46 pages • 1 hour read
Leo TolstoyHadji Murat
Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 1912A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Symbols & Motifs
Tartar Thistle
The Tartar thistle is a symbol that interlaces themes of resilience, defiance, and the essence of struggle against the backdrop of the central conflict of the story, the Caucasian War. This tumultuous and prolonged conflict saw the Chechen people pitted against the encroaching forces of the Russian Empire. Through the eyes of the narrator, the thistle emerges as a symbol of the Chechen spirit of resistance. Encountering the thistle while traversing a plowed field, the narrator expresses the desire to find something alive amidst the desolation of “this dead, black field” (4). Imperial Russia’s scorched earth tactics, marked by the deliberate destruction of forests in the Caucasus, take shape in the narrative as a strategy to strip the Chechen resistance of resources. This military strategy finds a symbolic parallel in the "dead, black field" described by Tolstoy.
When the narrator encounters the thistle, he reflects on the effort required to detach the flower, saying, “How staunchly it defended itself and how dearly it sold its life” (4). In this way, the thistle mirrors the broader struggle of the Chechen people to maintain their autonomy and cultural identity against imperial aggression. The thistle’s resilience in the bleakest environments epitomizes perseverance amidst devastation, paralleling the Chechen resistance to Russian domination. The thistle’s fight for survival leads to the narrator’s contemplation of the costs of war, the value of life, and the essence of resistance. On the novel’s final page, the narrator reminisces, “It was [Murat’s] death I was reminded of by the crushed thistle in the midst of the plowed field” (116). The narrative closes with the narrator linking the image of the plowed thistle directly to Hadji Murat’s fate, making the thistle a symbol of Murat's story and the themes of dignity, resistance, and the yearning for freedom.
The imagery of the thistle, a symbol of resilience facing eventual destruction, reflects the fate and struggle of Hadji Murat and the Chechen resistance. The thistle’s endurance amidst desolation becomes emblematic of the fight against imperialism and Murat’s predicament in the war. Through the symbol of the Tartar thistle, Tolstoy encapsulates the cost of freedom and the resilience of those who defend their way of life against conquest and subjugation.
Nightingales
Nightingales are a symbol that marks the intersection between the enduring spirit of nature and human conflict. It represents the cycle of life and death and the oscillation between war and peace. This songbird, native to Europe, Asia, and Africa, is celebrated for its melodious nocturnal song. In the novella, nightingales infuse the night’s silence with life and depth of feeling, reflecting the balance between the ephemeral and the eternal.
Nightingales emerge toward the end of the novella as Hadji Murat and his men make a daring escape from Nukha to rescue Murat’s family: "While Hadji Murat and his men made noise, entering the bushes the nightingales fell silent. But when the men became quiet, they again began to trill and call to each other" (104). The initial silence of the nightingales as the men rustle through the bushes represents how human endeavors, especially war, intrude upon the world’s natural tranquility. Their singing resumes, signaling the enduring resilience of nature amidst chaos. This dynamic between silence and song reveals the discord between human actions and the harmony of nature, reflecting Tolstoy’s critique of war as humanity’s estrangement from the natural world.
Furthermore, the nightingale’s song, particularly as dawn approaches, introduces themes of hope, renewal, and the promise of a new day, reinforcing the bird's symbolic associations. The imagery of dawn and the voice of the nightingale, set against the novella’s darker themes, captures the perpetual cycle of life and death. The bird’s short lifespan and rapid heartbeat are indicative of life's transience, foreshadowing Murat's death and offering a reflection on the resilience of beauty amidst human destruction, murder, and war.
Bulka’s Dagger
The dagger gifted by Hadji Murat to the young Bulka symbolizes kinship and connection despite ethnic differences. Bulka, the six-year-old son of Prince Mikhail Semyonovich Vorontsov and Princess Marya Vasilevna, is captivated by Murat’s dagger. Murat gives it to him, citing the Chechen custom of gifting one’s kunak anything they admire. In Chechen culture, a kunak is not merely a guest but a participant in a sacred bond of hospitality, where both guest and host are bound by reciprocal obligations; Murat acknowledges that as Vorontsov’s guest, he is the prince’s kunak and feels a duty toward the prince’s family. The gift symbolizes the importance of Murat’s connection with Vorontsov and Marya Vasilevna, demonstrating the sense of kinship and respect he holds for the family. Though Murat and Vorontsov are political opponents thrown into an uneasy alliance, the dagger highlights how human connection can overcome political enmity, if only temporarily.
Related Titles
By Leo Tolstoy
