though committed to the Los Angeles Department of Water and thus a clear enemy of Rocky’s, as a principled character. His refusal, for instance, to aim a gun at a person in a Hollywood film, despite its being filled with blanks, portrays him as a person of moral fiber. Likewise, he’s dedicated to his work and comes to believe, as he has been told, that providing water to the city of Los Angeles serves the greater good. In this way, the novel reveals the complexity of the water war: Both sides operate from a position of moral conviction that they’re in the right.

Like Suzy and her children with Stryker, the novel leaves the future of Schiff and Sunny’s relationship uncertain. The letters they exchange while Schiff is in Hawaii are loving and indicate a mutual desire to maintain their relationship after the war. Schiff is devastated, however, when he can’t go to Sunny upon her request after Rocky dies. When Schiff receives no future contact from her after this telegram, he’s certain that he has permanently destroyed their relationship by failing to respond in her time of grief and mourning. His decision, then, to visit her after the war is significant. He’s aware that she may refuse to speak to him entirely or respond with hostility.

Although Sunny had to relinquish the Three Chairs estate, she has established a new life in which she’s content. The son she has adopted from Manzanar provides an outlet for the love and care she yearns to give. Her naming the boy “Emerson” reflects Rocky’s love of the transcendental writers such as Ralph Waldo Emerson. Given that Stryker named his twin sons “Ralph” and “Waldo,” this third grandchild of Rocky’s completes the circle, establishing a new group of three in the spirit of Rocky’s “Three Chairs.”

Rocky’s death impacts Cas and Sunny greatly but doesn’t leave them entirely defeated. Cas lives a meaningful life with Lyndon, and Sunny’s adopted son provides her with an outlet for love and a family. Because the novel doesn’t reveal whether Sunny wrestled greatly with the decision to continue Rocky’s legal battles against the Los Angeles Department of Water, her thoughts on this subject remain unclear. In letting go of the estate, however, she undoubtedly let go of a large part of herself and her connection to her past.

Although Rocky’s death is presumed to be by suicide, the final chapter arguably calls this into question, suggesting instead an accidental drowning. His inner monologue nevertheless portrays an attitude of defeat and resignation that despite his efforts, the Los Angeles Department of Water would triumph in the end. Although his sadness is evident, however, Rocky takes solace in the fact that he never compromised his principles. Even though (as he predicts) the Los Angeles Department of Water seizes ownership of Three Chairs after Rocky’s death, arguably signifying a victory for his longtime enemy, Rocky dies satisfied that he fought for what he believed in and thus maintained his honor and sense of personal conviction. Thus, the novel brings together the three major themes—Pursuit of the American Dream, Loss and Remembrance, and Legacy and Familial Expectations—but leaves some of the plot threads unresolved.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text