logo

18 pages 36 minutes read

Paul Laurence Dunbar

Frederick Douglass

Fiction | Poem | Adult | Published in 1913

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

The Hero’s Fight for Truth and Justice

From the beginning of “Frederick Douglass,” Dunbar sets a heroic tone that continues throughout the poem, rooted in the hero’s fight for what is right at a time of systemic inequality and oppression. Dunbar’s depiction of Douglass is akin to a medieval knight, valiantly fighting an evil that seemed overwhelming at times, but emerging a victor in the end. In the first stanza, Douglass is described as Ethopia’s “noblest born” (Line 6), placing him above all others. He is also described as a “champion” (Line 9) during the most “direful years” (Line 9), raising up his people and speaking words of encouragement. Douglass is equipped for this fight against evil with a “strong bow” (Line 15) of his power, and attacks his enemy, “Oppression” (Line 17), who dwells in a bloody “den” (Line 16) like a formidable beast. Dunbar continues this metaphor throughout the poem, to Douglass’s death on the battlefield, where “he died in action with is armor on” (Line 48), but the “kindling spirit of his battle-cry” (Line 52) continues to echo “throughout the land” (Line 51).

This imagery draws from well known cultural tropes to place Douglass among immortal heroes, solidifying the righteousness of his fight against slavery and inequality. With each stanza, Dunbar affirms that righteousness—which is constantly challenged by supporters of slavery and others seeking to deny the basic humanity of African Americans—touting Douglass’s victories with each exchange. In stanza four, the “sunlight of his truth” (Line 21) acts to reveal the evils of bondage in a way that is undeniable, just as the line “to sin and crime he gave their proper hue” (Line 23) speaks to Douglass’s ability to reveal the true colors of laws and policies that were likely morally acceptable to his contemporaries at the time. Likewise, in stanza five, the power of Douglass’s reasoning and oratory is expressed through the lines, “he dared the lightening in the lightning’s track, / and answered thunder with his thunder back” (Lines 29-30). The significance of Douglass’s contribution is paramount here: For the first time in history, an educated former slave is in a position to debate his own freedom and status in the world and on the public stage—and he does so with an arsenal far superior to that of his oppressor.

In fact, for the speaker, Douglass’s arguments rise above those of his opponent in large part because he is not arguing for himself or his own interest, but instead he is following God’s calling. Douglass speaks “not for himself” (Line 34) but knows “the import of his Master’s call” (Line 35); in other words, he is doing God’s work and his message is rooted in the justice of the word of God. Like many medieval heroes in literature, the knight’s quest is ordained by God, elevating its divine purpose above the “petty spites” (Line 28) of humanity, and Dunbar uses this familiar imagery to establish a similar tone. As such, he depicts Douglass as having devoted his life to this calling, ultimately dying a hero “in Freedom’s lists and for the aid of Right” (Line 45).

Freedom and Equality

The question of equality among men was hotly debated in the late 19th century in the aftermath of the American Civil War; by the time Dunbar wrote “Frederick Douglass,” segregation moved from being an informal custom to a practice codified in law. The 1890s in particular became a devastating turning point for the Black community after so much progress, as “Jim Crow” laws were being passed to separate white and black communities, southern states sought to disenfranchise Black voters, and lynching was on the rise. Douglass’s death at such a dire time would have felt like a devastating loss, and Dunbar’s poem in turn speaks to the core ideas Douglass fought for in his lifetime: freedom and equality for all under the law.

For the speaker, Douglass’s life was devoted to the liberation of his race, depicted in the second stanza where he raises Ethiopia up from “Bondage [which] held her bleeding in the dust” (Line 11). However, Douglass shares his “bounty” (Line 42) with “all who truly needed aught of him” (Line 40), noting that Douglass’s abolitionist work and later efforts in the suffragist movement reflected his interest in the equality of all people. In the end, despite Douglass’s absence, Ethiopia independently rises “from beneath the chast’ning rod” (Line 61), truly liberated and enabled to grasp her own freedom.

Douglass’s Death and Legacy

Throughout the poem, the devastating loss of Frederick Douglass is coupled with a deep appreciation for his legacy, as the speaker alternates between grief and hope. Written as a traditional elegy for Douglass, it mourns both the communal loss of Douglass, and speaks to Dunbar’s personal loss of a mentor and friend. This dual feeling is expressed by the speaker in stanza nine, where the speaker says, “we weep for him, but we have touched his hand, / and felt the magic of his presence nigh” (Lines 49-50). The loss is deeply felt because of the exceptional contribution Douglass made, here depicted as a “battle-cry” (Line 52) still echoing across America.

Dunbar identifies that battle cry as his greatest gift. A powerful orator, Douglass’s voice—whether as an orator, writer, diplomat, or statesman—contributed to reshaping the way Americans thought of African Americans, and how African Americans thought of themselves. In stanza two, Douglass’s whisper to his own race of “Hope and Trust” (Line 12) forms the first bond that will inspire them to action in the fight for the abolition of slavery and later for equality under the law. The whisper becomes “a fearless clarion” (Line 13) in the second stanza, boldly announcing his truth to the world, as he goes to battle for their freedom. Douglass’s exceptional talent as a voice for his people is present in almost every verse, as his voice cuts through arguments to reveal truths, expose evil, and defend his people.

Returning to the first stanza, that voice is eventually silenced in death. Here, a stark quiet hangs over “the teeming lists” (Line 1), which falls to a hush with Douglass’s passing. But as Dunbar ends the poem, that quiet is replaced with a “battle-cry” (Line 52) that can still be heard across the land; Douglass’s voice has become immortal and is still “ringing o’er the gale” (Line 56) for all to hear. For Dunbar, that voice symbolizes the spark of hope that galvanized the abolitionist movement and showed enslaved people and their descendants they could achieve more and live in freedom. In the last stanza, the speaker asserts this is still worth fighting for, and that voice will ultimately guide new generations to victory.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text