55 pages • 1 hour read
Jodi Lynn AndersonA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
10 months after she was supposed to leave for the United States, Lenore writes to Beth. She writes that she is pregnant, and she apologizes for not getting on the ship. She says that she went to the ship that day, but when she tried to hand over her ticket to board, she panicked and left. She was scared.
Lenore describes how she stayed with her parents and started going to London with her mother. She went back to the house, but James clearly had not been there. Lenore fell into a routine and convinced herself she didn’t want to go to the United States and that Beth was not a good friend.
During her trips to London, Lenore would go to the British Museum, where one time she saw James, who was getting ready to depart on a five-year expedition to Indonesia with his family. She met his parents and looked at their exhibit then left to rejoin her mother.
Later that night, Lenore saw smoke coming from the cottage, and she went there to find James waiting for her with dinner. They apologized to each other, and James gave her a baby Galapágos tortoise. Lenore and James slept together that night, and Lenore became pregnant. Lenore is worried that her tailbone, which she broke as a child, will interfere with the birthing process. She also writes that she is on a ship traveling to America and that she will be coming to Beth’s home.
Catherine takes Beezie and they run away from home, toward New York City. She writes to Ellis three days after they leave. The areas surrounding Canaan are also suffering from the Dust Bowl conditions. Beezie is upset that they have left, and Catherine assumes Ellis and Beth are, too. Catherine has left Ellis the letters from Lenore, and she has left her journal for her mother. She asks Ellis to share with Beth that she and Beezie are safe.
Catherine and Beezie make it to Harrisburg. They have seen many other travelers, and Catherine resents how strangers look at her and Beezie like they are diseased. Catherine is focused on helping Beezie, and she is still upset with Beth for lying about being Catherine’s mother and for being a bad friend to her biological mother, Lenore.
Catherine and Beezie are set to arrive in New York the following day. Catherine is desperate to save Beezie, and says she will write to Ellis again once she knows whether they will be safe in New York.
Catherine writes her last letter to Ellis. When she and Beezie first arrived in New York, Catherine found work doing laundry and found a room to rent that she and Beezie shared with several people. Beezie’s health declined, and Catherine took her to a doctor who blamed her health on the dust, warning Catherine to watch for signs of a fever.
New York is much different from Kansas; Catherine writes that she can’t see the sky but that the city is full of electricity and things to do. When winter arrived, Beezie got sicker; Catherine soothed her by talking of home. Catherine lost her job and started to plan their trip back to Canaan, but then a young woman named Sofia Ortiz moved into their shared room.
Sofia quickly found a job, and helped her roommates. One night, Sofia helped Beezie when Beezie had a bad coughing fit. She gave Catherine home remedies to use on Beezie and promised to find Catherine a new job. Sofia had lived on a farm in Texas, but they lost the farm because of the dust. She also lost her father to dust pneumonia, which is one of the reasons she came to New York. However, she deeply misses her farm and farmwork. Sofia and Catherine made a deal to support each other.
A few weeks after Beezie’s coughing fit, Sofia found Catherine a job making clothing. Beezie’s health drastically declined, and she struggled to breathe, so Catherine carried her to a hospital. Delirious, Beezie fought against the medical staff, but Sofia arrived and helped to calm her by asking her questions including asking what her favorite flower is. Beezie told them it was a lily, and Sofia promised to name her first child Lily if Beezie would allow the to doctors help. After three days of caring for Beezie, Catherine woke up to find Beezie was gone. Feeling better, Beezie had gotten up and found a piece of cake.
Catherine tells Ellis that she isn’t coming back to Canaan. Two weeks before writing, Beth arrived in New York. Catherine knows Ellis is working at Jack’s store and is back together with Lyla. He is also caring for Galapagos.
Catherine speaks to Beth about Lenore, and Beth explains that she didn’t mean to keep Catherine’s mother a secret. Beth had ignored Lenore because she felt inferior to Lenore and didn’t want Lenore to leave her behind someday. When Lenore arrived in Kansas, she and Beth started their friendship over; they were soul mates. Then Lenore died in childbirth.
When Catherine asks when Beth will return to Canaan, Beth reveals that she has sold part of their land. She shows Catherine a newspaper clipping about it in which the reporter misunderstood Beth, writing that Catherine and Beezie had died. A few days later, Sofia offered Catherine a job, but Catherine turned it down and offered Sofia their family farm. Catherine writes that she is not returning to Canaan but that she, Beth, and Beezie are sailing to England to see the Allstock family. Catherine says goodbye to Ellis and encloses fifty dollars to pay him back, suggesting that it is enough money for him to afford to follow her to Forest Row.
In “Lenore: Part 2” and “Catherine: Part 2,” the narratives are structured to enhance the exploration of the themes of belonging, resilience, and the interconnectedness of human experiences. Through alternating timelines and intimate letter-writing, the reader gains an understanding of the characters’ inner worlds and the challenges they face. The structure serves to juxtapose past and present, revealing how personal histories and relationships impact individuals’ lives.
The fragmented and epistolary nature of Lenore’s and Catherine’s narratives reflects their emotional states and the turbulent times they live in, demonstrating the importance of the novel’s historical contexts. This structure allows the reader to develop a deeper understanding of each protagonist’s personal thoughts and fears, such as those depicted during Lenore’s candid confession in her letter to Beth— “What if I can’t deliver this baby? To be honest I don’t know if I’m more scared for her or me” (202). This vulnerability highlights Lenore’s internal conflict, which is a recurring concept in her storyline. The alternating perspectives between Lenore and her daughter Catherine contribute to the development of The Interconnectedness of Human Experiences Across Time. Lenore’s decision to leave for America after becoming pregnant is paralleled by Catherine’s arduous journey to New York City and her struggle to protect Beezie. Through their determination, both characters exhibit Resilience in the Face of Adversity. They also contribute to The Quest for Belonging and Acceptance through Catherine’s connection with Sofia and through Lenore’s continued emotional connection to Beth.
Lenore’s letters to Beth and Catherine’s letters to Ellis serve not only as narrative devices to provide exposition but also as a means to explore their respective character arcs. Through the letters, the reader witnesses Lenore’s gradual acceptance of her grief and fears and her decision to move forward despite them. Similarly, Catherine’s letters reveal her determination to survive and provide a better life for Beezie, even as she grapples with her feelings of betrayal stemming from Beth keeping Catherine’s true parentage a secret. The structure of these narratives also allows for the integration of the historical contexts. The Dust Bowl and the impacts of WWI are ever-present backdrops that influence the characters’ decisions and shape their realities. Catherine’s descriptions of the harsh conditions in Kansas and the struggles she faces in New York—living in a crowded room and struggling to find and maintain employment—provide a vivid depiction of the era’s challenges, further contributing to Resilience in the Face of Adversity.
The portrayal of Lenore’s and Catherine’s stories also suggests the cyclical nature of human experiences. Both women face similar challenges, including fear, uncertainty, and the quest for belonging, despite the different times and places they inhabit. This cyclical theme is reinforced by the recurring motif of letters, which is expanded upon in the final section of the novel in which Adri leaves behind a letter for Lily. The motif of letter-writing contributes to The Interconnectedness of Human Experiences Across Time by connecting the past and present through personal correspondences. This theme is poignant because it highlights how individual actions and emotions pass through generations, reminding us of our collective humanity and implying a real-world hope that humans can make positive changes and not repeat their past mistakes.