My Fault

Compare Noah’s and Nick’s characters. How do their differences and similarities both drive them apart and bring them together? Consider how their relationship would evolve differently if they had more or less in common.

Craft an argument that supports the following claim: Noah’s move from Toronto to Los Angeles catalyzes all the novel’s subsequent conflicts and thematic explorations. Consider how she reacts to the move and how her life changes thereafter.

Craft an argument that supports or refutes the following claim: Nick’s character has abusive tendencies. Consider how Nick expresses himself and how Noah responds to his behavior. Is the novel using his character to make a commentary on toxic masculinity? If so, how?

Compare and contrast Noah’s and Nick’s family histories. What encounters with trauma, abandonment, or violence have they both experienced? How do these experiences continue to impact them, including their decisions and relationships, in the narrative present?

Analyze the role of Nick’s and Noah’s ancillary interpersonal relationships on their character evolutions. Consider Nick’s history with Lion and Noah’s newfound friendship with Jenna, as well as Nick’s dynamic with Ronnie and Noah’s dynamic with Beth.

Explore the ways Nick’s and Noah’s romantic histories impact their intimate relationship in the present. How does Nick regard women, and why? How does Noah regard men, and why? How do their opinions change as a result of their romance?

Analyze Nick’s role in Noah’s journey toward personal growth and healing. How does Nick treat Noah after he realizes he loves her? How does he encourage her to see herself differently?

Analyze the narrative, symbolic, and thematic significance of the novel’s micro and macro settings. How do the characters’ lives in California impact their behavior? How do their experiences at home, school, and various event venues impact their psyches?