50 pages • 1 hour read
Émile Zola, Transl. Gerhard KrügerA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Nana and Labordette sit in a box at the Théâtre des Variétés, where the actors are rehearsing a new play written by Fauchery. Bordenave, whose last two plays have been financial failures, thinks that with Nana in the role of the courtesan, he can attract a larger audience, court Muffat’s favor, and, more importantly, loosen Muffat’s purse strings. Labordette, ever the diplomat, has arranged for Nana to meet with Muffat to reconcile. Rose, who is portraying the duchess in the new play, is furious that Nana might soon take Muffat back from her.
Nana meets Muffat in her old dressing room. He wants her back. He offers her everything he can think of—a townhouse of her own, jewels, money—if only she will return to him and promise fidelity. She answers that she wants only one thing: the role of the duchess, the respectable woman, in the play. She knows he can procure this for her by appealing to Bordenave, who is desperate for Muffat’s funding. She argues that Muffat can also get Fauchery to write positively about her by using the fact that Fauchery is having an affair with Muffat’s wife and thus is in no position to refuse him any request. Muffat, who has tried to move on by assuming that the rumors about Sabine and Fauchery are false, pleads with Nana to ask for anything but this. After she gives him a single kiss, however, he agrees.
As Nana predicted, Muffat obtains Bordenave’s agreement readily enough with the promise of financing, even though Bordenave first tries to protest that Nana would be a natural as the courtesan and a disaster as the duchess. Fauchery is less amenable. He thinks the casting change is a mistake and knows Rose Mignon will not take the news of being recast lightly. He is right: the three men—Muffat, Fauchery, and Bordenave—have to negotiate a large payout with Rose’s manager-husband to get her to walk away from the role.
When the play opens months later, Nana’s doubters are proven correct: She is ridiculous in the role of the duchess, and the audience laughs at her. Rose shows up to the debut performance and begins the jeers. Rather than breaking her spirit, this ridicule only fuels Nana to seek revenge by climbing ever higher on the social ladder. She says to Muffat, “I bet you a hundred louis that all those people laughing tonight, I’ll have them worshipping the ground I tread on! Yes, I’ll show your Paris what a fine lady I am!” (243).
Nana accomplishes the meteoric rise she predicted: After quitting the play, she turns herself into the most fashionable and trendsetting woman in Paris. Moreover, she has come to hold men in general responsible for Fontan’s abuse and has become proud of her ability to ruin men, harboring “a natural contempt for the man footing the bill” (247). Muffat has given her an elegant townhouse and a generous monthly allowance, as promised. He tries to insist on her fidelity, but she has rules of her own: He must never get suspicious of her, must allow her private time, and must treat her with respect. He obliges on all counts, but she has no intention of being faithful. She is also so careless with her money that she somehow needs more than Muffat’s allowance, so she begins an affair with Vandeuvres, taking money from him as well.
One year after the gathering at Les Fondettes, Georges pays her a visit, having finally escaped the watchful eye of his mother. They resume their affair, though her passion has worn off. Madame Hugon sends her older son, Philippe, to rescue Georges from Nana’s clutches, but Nana wins him over as spectacularly as she does every other man. Philippe becomes just another of her frequent visitors and lovers.
Nana’s days grow very boring, an endless loop of juggling her lovers and playing with her sickly son and her dog. One day, while on a carriage ride, she passes Satin in the street. Reunited, the two start a relationship. One of Satin’s jealous lovers, Madame Robert, writes to Muffat to tell him about Nana’s many other lovers. When he confronts Nana, she denies the men but admits to her affair with Satin, telling him that this is common and natural—even among aristocratic women. He hesitates to believe her but finds that her affair with Satin bothers him less than the thought of affairs with men.
One night, Nana has dinner with all her lovers gathered around her as guests—Muffat, Georges, Philippe, Vandeuvres, and Satin. Most of them are aware that she is sleeping with all of them. Vandeuvres and Philippe understand that this is what she does, Georges wishes she was his alone but knows she is not, Satin wants to be the one who takes precedence, and only Muffat labors under the extraordinary delusion that she is still faithful to him except for Satin. At the dinner, the atmosphere is strained as Nana and Satin flirt and pet openly and the men make half-joking protestations.
The atmosphere only gets more awkward, as Nana’s increasing drunkenness leads her to talk about her lower-class family with pride, only to then vacillate wildly to the idea that it would be disastrous if the country went back to republican government and common people got to make decisions. Nana hopes that Napoleon III will reign forever. She also decries contemporary literature, with all its “realism” getting in the way of romance.
Late in the evening, Satin convinces Nana to send everyone else away. Satin points out an old alcoholic nicknamed Queen Pomare, a formerly popular courtesan who had a long string of wealthy lovers. They are disturbed at this glimpse of their possible future; Nana compares it to her memory of Irma d’Anglars, the exact opposite of Queen Pomare. They shake off their gloom, however, and commit to enjoying their youth.
Nana arrives at the Paris Grand Prix in style, with a magnificent carriage and dress. Gossiping with her friends, she learns that Steiner has regained his wealth, while the Marquis de Chouard has bought time with Gaga’s daughter, sending Gaga into a depression. La Faloise, meanwhile, has come into his inheritance. To get her attention, he bets on a horse that Vandeuvres has named after her. This horse has extremely long odds, 50-1, but La Faloise and some other members of Nana’s circle begin stirring up the crowd to bet on her. They convince so many people that the odds fall quickly to 40-1, then to 25-1, then to 15-1, and lower.
Auguste Mignon approaches Nana to ask for her help with Rose, who has obtained a letter that Sabine wrote to Fauchery, clearly referencing their affair. Rose wants to publicize it to punish Nana by humiliating Muffat, but Nana is unconcerned.
Vandeuvres shows Nana around the stables distractedly; everyone in his circle knows this race will make or break him because he has squandered so much of his fortune on Nana. He has two horses in the race, the one named after Nana and Frangipane. In the final moments of the race, Nana the horse claims a narrow win. The crowd erupts, thrilled. As they chant the winner’s name, “no one knew if it was the animal or the woman who had captivated every heart” (300).
While this outcome should be good for Vandeuvres, it turns out that he had publicly downplaying the horse’s talents to produce long odds. That way, he could make an enormous sum by betting. Because of Nana’s friends’ last-minute bets, however, the odds on Nana grew so narrow that Vandeuvres’s plan was foiled.
Nana spends that night at a raucous after-party where the attendees become almost animalistic in their drunken revelry. At the same time, Vandeuvres locks himself in his stable and burns himself and his horses alive. When Madame Lerat tells Nana this gruesome news, Nana just wishes he’d told her how good her namesake horse was so she could have won more money. It pleases her to think of his courageous method of suicide, however: “Poor boy, such a magnificent way to go!” (303).
Although Nana is wrong about her ability to convincingly portray a noble lady on stage, she is right about her ability to become a celebrated, trendsetting celebrity. While she lacks the breeding to convincingly convey the effect of someone born into the upper class, the latter transformation requires only her innate ostentatious materialism. By combining her good looks with the conspicuous consumption of luxury goods, Nana ascends higher and higher in Parisian society, which gives her a startling amount of power: Most people in her orbit are so desperate for and addicted to her attention that she can behave as badly as she wants with no consequences. After many months of feeling powerless at the hands of Fontan’s brutality, she regains a sense of control by refusing to follow any man’s rules.
The dinner scene places Nana within her historical context at the end of France’s Second Empire and mocks her for her emotion-driven, uneducated approach to class and political loyalties. As the child of a lower-class family, Nana loudly proclaims her origins with no shame; as someone who aspires to respectability and has internalized class-based inferiority, she also declares her loyalty to Napoleon III’s Second Empire autocracy and dismisses the idea that the lower classes should have a political voice. Napoleon III’s reign perpetuated the dominance of the wealthy aristocratic class, keeping people like Nana’s family in poverty while Nana’s clients lived more lavishly than ever. As Nana rises in the world, she benefits from the Second Empire’s policies.
Zola includes a cheeky nod to the novel—and his genre more broadly—in Chapter 10’s dinner scene. During her drunken rant, Nana complains about the literary realism that she is noticing in more and more books. Zola wrote in a subgenre of realism called naturalism, which aimed to show that human beings are a result of their biology and their environment. Nana would, of course, dislike this ideology, captivated as she is by the idea of escaping the world in which she was raised to become a lady. She wants romance, fantasy, and the possibility that people can steer their own lives.
Few moments in the novel portray Nana as chillingly as her reaction to Vandeuvres’s death in Chapter 11. Vandeuvres’s death by suicide is highly disturbing; not only does he choose an especially painful way to die, but he forces his horses to endure this painful death with him. All Nana can see in this death is a glorious spectacle. She imagines it as she would one of her stage performances: a stunning finale to Vandeuvres’s life. She does not conceive of Vandeuvres as a real human being, but rather just as a character in the evolving drama of her sex life. As the novel nears its conclusion, she is drifting further and further from human decency.
By these authors
Beauty
View Collection
Books that Feature the Theme of...
View Collection
Books that Feature the Theme of...
View Collection
Challenging Authority
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Class
View Collection
European History
View Collection
French Literature
View Collection
Historical Fiction
View Collection
Nation & Nationalism
View Collection
Naturalism
View Collection
Power
View Collection
Realism
View Collection
School Book List Titles
View Collection
SuperSummary Staff Picks
View Collection
The Power & Perils of Fame
View Collection