68 pages • 2 hours read
Sally HepworthDarling Girls
Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2022A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Themes
Abuse in the Foster Care System
At its core, Darling Girls exposes the vulnerability of children within the foster care system and highlights the potential for abuse in the absence of proper oversight and accountability. The character of Miss Fairchild is therefore designed to embody the worst possible version of a foster parent, for although she is vicious and manipulative in the privacy of her own home, she is also cunning enough to conceal her true nature from the authorities. Her ability to maintain custody of the children despite her abusive behavior is further enabled by Scott’s apparent complete lack of oversight, and these elements combine to emphasize the critical failures in a system that is ostensibly designed to protect vulnerable children.
The novel showcases numerous examples of abuses that can occur within a flawed foster care system. Physical abuse is evident in Miss Fairchild’s harsh punishments, as when she forces Alicia to eat beans off the floor or locks Norah in the dark basement. However, Sally Hepworth also depicts a far more nuanced landscape of abuse for the girls to navigate, for Miss Fairchild is just as adept at inflicting emotional abuse as she is at meting out physical punishments, and her unpredictable mood swings and manipulative behavior keep the children in a state of perpetual anxiety. She is also prone to egregious neglect, as when she denies the girls adequate nutrition and mistreats the many foster babies.
By juxtaposing the three sisters’ present predicaments with their past traumas, Hepworth also explores the long-term consequences of such abuse. For example, the adult Jessica struggles with anxiety and drug addiction, while Norah exhibits aggressive behavior and engages in transactional sexual encounters. Likewise, Alicia also has difficulty forming lasting relationships. These ongoing struggles drastically affect the women’s well-being and emphasize the lasting psychological and emotional damage of childhood trauma. As the three sisters struggle to learn adequate coping skills years and decades after Miss Fairchild’s abuse has ended, the author delivers a scathing review of the foster care system. This critical approach is further developed through the character of Scott, the unscrupulous social worker who facilitates illegal adoptions. His involvement in Amy’s (Zara’s) kidnapping and placement with Miss Fairchild represents a profound betrayal of his responsibilities and draws attention to the fact that the people who are meant to protect foster children are in the ideal position to exploit them if they so choose.
Ultimately, Hepworth’s harsh depictions of the abuse that runs rampant in the foster care system serves as a powerful critique of institutional failures and the resulting consequences for vulnerable children who grow up to become traumatized adults. By tracing the sisters’ experiences from childhood through adulthood, the novel paints a vivid picture of the long-lasting impact of such abuse, and the subtext calls for urgent reform and increased vigilance in child protection services. The novel also underscores the critical importance of listening to and believing children when they report abuse.
The Contrast Between Chosen Families and Assigned Families
The theme of The Contrast Between Chosen Families and Assigned Families becomes central to both the plot and the emotional arcs of the characters in Darling Girls. The novel presents the foster care system as the primary example of assigned family, with Miss Fairchild serving as the state-appointed caregiver for Jessica, Norah, and Alicia. This assigned family structure is portrayed as dysfunctional and abusive, with Miss Fairchild consistently using abusive tactics to control the girls’ behavior and to attempt to control their opinion of her. In stark contrast, the bonds that form among Jessica, Norah, and Alicia represent the strength of chosen family, for despite their lack of a biological family connection, the three girls forge a deep, sisterly bond that persists into adulthood. Their relationship, which is built on shared traumatic experiences and mutual support, proves to be far more nurturing and enduring than their assigned family structure under Miss Fairchild’s dubious care.
Hepworth also extends this theme beyond the sisters’ relationship with each other, for in adulthood, they and other characters actively choose their own family connections. For example, Alicia’s adoption of Aaron and Theo and her relationship with Meera demonstrate her determination to create a chosen family structure with the love and stability that she lacked in childhood. Similarly, Norah’s relationship with Ishir represents another form of chosen family, for she finally has a chance to develop a healthy, supportive partnership with a worthy companion. By contrast, Miss Fairchild’s dysfunctional relationship with her own mother, along with her jealousy toward her half-sister Amy, highlights the reality that biological connections do not always guarantee the formation of loving or healthy family dynamics.
Along with Hepworth’s representation of healthy chosen families, she additionally suggests that chosen family can be a powerful source of healing and growth. This dynamic is most prominently displayed in the sisters’ continued support for each other in adulthood as they all confront their past trauma in their own ways and navigate personal challenges with varying degrees of success. This pattern illustrates the resilience they have gained from their chosen family bond, and their connection ultimately helps them to move beyond their trauma and begin to heal: an opportunity that is explicitly denied to the self-centered Miss Fairchild. The sisters’ collective healing process is further emphasized by Alicia’s personal journey toward becoming a foster mother herself, for rather than reconstructing the patterns of her childhood, she chooses to create a nurturing family environment for children in need.
Ultimately, Darling Girls presents chosen family as a powerful alternative to assigned or biological family structures that fall short of the mark. While Hepworth acknowledges the profound impact of childhood experiences within assigned families, the novel also celebrates the potential for individuals to create meaningful, supportive family connections of their own choosing in order to forge a path of healing and fulfillment.
The Long-Term Impact of Trauma
Trauma and its effects emerge as a central theme in Darling Girls, illustrating how unresolved issues can perpetuate cycles of abuse across multiple generations. Miss Fairchild’s character arc serves as the most prominent example of this cycle. Her backstory reveals a childhood marred by jealousy and resentment toward her mother’s new relationship, and she also resents the presence of her infant half-sister, Amy. This unresolved emotional trauma—however misguided—leads her to commit a horrific act of violence against Amy, thereby initiating a cycle of abuse that extends to her adult role as a foster parent. However, Miss Fairchild also fails to show any self-awareness or guilt for her inexcusable actions. Because the narrative eventually reveals that Miss Fairchild’s own tale of childhood abuse is patently false, she is shown to have internal issues and insecurities that extend far beyond the latent effects of trauma.
Despite her lies, Miss Fairchild demonstrates an understanding of the effects of her behavior on her foster children, as is shown by her decision to lie to the psychiatrist in order to bolster her defense at trial. If she did not understand the psychological effects of abuse on some level, she wouldn’t be able to create such a convincing lie about abuse in her own life in order to garner sympathy. This tactic reveals Miss Fairchild to be even more monstrous and malicious than the narrative previously suggested, for as a foster mother she intentionally chooses to harm the children despite her intellectual understanding of the damage that she is causing them.
The theme is further explored through the effects of childhood trauma on Jessica, Norah, and Alicia in their adult lives, for Jessica’s anxiety and addiction issues, Norah’s complex relationship with sexuality and control, and Alicia’s difficulties in forming intimate relationships all are shown to stem from their experiences at Wild Meadows. However, the novel also offers a hopeful approach by describing Alicia’s journey toward becoming a foster parent herself, for this goal represents an attempt to break the cycle of trauma. By choosing to provide a loving home for children in need, she aims to create the nurturing environment that she lacked in her own childhood. Similarly, Jessica’s pregnancy at the end of the novel symbolizes the potential for renewal and the possibility of breaking generational cycles of abuse. The sisters are portrayed as self-aware and intelligent, and they are kind enough to intentionally raise their children in healthier environments than they experienced. Ultimately, Darling Girls presents The Long-Term Impact of Trauma as a complex and insidious force that can warp family dynamics across generations. While acknowledging the profound impact of childhood trauma on adult behavior, the novel also suggests that with awareness, support, and conscious effort, it is possible to break these cycles and create healthier family environments.
Related Titles
By Sally Hepworth
