51 pages • 1 hour read
James PontiA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Twelve-year-old Florian Bates is a seventh grader at Alice Deal Middle School in Washington, DC. He also is a covert asset for the FBI because he notices things that others do not. To avoid the rain, Florian takes a shortcut behind the Safeway, ignoring the warning of his best friend Margaret that the route is not safe. A large Romanian man in a florist van is waiting for him. He knocks Florian unconscious.
Florian regains consciousness in the back of the van. He is relieved to see that he still has his backpack, as it contains a panic button disguised as an inhaler. He remembers his FBI training and uses his knowledge to build rapport with his captor. When he says the one phrase he knows in Romanian—“My hovercraft is full of monkeys” (9), his captor laughs. Florian is brought to a farmhouse, where he meets the famous gangster Nicolae Nevrescu: the main suspect in Florian’s current case. Florian tricks his captors into letting him use his inhaler, but when he sees a daisy tattoo on Nevrescu’s arm, he realizes that the FBI have been investigating the wrong man.
The narrative shifts back in time to five months before the events of Chapter 1. In this earlier timeline, Florian has just moved to Washington, DC, from Italy. A tall African American girl with a confident, friendly smile comes to the door to welcome him and his family. Her name is Margaret. Florian deduces many facts about her using clues that he obtained through his keen observation skills. He is worried that she will find his deductions creepy, but instead, Margaret is impressed and wants to learn how to use his method. He introduces her to TOAST, his Theory of All Small Things, which allows him to look for many small items that add up to a broader picture. He tells Margaret that his theory helped his father, a security systems designer, to catch a museum thief in Spain because Florian noticed the pattern that governed the robberies. Margaret wants to learn more but is late for soccer practice.
Florian and Margaret go to the National Gallery of Art, where Florian’s mother is an art conservator. The two children view the Van Gogh painting, and as Florian tells Margaret, there is evidence that Gauguin cut off Van Gogh’s ear—contrary to the commonly held belief that Van Gogh did it himself. While he admits that the dominant narrative may be correct, he also criticizes those who believe it to be an absolute certainty. He states that people are wrong to stop questioning commonly held beliefs. He says, “[I]f you don’t question what you think you know, then you’ll only ever see the big things and TOAST is worthless to you” (30). He shows her the portrait of Napoleon and asks her what time it is in the picture. She tells him that the clock reads 4:13, but he asks her to use TOAST to discern whether the painting depicts the morning or the afternoon.
After using details from the portrait to solve this minor mystery, they try applying the same methods to living people, and Margaret is a natural at TOAST. They observe a man who is sleeping on a couch. Margaret notes he has a scar on his chin. They also notice the man’s Spy Museum shirt and the camera around his neck, his Eastern European shoes, the wedding ring on his right hand (another European custom), and spit stains on his right shoulder. They deduce that he is a left-handed tourist from Eastern Europe who has a new baby. When a woman approaches him with a baby and speaks in a foreign language, Florian and Margaret’s deductions are proven correct. Margaret is excited to keep using the TOAST method. One week later, Margaret has dinner at Florian’s house and uses TOAST to deduce that Florian’s dad has been playing golf in California.
The family is pleasantly shocked that someone else has used Florian’s technique to baffle them. Margaret reveals that she got her hints from the LA Times in Florian’s father’s briefcase, the LACMA tag on his handle (Los Angeles County Museum of Art), and his tanned right hand. She reasons that because his left hand is pale, he was probably wearing a golfing glove, and because he didn’t come home with clubs, he must have borrowed someone else’s. Florian is elated, and TOAST becomes a game that he and Margaret play often.
At the end of July, they celebrate Margaret’s birthday by going to the museum. In the gallery dedicated to impressionism, they see a man painting a replica of Monet’s Woman with a Parasol. Florian explains that the copyist gets a permit from the museum. He notes that the difference between a copyist and a forger is that a copyist would never misrepresent their work to be the original. Margaret notes that the copyist has the same shoes as the man who was sleeping in the gallery on their last visit. Florian notices that the man is also left-handed and has the same scar on his chin. They believe that it is the same man.
Florian and Margaret don’t know what to do; they have no evidence that the copyist is doing anything wrong. Margaret proposes following him to see if he engages in criminal activity. Florian believes that this is a bad idea, but Margaret insists, and Florian agrees because it is her birthday. She notes that the copyist’s bag is from the George Washington University bookstore and suggests going there to see if he returns. They go to the Foggy Bottom Metro Station and wait. While there, Margaret reveals that she is adopted and that her birth parents left her at Engine House Four when she was 10 days old. The two friends suddenly see their suspect coming out of the metro station and going into one of the GWU dorms. When they go in after the man, he recognizes Margaret. She and Florian make up a story about being there earlier. They leave, shaken, and Margaret agrees that her suggestion to investigate the man was a bad idea.
Using a five-act structure, the author dedicates the novel’s first five chapters to establishing the dynamics between the core characters and delivering necessary exposition. James Ponti clearly draws upon the conventions of the classic Sherlock Holmes stories to lay out the rules of Florian’s TOAST method, and the protagonists’ shared interest in solving mysteries sets the stage for their investigation of the man who is changing his appearance for no apparent reason. As these initial scenes unfold, Ponti also uses cliffhangers to accelerate the pace and the tension of the narrative.
Even in the very first sentence, Ponti uses the combination of a matter-of-fact tone and unusual details to enhance the sense of intrigue that permeates the plot. When Florian first introduces himself, he delivers five very normal statements for a typical 12-year-old, then follows these deliberately mundane details with the bald statement, “I also work for the FBI” (1). This admission is placed alone on its own line in order to emphasize the point. Thus, Ponti abruptly catapults the narrative out of the realm of the ordinary and into a deliberately humorous and offbeat world in which anything becomes possible. These present-tense descriptions also emphasize the fact that for most of the novel, Florian will be delivering a retrospective narrative about the recent events that led to his involvement with the FBI. As these basic plot points are established, the near-cinematic nature of Ponti’s approach is also apparent in his decision to use Chapter 1 as a “teaser” segment of sorts. By crafting the action-packed scene of Florian’s abduction and describing the character’s astute application of FBI-related skills, Ponti establishes a sense of urgency and implicitly promises to relate the full range of events leading up to the kidnapping.
To fully introduce the two protagonists, Ponti then shifts the narrative back in time and describes the origin of their friendship and their shared interests in applying Florian’s TOAST method to real-life scenarios. As the narrator, Florian uses an honest, friendly tone that addresses readers directly. When Florian whimsically describes himself with five ordinary facts and one extraordinary statement, this stylistic choice establish makes Florian more accessible than the brilliant detectives from classic literature. Characters such as Sherlock Holmes or Hercule Poirot demonstrate a level of genius that is implied to be far beyond the capabilities of the average person, but Florian’s explanation of TOAST makes it clear than anyone with the patience to observe small details can apply this method effectively.
Just as Ponti uses both direct and indirect characterization to introduce Florian, he also uses both methods to quickly establish Margaret’s presence in the novel. By allowing the character to speak for herself, Ponti conveys the clear sense that Margaret is practical and street-smart; this aspect of her personality becomes apparent when she warns Florian about the risks of walking behind the Safeway. Ponti then balances this indirect characterization by describing Margaret’s physical appearance and openly stating that she “radiate[s] confidence” (17). Similarly, Ponti uses Florian’s character-driven voice to simultaneously develop the plot and add depth to other characters who have been rapidly introduced. Florian’s small asides and observations add quick snippets of vital exposition amidst a plot that is already racing along. Thus, Ponti manages to create adequate sketches of each main character even as the majority of the opening chapters are spent presenting the idea of TOAST and setting up the primary mystery of the story.
Florian and Margaret’s easy camaraderie and dedicated teamwork establishes The Importance of Friends and Allies, especially in the context of working together to overcome obstacles. Instead of thinking Florian is strange, Margaret is wowed by his ability and wants to rise to his level of observational skills, while he in turn is surprised to realize that TOAST is a method that he can share with others. Florian’s friendship with Margaret is central to the novel, and her social skills, local knowledge, and encouragement become vital elements that help Florian to overcome the obstacles of solving crimes and the challenges of everyday life.
In order to focus on Integrating Real-World Knowledge into Fictional Narratives, Ponti frequently incorporates prominent landmarks and famous settings. This approach allows him to educate readers and encourage further interest in the aspects of Washington, DC, that are featured in the story. To this end, Florian and Margaret’s visit to the National Gallery is punctuated by their fascination with their surroundings. Additionally, Florian’s use of the real-life portrait of Napoleon to explain the basic principles of TOAST adds an element of realism to the novel that offsets the somewhat fantastical nature of his more serious investigations for the FBI.
It is also important to note that Ponti uses these early chapters to establish key details and inject moments of foreshadowing that will be essential to the climax of the novel. Specifically, the symbol of the daisy tattoo on the suspicious man’s forearm is introduced in this section, and it will reappear in the final chapters as the full details of the mystery are uncovered. Additionally, the literary device of the cliffhanger is used so often that it becomes a motif, appearing at the end of almost every chapter. While the daisy symbol is simply mentioned without explanation, Florian states in the final sentence of Chapter 5 that this tattoo changes everything. This enigmatic statement is designed to pique interest, and as the narrative unfolds, the author implicitly promises a solution that involves the tattoo and a Romanian crime lord.