52 pages • 1 hour read
Polly HorvathA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Prepped for baking rolls, Primrose hears that Uncle Jack will show the cinnamon house the next afternoon. The following day, with rolls prepared, Primrose puts on her best dress and goes to Miss Perfidy’s house to get her best cardigan sweater. She explains why she left her sweaters with Miss Perfidy: “I wanted to see Miss Perfidy now and then. We had a peculiar relationship. We didn’t like each other much but had lived through my parents’ disappearance together. It gave us a kind of melancholy bond” (58-59).
Primrose notes that Miss Perfidy has her dress on backward. Miss Perfidy greets her by saying she knows Primrose came to get one of her sweaters. As Primrose enters the house, she sees several things that do not jive with her knowledge of Miss Perfidy’s routines. As they chat, Primrose realizes this is the most in-depth conversation the two have ever shared. As is typical, Miss Perfidy walks away while Primrose still speaks. Miss Perfidy describes a memory problem she has acquired: She remembers events that did not occur. For instance, she called a woman to thank her for inviting her to her family’s Sunday dinner, including her daughter’s piano performance afterward. The woman replied that Miss Perfidy had never been in her house on Sunday, they never cooked on Sunday, and her daughter did not play the piano.
Saying she thinks she has an appointment, Miss Perfidy rises to leave. Primrose goes upstairs to the closet where her sweaters hang. The sweaters are gone.
Uncle Jack picks up Primrose and her cinnamon rolls, and they drive to Miss Bailey’s house. As they walk across the street, Primrose emulates her uncle’s long strides and stumbles, skinning her knee, which begins to bleed. Miss Bailey says she has a bandage in the house, but the family that wants to see the home shows up, precluding Miss Bailey from reentering. Primrose stands outside with Uncle Jack’s handkerchief on her knee for half an hour. She begins practicing her uncle’s long strides and feels her knee start to bleed again, causing her to stop in the middle of the street and look down. Primrose hears the blast of a truck horn and looks up in time to see a truck headed toward her.
Waking in the hospital, Primrose is first aware of the cacophony around her and decides that she has not died and gone to heaven, which would certainly be less noisy. The nurse and doctor speak to her and tell her caregivers airlifted her to Comox Hospital after a truck struck her. Uncle Jack, who is downstairs getting coffee, hastens to her room. He explains to her that the truck was able to avoid a direct hit but did cause a concussion, and she has lost the little toe on one foot.
She says, “In the days that followed, once I got used to being short a toe, I began to enjoy certain aspects of hospital life” (71). Though the truck driver heroically prevented a fatality, he feels profound remorse. His wife bakes chocolate-covered cashews—that look like tiny toes—of which Primrose never tires. Grateful for their care, Uncle Jack distributes boxes of chocolates to Primrose’s nurses, who all seem to find him attractive.
Miss Honeycut appears with get well cards from Primrose’s classmates. She asks Primrose if Uncle Jack might enjoy company at supper since Primrose is in the hospital. Primrose immediately says no, then quickly explains that her uncle shows houses during the supper hour. When the counselor asks if it is time for her to abandon hope in her parents’ survival, Primrose asks Miss Honeycut if she has ever known something in her heart for which there was no rational explanation. The counselor rambles, then confesses to having an almost telepathic connection with her older sister. As Miss Honeycut leaves, she encounters Uncle Jack and Miss Perfidy, who came with him to Comox to see Primrose and then to visit her widowed sister. Primrose asks Miss Perfidy if she has known things in her heart for which there was no evidence, to which Miss Perfidy simply replies no. As they talk, Miss Perfidy scolds Primrose for eating chocolates, saying that when she grew up on a coffee plantation in Africa, she was not allowed to eat chocolates before bed. Later, Primrose discovers that Miss Perfidy has never traveled outside of Canada. Mrs. Witherspoon, Miss Perfidy’s sister, arrives to take Miss Perfidy home with her and seems distressed at Miss Perfidy’s disheveled appearance.
When Uncle Jack returns, Primrose asks him why he works so hard to sell the cinnamon house, which will bring him less return than most other properties. He replies, “Because […] it’s going to be the hardest to sell” (80). Lying alone after everyone has departed, her foot throbbing, Primrose experiences the unexpected sensation of real joy.
Once home from the hospital, Primrose discovers that Uncle Jack had supper with Miss Honeycut, who served him pear soup. She worked to convince him that he should free himself from the obligation of an orphaned niece. Uncle Jack insisted that he would perpetually care for Primrose. Primrose thought, “I knew he had just said this to let her down gently but it seemed to me it only gave her a greater motivation to get rid of me” (81).
When she returns to school, Miss Honeycut lectures her about the need to deal with her issues. Primrose has no idea what Miss Honeycut means. As a result of Miss Honeycut’s conversation with her teacher, Primrose receives the assignment of taking Herman, the class guinea pig, home with her on weekends. The teacher explains how this is therapeutic, and Primrose responds with a positive comment, to which the teacher also responds positively. Primrose writes, “But, of course, none of us had any idea what we were talking about. It was just one of those situations where everyone involved feels compelled to say something, anything at all” (83).
The boys who help Primrose carry Herman home end up playing hockey in the attached gymnasium. When she mentions this to Uncle Jack, he explains that this developed from his conversation with Miss Honeycut, who says she thinks Primrose spends too much time alone. Uncle Jack says he has set up a daily hockey match so that Primrose can hobble on one foot and be the goalie. After a week of waiting for the boys to ask her to play goalie, she takes Mallomar and goes to the harbor to watch for her parents.
Standing on a pier as Mallomar chases birds, Primrose sees a line of seals swimming through the harbor. They remind her of the occasion when her family spent a day sailing and continually encountered a pod of orcas. Her father knew this pod, having seen them many times while catching fish. As she watches the seals, she hears someone call her name and turns to see Miss Honeycut and Miss Perfidy across the street in front of a church where women gather goods for a rummage sale. Since a light rain has started falling, Miss Honeycut and Miss Perfidy decry Primrose’s lack of supervision and her unawareness that one should come out of the rain. Miss Honeycut insists on taking Primrose and Mallomar home. When they arrive and the women realize the gym is full of hockey players, Miss Perfidy announces it is inappropriate to leave Primrose alone with boys. Primrose picks up Herman’s cage, saying she will go to Miss Bowzer’s café. Miss Honeycut says she will drive her.
When Miss Bowzer sees Primrose standing at the kitchen door with Miss Honeycut, she grasps Primrose’s arm and pulls her straight inside, saying, “I’ll take it from here.” (92-93). Inside, Primrose covers Herman’s cage with an apron and sets him out of the way but too close to the stove. She and Miss Bowzer discuss preparing tuna casserole for Uncle Jack, with Primrose explaining that, while he might insist that the café upgrade its menu offerings, his own meal choices were not at all upscale. They realize that the wood chips in Herman’s cage are on fire. They extinguish Herman with little harm done, and Primrose takes him home.
Having trimmed the singed fur off of Herman, Primrose knows it will draw the teacher’s attention when she returns to school. Miss Honeycut calls Primrose to her office for the first of several counseling sessions. She launches into a lecture without asking Primrose what happened or allowing her to speak. Primrose’s attention wavers several minutes into the lecture, only to have Miss Honeycut yell a question at her, causing Primrose to fall backward in her chair. At that point, an emergency with another student summons Miss Honeycut, so Primrose escapes back to her classroom.
Primrose meets Uncle Jack at The Girl in the Red Swing café for supper that evening for the first time. They bump into Miss Honeycut, who is to eat with a group of teachers. Miss Honeycut begins criticizing Uncle Jack’s parenting efforts. He responds with pleasant, optimistic fervor, quickly turning the conversation to the apartment where Miss Honeycut lives. Having been there, he knows it is not suitable and offers to sell her at cost a new townhouse with a sunset view over the Pacific, throwing in her moving fees. Miss Honeycut says she must rejoin her friends. When Primrose asks about Miss Honeycut’s reply, Uncle Jack responds, “It means she plans to think about this when she gets home” (104). All three understand that Miss Honeycut’s acceptance of the deal means she must quit trying to remove Primrose from Uncle Jack’s home and life.
As they eat their supper, which Uncle Jack finds surprisingly good, Primrose expresses concern that Miss Honeycut will remain hypervigilant: “I don’t know how I’m going to take Mallomar down to the beach or sit on the dock and watch for my parents if everyone thinks I can’t even take care of myself anymore” (105). Uncle Jack suggests that Primrose take a long-handled net with her to the pier. Then she will look like those boys who use these nets to scoop fish and sell them. Primrose says the plan would have been perfect if it had not resulted in her removal to a foster home.
As mentioned, the second element of the traditional novel concept dictates that the conflict faced by the protagonist grows more complicated throughout the narrative. This element is introduced in the second section of Everything on a Waffle on a dramatic scale as various challenging elements work together in this section to compound the difficulties faced by Primrose.
For example, while Primrose stands in the middle of a residential street to examine a scraped, bleeding knee, a truck hits her. She ends up spending several days in the Comox Hospital. In addition to coping with the body-image dilemma of losing a toe, staying in the hospital makes Primrose something of a sitting duck for those who think they mean her well while actually compounding the conflict she faces. Primrose must successively listen to her hospital visitors, Miss Honeycut and Miss Perfidy. Rather than comforting Primrose, her counselor expresses the hope that she can spend time with Uncle Jack now that he does not have to care for Primrose in the evenings. When Primrose expresses her hope that her parents will soon return, Miss Honeycut snaps, “Don’t you think you ought to give that up” (73). Thus, within a few moments, Miss Honeycut reveals she is glad she can have Primrose’s uncle to herself and casts doubt on the most important hope in Primrose’s life—offering no comfort to the seriously injured girl. Miss Perfidy arrives to visit the bedfast patient and compounds Primrose’s difficulties by criticizing her for drawing attention to herself by getting hurt. Primrose insists it was simply an accident, only to have Miss Perfidy respond, “That's not what I hear. People have been saying that you tried to do yourself in. Everyone has agreed that you've gotten stranger and stranger since your parents drowned” (76). So, in a few brief sentences, Miss Perfidy tells Primrose that she was at fault for the accident and that her hometown neighbors spread negative gossip about her. In addition, for the first time, she plants the idea in Primrose’s mind that she might be self-destructive.
In the second section, Horvath portrays even those who are supposedly on Primrose’s side as making her life more difficult. During a private conversation, Miss Bowzer, like other adults in Coal Harbour, implies that Primrose’s parents are dead. In a bid to answer Miss Honeycut’s criticism that Primrose spends too much time alone, Uncle Jack recruits a series of hockey-playing boys to inhabit the adjoining gym after school, telling Primrose that the boys will let her play goalie and that she should lean on a hockey stick rather than her crutches. At the urging of Miss Honeycut, Primrose’s well-meaning teacher saddles her with the responsibility of caring for Herman, the class’s guinea pig, on weekends while Primrose still hobbles with crutches that prevent her from carrying the animal’s cage.
The greatest of her antagonists, however, is Miss Honeycut. In the five chapters of the second section, there is only one in which Miss Honeycut does not personally intrude in Primrose’s life and personal space: summoning her to the counselor’s office for counseling sessions, criticizing her at the beach for simply watching seals swim across the harbor, and interrupting her uncle and her in the café during supper to criticize Uncle Jack’s parenting skills.
All of these criticisms and judgments have the impact of exposing Primrose to The Challenges of Being Isolated. As noted, Primrose is unique as a tween character in that she never speaks about a group of friends or ever mentions having a best friend. This is a literary conceit the author uses to heighten the sense of Primrose’s isolation. While she is still physically present in Cold Harbour, Primrose spends most of her free time by herself at the harbor, watching for the ship that will bring home her parents. Beyond the physical isolation, the treatment she receives makes Primrose feel all the more alone, believing she will never escape the hypervigilance of an unchecked school counselor who wants to move her away from Cold Harbour and feels justified in doing so. Even after Uncle Jack offers Miss Honeycut a real estate bargain intended to get the counselor off her back, Primrose worries that Miss Honeycut will never leave her alone, all the while sincerely believing she is acting in Primrose’s best interest. Conversing with Miss Honeycut—with Primrose listening—Uncle Jack makes the doubly ironic comment, “I know you've got Primrose's best interests at heart. I'm sure we all do” (103). While his comment about Miss Honeycut’s intentions may have been cynical, Jack seems genuinely unaware that even the people who mean the best for Primrose cause her to be more isolated. The ultimate expression of her isolation comes in the third section when Miss Honeycut finally gets Child Protective Services to send her into foster care.
Primrose’s growing isolation is ironic in another sense as well, in that she is emblematic of the pervasive isolation that marks Cold Harbour. One may note that the author mentions only three functional marriages in the narrative: Primrose’s parents, Miss Bowzer’s parents, and Evie and Bert. Indeed, Horvath writes of few other couples at all. Lena and her husband quietly move out of town after her emotional break. Mrs. Witherspoon is a widow. Miss Perfidy, Miss Honeycut, and Miss Bowzer never married, just as Uncle Jack, despite all the attention he draws from women, has always been single. Part of the dynamic that prevents emotional connection among the characters, as Horvath portrays them, is the steadfast cleaving of each individual to a personal agenda. Perhaps the clearest example of the theme of Everyone Has an Agenda is the relationship between Uncle Jack and Miss Bowzer. Primrose laments the fact that two people who are really so nice cannot get together. However, as long as Uncle Jack intends to buy the café and turn it into an upscale restaurant, and Miss Bowzer intends to serve waffles garnished with comfort food, they will never bridge the agendas that isolate them. Thus, the author implies that the forces isolating the tween protagonist also prevent closeness among the citizens of Cold Harbour.