45 pages • 1 hour read
Albert MarrinA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
The Triangle Shirtwaist Factory was located in Washington Square Park. The area used to be a wealthy neighborhood called “the Row,” featuring “elegant townhouses,” but over the course of the city’s development, it changed to “a green oasis amid grimy factories and immigrant neighborhoods” (2). Marrin highlights Miss Francis Perkins, a key figure in the movement for workers’ rights and improved work conditions. Perkins and some friends were in the neighborhood and rushed to the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory when the fire broke out. The senseless loss of life profoundly affected Perkins and her friends.
The Triangle fire took place during a time of mass immigration to the United States. This coincided with the United States’ rise as a wealthy nation, but few immigrants were able to make their dreams of fortune a reality due to inhumane working conditions and pitifully low wages. The Triangle fire happened during a time when workplace health and safety were serious topics of discussion. The tragedy brought important questions about labor and humanity to the forefront.
The history of immigration to the United States is divided into two categories: old and new. Old immigration took place during the pre-independence colonial era and consisted mostly of people from Western and Northern Europe. Most of these people were English speakers and Protestant Christians. The 1880s marked the shift from old to new immigration; people began arriving from places in Eastern and Southern Europe. These immigrants were largely Italian Catholics and Russian Jews.
The Italians immigrating were primarily from southern Italy, which was experiencing widespread poverty and a restrictive landlord/peasant system. Southern Italy was taxed heavily, but little of that money found its way back to the people or infrastructure; instead, the taxes were spent on improvements in northern Italy. Southern Italians were discriminated against by their northern counterparts; they were called “black Italians” in a racist attempt to show their inferiority. In addition to social and economic challenges, there were environmental disasters. Overcutting of forests led to soil infertility, crop failure, and famine. Swamps formed, breeding mosquitos that spread malaria into an epidemic. In 1905, a series of earthquakes led to casualties; a year later, the volcano Mount Vesuvius erupted, killing hundreds and causing over 150,000 residents to flee. In 1908, a tsunami swept through the Strait of Messina, killing 100,000 people and destroying hundreds of villages. These factors led to mass immigration; approximately 4.5 million immigrants traveled to the United States between 1880 and 1921.
Another significant immigrant group were the Russian Jews, who had been segregated and oppressed by the religious hatred of the Eastern Orthodox Russians. Before Russia acquired what is now known as eastern Poland in the late 1700s, Jewish people had been forbidden to enter Russia. With the acquisition of eastern Poland, Russia also acquired its many Jewish citizens. To keep this population segregated, Russia founded a territory called the Pale of Settlement, to which Jews were restricted by threat of imprisonment. A few thousand Jewish merchants and skilled artisans were permitted to live in Russian cities, but by the year 1900, 4.8 million Jews were living in the Pale.
In the Pale, most Jewish people lived in the shtetls, or small villages. They mostly spoke three languages: Hebrew, the language of their home country; Yiddish; and a dialect of German. The Russians severely oppressed the Jews: “[L]aws limiting Jewish rights filled a book of nearly a thousand pages” (17). Moreover, Jews were scapegoated, with government officials encouraging Russians to blame their troubles on the Jewish people. Many Jews, including children and babies, were killed in pogroms, or targeted massacres of Jewish people: “A single month, November 1905, saw no fewer than six hundred pogroms, an average of twenty a day” (18). The United States, with its constitutional guarantee of religious freedom, was an appealing option for many.
Immigrants traveled to America on ships. These trips could last anywhere from six to 17 days at sea. The conditions on the ships were terrible and unsanitary, with as many as 400 people sharing only two toilets, and no bathing facilities. It was a very difficult journey, but immigrants were rewarded at the end by the sight of the Statue of Liberty as their ships entered New York.
The prelude and first chapter provide important global context for immigration and the demographics of early 20th-century America. By establishing the differences between old and new immigration, Marrin develops the reader’s understanding of the racial and ethnic prejudices faced by post-colonial immigrants to the United States. Marrin’s use of statistics and headcounts provides a foundation for the reader’s understanding of how population exceeded jobs in the US, a dynamic that enabled sweatshops and abusive factory working environments.
Part of this context includes analyzing the forces driving southern Italians and Russian Jews from their homes. Marrin explains the plight of both groups in detail, highlighting social and religious discrimination. In contrast, America’s reputation as a free nation provided a significant allure, resulting in the mass migration Marrin describes. Though religious and social discrimination still occurred in the United States, the Constitution guaranteed certain rights and opportunities to all people, including the freedom to practice the religion of one’s choice. Life in the United States had its problems, but its public schools, religious freedom, and relative lack of violent persecution made the difficult process of immigrating worth the effort. Public education in particular served as a pathway for many immigrant families to establish themselves in the middle class as business owners and skilled tradespeople.
The book’s description of the suffering already endured by immigrants builds sympathy in advance for the conditions of factories and sweatshops. The immigrants are depicted as tough people accustomed to hard labor and poor conditions. Despite the reputation of the United States as a land of fairness and opportunity, Marrin’s inclusion of southern Italian and Russian Jewish history shows how determinative class, ethnicity, and background were. Immigrants faced the same kind of labor and poor living conditions in the United States as they had in their impoverished regions of Italy and Russia. Though immigrants gained certain freedoms when they came to the United States, they were once again treated as subhuman within the labor system.
These chapters also establish the causes and effects of wealth disparity between the rich and the poor, introducing the theme of Wealth, Greed, Corruption, and Destruction. Marrin describes immigrants living in unsafe, unsanitary conditions, in cramped, dark buildings that smelled like human waste. In contrast, he describes the wealthy as living in large mansions and townhomes, indulging in excess, and wasting money by “[smoking] cigarettes rolled in hundred-dollar bills” (33). The wealthy tended to see the poor as less than human, and themselves as special and deserving of their privilege.
Books on U.S. History
View Collection
Books that Feature the Theme of...
View Collection
Challenging Authority
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Community
View Collection
Contemporary Books on Social Justice
View Collection
Immigrants & Refugees
View Collection
National Book Awards Winners & Finalists
View Collection
Power
View Collection
Safety & Danger
View Collection
Teams & Gangs
View Collection