logo

77 pages 2 hours read

Larry Mcmurtry

Lonesome Dove

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 1985

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 2, Chapters 41-45Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 2, Chapter 41 Summary

Lippy almost drowns when his wagon goes into a river. Bolivar resigns from the company shortly after. He’d had a dream about his wife and believes he should be with his countrymen. He leaves, and Newt doesn’t understand how he does it so easily. Bolivar had fired the shot that scared Lippy’s mules, leading to them dragging the wagon into the river.

Part 2, Chapter 42 Summary

Gus notices that Call is depressed. To cheer him up, they agree to go into San Antonio to hire a cook. They pass settlements on the way. Gus says they’re to blame for making the land safe. They’ve killed the people that made life interesting.

They visit a saloon called the Buckhorn, which is run by a man named Willie Montgomery, whom Gus knows well. Willie isn’t there, however, and the bartender ignores them. He tells them they should have cleaned up before coming in. Gus smashes his face into the bar and points his gun at him. He tells the man that their pictures are on the wall behind him. Then he throws a glass into the air and shoots it, before hitting the bartender on the ear with the pistol and knocking him out. Call looks at the picture of Gus, Jake, and himself. It was taken after they drove Kicking Wolf out of the territories.

The sheriff, Tobe Walker, arrives. Tobe had been in their Ranger troop. The new owner tells him to arrest Gus and Call, but Tobe ignores him. They reminisce and then say goodbye. Gus is still annoyed by the insults. He says in 20 years they’ll be the ones on reservations. They both know Tobe was sad that he couldn’t go with them.

Part 2, Chapter 43 Summary

Roscoe meets four soldiers who are headed to Buffalo Springs, Texas. They get him drunk, and he rides in their wagon. They drop him off the next day and point him to San Antonio, warning him about the Comanches and their forms of torture.

He comes to a cabin where an old man is sitting with a young girl. He tells Roscoe to leave the girl alone because he bought her. Roscoe sleeps outside. Later, he hears the man hitting the girl. Then he hears their bed creaking. Later, she continues to whimper.

The next day, a wasp’s nest falls on Roscoe when his horse brushes a tree. He sees the girl, Janey, behind a tree after he gets away from the wasps. She has run away from the old man. She says she can help him catch game. She makes a mud salve for his stings. She catches a frog and a rabbit for him. She says Sam won’t follow them because she hit his knees with a frying pan. She says that a man named Bill traded her to Sam but offers no further details.

Part 2, Chapter 44 Summary

As the men tell more horrific stories about capture by Comanches, Call goes off alone. The food has been bad since Bolivar’s departure. Call and Gus head to Austin to look for a cook, but on the way, Gus takes them on a detour. They arrive at a stream and Call sees that Gus has tears in his eyes. He calls the spot Clara’s orchard and then asks when Call was the happiest. Call can’t answer.

They see Lorena and Gus proposes that they bring her to the camp to cook. When Call complains, Gus reminds him about Maggie. She says Jake has been gone for two days, and he said he wouldn’t return. Call is annoyed when Gus dismounts and tells him to go on while he plays cards. Miles away, the Hell Bitch throws Call off. He tells her that if they don’t arrive at the Yellowstone together, it will be because one of them is dead.

Part 2, Chapter 45 Summary

Lorena is glad for Gus’s company. He says the trouble is that Jake gave her hope but only cares about himself. He challenges her to a game of blackjack for a poke, then asks her to imagine that he is the sporting girl, instead of her. If she wins, she can have him, if she tries to enjoy it.

Gus gets in the water in his long johns. Then he sees a man coming. As the man drinks from the creek, he says his name is Blue Duck. He has heard of Gus. He asks where Call is, and says he’d been told to kill them both if he found them. He leaves after making a couple of threats, and Lorena is terrified of him.

Gus says they almost caught Blue Duck ten years earlier. Lorena is frightened and says Gus could take her to California, but Gus says he’s going to Ogallala to see Clara. He wishes he had shot Blue Duck. Now that he knows the man is out there, he will not be able to relax. He says he’ll send someone back to watch Lorena. Lorena is hurt that he’s thinking of Clara when she is there with him.

Part 2, Chapters 41-45 Analysis

When Gus and Call visit the saloon, a new facet of Gus’s character emerges. For all his bluster and whimsy, he takes pride in what he, Call, and the Rangers accomplished. He also expects respect for their sacrifices. The men in their company have always paid respect to Gus and Call, but this is the first time the reader has public acknowledgment—in the form of the photograph—of how esteemed they are.

At Clara’s Orchard, Gus is unashamed of his tears as he recalls a treasured memory. Call cannot, or will not, answer Gus’s question about when he was the happiest. This is not the last time that Gus will question whether Call is even capable of—or desirous of—happiness. Because they are eventually headed towards Clara, the moment in Clara’s Orchard raises questions about her past with Gus.

Janey is a reminder of how cruel life on the frontier can be. She is essentially a sex slave, traded to Sam as a commodity to be used however he chooses. Outside of the brothels, which are relatively civilized, men in the novel often do what they want with women. Like Lorena and Clara, Janey is unwilling to remain the captive of men. Janey joining with Roscoe will provide more comedic moments, but she is also a narrative device whose death will compound July’s devastation in the coming chapters.

The appearance of Blue Duck brings a level of tension into the story that will not relent until his death much later. He embodies every racist story the men tell about the cruelties that Indigenous Americans visit upon their captives. He and Gus speak frankly about their pasts and their wishes for the destruction of the other. Afterward, Gus experiences a rare moment of frustration with himself; he wishes he had shot him and knows that he may never get another chance. They are now in a region that Blue Duck knows better than any of them, and Gus knows that the man’s sadistic streak and lust for revenge mean he will not leave them alone. Human danger and evil have now entered the story in their ultimate form, and Blue Duck’s actions will influence the rest of the novel.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text