66 pages • 2 hours read
Jon Kabat-ZinnA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
There are many kinds of stress, ranging from psychological, physiological, and social, all of which influence each other and have consequences for the mind and body. Dr. Hans Selye brought the terms stress and stressor into the mainstream with his research in the 1950s. Dr. Selye observed that animals who experienced stress succumbed to illness at higher rates; he argued that stress was as much a cause of illness as pathogens. According to Dr. Selye, while stress is a normal part of life, in some situations it can cause “diseases of adaption” (289). Kabat-Zinn claims that these theories are well supported by modern medicine and neuroscience and reiterates that it is not the stress itself, but the way people perceive and react to it, that results in illness. Studies have shown that having a “sense of control,” rather than a feeling of “helplessness,” over one’s stressful experiences is highly beneficial for coping with stress well (291-92).
The author argues that meditation, even when not immediately necessary to reduce stress, is a skill one can build and draw from in more challenging times. This practice will help practitioners become more “stress-hardy” and resist the pessimistic lenses which are easily applied to negative life events (294). Through reflection people may identify stressors in their life which they previously were unaware of, such as certain relationships or lifestyle choices. He concludes his chapter by reminding the reader, “If we can change the way we see, we can change the way we respond and thereby dramatically lower our stress and its short- and long-term consequences for our health and wellbeing” (296).
The author reflects on the ever-changing nature of everyone’s lives, from conception to death, and notes that change can often be a stressful experience if it is interpreted as a “threat to our well-being” (297). He explains that the human body has evolved to cope with environmental changes by working to maintain an “internal balance” called “homeostasis” (300). However, chronic stress can impede the body’s ability to perform these functions and create dysregulation. The author marvels at the body’s many automatic systems which operate subconsciously, such as breathing, healing, hormone release, and more. These systems can be compromised when the body’s stress burden, or “allostatic load,” becomes overwhelming (302). Researchers have found that negative life changes such as losing one’s spouse correlate with an increase in physical illness. The author argues that even positive life changes, such as having children or being promoted, can become distressing if people cannot adjust to the change. Kabat-Zinn posits that major life changes are an opportunity for meditators to become mindful about their mind-body reactions to stressful events and the beliefs they are holding about themselves.
Humans tend to be resilient in the face of many physical and emotional challenges, and can use creativity, intelligence, problem-solving, and community to overcome many problems. While human biology is hardwired to try to maintain balance, these systems can be overburdened, resulting in disease. “Internal stressors” are those generated by an individual, for example, the belief that they have an illness, even if they do not. “Chronic stressors,” meanwhile, are long term sources of stress, such as being a caregiver for a sick relative. “Acute stressors” are stressful events which come and go quickly, such as an argument with a family member. These types of stress can become chronic if people develop entrenched thought patterns around them and ruminate on them; research has shown that this can cause hypertension. When people feel threatened their body produces an “alarm reaction,” which can trigger a fight or flight response and the release of several stress hormones such as adrenaline, noradrenaline, and cortisol (312). Researcher Richard Davidson has demonstrated that meditation helps to stimulate the left side of the prefrontal cortex, reducing fear and anxiety in meditators.
The author ponders how people’s fight or flight responses served humanity better in past evolutionary phases when humans experienced more frequent physical threats to life. He laments that in modern life this stress response can become “chronically activated” (318). Even imagined threats to social status can trigger these powerful responses and many people become entrenched in negative reactive patterns. Kabat-Zinn explains that suppressing these emotions and pretending to be calm is “toxic” for the body and prevents it from achieving the release that running (flight) or fighting would provide (321). The only way to wrest control away from one’s stress hormones is to activate the prefrontal cortex by becoming aware of one’s own thoughts. “Maladaptive coping” is when people try to cope with stress through denial, workaholism, busyness, rumination, or addictions to cigarettes, food, alcohol, or drugs.
The author laments the culture of frequent prescription drug use in the US, and the influence that pharmaceutical companies have on doctors and medicine in general. He argues that people should think carefully before taking medication to relieve symptoms and become curious about how they might address the root cause of their discomfort. He considers some forms of legal and illegal drug use to be maladaptive coping methods since they do not “help us optimize our own capacity for self-efficacy, self-regulation, emotional balance, and the cultivation of our own deep biological capacity for homeostasis and allostasis” (330). Due to the short-term comfort that maladaptive coping brings, it is inherently addictive. Eventually, maladaptive coping damages organs, resulting in disease, or leads to burnout and nervous breakdowns.
People with chronic stress who suffer from an ongoing state of hyperarousal are generally very sensitive to feeling threatened, which triggers a physiological and behavioral process called an automatic stress reaction. Kabat-Zinn claims that by honing one’s awareness and paying close attention to one’s thoughts people can intervene in these responses, and change them from a “Stress Reaction,” in which they are helpless to their physiological or behavioral reactions, to a “Stress Response,” in which they can respond with intention. The author instructs the reader to allow themselves to feel negative emotions and physical sensations while observing what exactly these are. He argues that this form of mindfulness allows people to be “in relationship” to their pain or discomfort, instead of helplessly triggered by it (339). Daily meditation helps people build the “‘muscle’ of mindfulness” that makes this possible. While this process often takes practice, and has varying results, the author urges the reader to try it. He points out that people often have little to lose by taking the time to reconsider a charged situation or approach a conflict with compassion for themselves and others.
The author encourages the reader to think about how their bodies are feeling and place specific reactions, such as a pounding heart or clenched jaw, to reorient themselves to the present moment. He suggests that breathing is a good way to calm down and rest one’s mind to avoid spontaneous reactions. Once the stress response is over, the author instructs the reader to move on and continue to live in the present. These strategies can help people cope with a wide variety of stressors, for instance, one woman learned to pay attention to her cravings and manage her breathing to overcome a smoking addiction.
Studies have shown that people who practice mindfulness have lower blood pressure when stressed than those who are not familiar with these tools.
In these passages the author expands his theme on Meditation as Medicine by further exploring the connection between stress and poor health. He offers the reader a detailed summary of Dr. Selye’s 1950s experiments on animals which showed that stressful conditions resulted in higher rates of disease. He quotes Dr. Selye, writing, “If a microbe is in or around us all the time and yet causes no disease until we are exposed to stress, what is the ‘cause’ of our illness, the microbe or the stress? I think both are—equally so’” (288). Kabat-Zinn explores how achieving a sense of control, in contrast to feeling helpless, is proven to reduce stress and illness in animal and human test subjects. He emphasizes that exercising more agency in a situation is a learnable skill, so people can rely on this aspect of the mind-body connection to help themselves heal. He explains, “Stress studies with animals demonstrated the extreme toxicity of learned helplessness, a term describing a condition in which we discover that nothing we do matters. But if helplessness can be learned, it can also be unlearned, at least by people” (292). By reminding the reader of the strong evidence demonstrating the mind-body relationship, and how ubiquitous stress is in people’s lives, Kabat-Zinn makes a strong case for learning tools to mitigate this stress.
Kabat-Zinn connects this research with his theme on Meditation as Medicine and as a form of empowerment, comparing the learned helplessness of the Stress Reaction to the empowered agency of the Stress Response. In discussing the physiological and psychological phenomenon of Stress Reactions, he emphasizes how this “very rapid cascade of brain and nervous system firings and the release of a bevy of stress hormones” makes people feel powerless to their own bodily and behavioral reactions (312). By characterizing meditation as a method to regain control over one’s own reactions, the author emphasizes the pragmatic benefits of such a practice, especially for one’s relationships. He notes, “In some situations, feeling threatened may have more to do with your state of mind and the context in which you find yourself rather than with the triggering event itself…You might try trusting that things will become more harmonious if you make the effort to meet the situation with a more open and spacious frame of mind, with a bit more calmness and clarity and even self-compassion” (340). The author argues that even when confronting problems alone, mindfulness is a practical tool to overcome constrained thinking. He explains that with awareness, “you are more likely to be creative and to see new options and openings where the moment before there didn’t seem to be any. You are more likely to see new solutions even to old and tiresome challenges…” (343). This argument suggests that meditation helps people thrive in their personal and professional lives, and that meditators can more gracefully withstand pressure.
Kabat-Zinn builds on this theme of Meditation as Medicine by continuing to employ both scientific evidence and anecdotal examples to support his argument that meditation has a powerful influence on both mind and body. One of the first studies on meditators’ mental health, performed in the 1970s by Daniel Goleman and Gary Schwartz, found that meditators were more sensitive and emotionally stimulated when viewing a disturbing video, but recovered more quickly than those who did not meditate. Kabat-Zinn also points to a study by Dr. Dean Ornish, who found that people with coronary heart disease who practiced mindfulness and yoga and ate a healthier diet, reduced their blood pressure during stressful tests. He also summarizes the findings of the Shamatha project, in which researchers measured the biological and psychological health of participants who attended a three-month long meditation retreat. The Shamatha project found that participants’ neuroticism decreased, and their levels of telomerase, an anti-aging enzyme, were 30% higher than people who did not meditate. Kabat-Zinn also provides examples of how his patients have put their mindfulness to use in stressful situations where they previously would have become upset or combative. For example, one man named Doug was able to calmly deal with a minor car accident that was not his fault, while another patient, Keith, used his mindfulness to overcome the extreme stress he felt at the dentist. This wide array of evidence convinces the reader that meditation can promote physical health as well as increase mental strength.
Books About Leadership
View Collection
#CommonReads 2020
View Collection
Goodreads Reading Challenge
View Collection
Health & Medicine
View Collection
Mental Illness
View Collection
Philosophy, Logic, & Ethics
View Collection
Psychology
View Collection
Religion & Spirituality
View Collection
Self-Help Books
View Collection