74 pages • 2 hours read
George EliotDaniel Deronda
Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 1876A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Background
Authorial Context: George Eliot and Daniel Deronda
George Eliot, the pen name of Mary Ann Evans, was a prominent English novelist and one of the leading authors of the Victorian era. Born in 1819, she lived through a period of great social and intellectual change. Her later years were marked by literary success, personal challenges, and an exploration of her philosophical and moral beliefs through her final novel, Daniel Deronda. George Eliot achieved literary fame with works such as Adam Bede, The Mill on the Floss, and Middlemarch. Her writing style was characterized by psychological insight into her characters and an attempt to understand human nature. Despite facing criticism and prejudice due to her unconventional relationship with long-time partner George Henry Lewes, a philosopher and critic, Eliot remained steadfast in her pursuit of intellectual growth and literary excellence.
As Eliot entered her later years, she continued to work on her writing while grappling with health conditions and the loss of Lewes, who passed away in 1878. The grief from this loss was profound, and she found solace in her writing, which helped her cope with her emotions. During this period, Eliot embarked on her final literary venture, Daniel Deronda, published in 1876. This novel stands apart from her earlier works in that it delves into themes of Jewish identity and Zionism. Set predominantly in England, the novel follows two parallel narratives: one revolving around Gwendolen Harleth, a young woman from a privileged background facing personal and moral dilemmas, and the other focusing on Daniel Deronda, a young man of mysterious parentage who becomes involved in the search for his true identity.
The character of Daniel Deronda is central to the novel’s exploration of Jewish heritage and culture. Deronda, despite being raised as an Englishman in an aristocratic setting, discovers his Jewish roots and begins to grapple with questions of identity, belonging, and the meaning of life. Eliot’s portrayal of the Jewish community in Daniel Deronda was revolutionary for its time, breaking away from stereotypes and prejudices prevalent in Victorian society. Eliot met Emanuel Deutsch, a Jewish scholar, in the 1860s. He stoked her interest in the Zionist movement and the history of the Jewish people and religion. Eliot sought to bring this interest to her audience, though the antisemitic attitudes of Victorian Britain meant that Daniel Deronda was not as universally loved as her earlier works, and the novel received mixed reactions upon its publication. Some critics even called for a version of Daniel Deronda to be published with the Jewish-focused sections removed. Despite the divided opinions, Daniel Deronda remains a significant work in George Eliot’s literary legacy.
As her health became impacted, Eliot sought treatment for kidney disease, but her condition worsened, and she passed away on December 22, 1880, at the age of 61. Her death was considered a great loss to the literary world, and she was mourned by many. Despite her relatively short life, George Eliot’s contributions to literature and her exploration of human character and societal issues have left a lasting impact.
Socio-Historical Context: Jewish Life in Victorian Britain
The Victorian era was marked by significant social, political, and cultural changes in Britain. However, despite the progress, it was a challenging time for many communities, particularly the Jewish population. One of the primary difficulties Jewish people encountered in Victorian Britain was the prevalence of antisemitism. The Jewish community faced deep-rooted prejudices and stereotypes perpetuated by both the general population and influential figures in society. Antisemitic attitudes often portrayed Jewish people as outsiders or conspirators, perpetuating mistrust and hostility. The Jewish community was subject to numerous legal restrictions that limited their participation in various aspects of British society. The infamous Mortara case in 1858, in which a Jewish child was forcibly removed from his family by the Papal States, highlighted the vulnerability of Jewish people even beyond British borders. Additionally, Jewish people were restricted from holding certain public offices, and discriminatory laws often hindered their access to education and employment.
Jewish individuals faced economic hardships as they were often excluded from trades and industries due to discriminatory practices. The antisemitic perception of Jewish people as moneylenders or merchants led to economic prejudices, which further exacerbated their financial struggles. Consequently, many Jewish people were pushed into specific professions or trades, perpetuating stereotypes and limiting their opportunities for economic growth. Access to quality education was limited for Jewish children during the Victorian era. Jewish schools were few in number and often lacked the resources and recognition needed to provide comprehensive education. The exclusion from prestigious educational institutions hindered Jewish individuals from pursuing careers in fields requiring higher education. Jewish communities were often concentrated in specific areas, leading to residential segregation. The establishment of Jewish ghettos in certain cities perpetuated isolation and limited social integration within the broader British population. This segregation further reinforced negative stereotypes and contributed to the marginalization of Jewish communities.
Jewish characters in literature and theater were often portrayed using harmful stereotypes, further contributing to the negative perception of Jewish people in society. Authors such as Charles Dickens—with characters such as Fagan in Oliver Twist—reinforced these stereotypes, making it difficult for Jewish individuals to escape the shackles of biased public opinion. Eliot’s sympathetic portrayal of Jewish people in Daniel Deronda exhibits these same prejudices but provides a well-meaning attempt to address prejudicial attitudes. Eliot’s challenge to prevailing views led to criticism of her final novel.
During the Victorian era, conversion attempts were made to assimilate Jews into the Christian faith, often driven by religious zeal or a desire to promote conformity. The pressure to convert was a constant struggle for Jewish individuals who faced challenges in preserving their religious and cultural identities. Jewish individuals were often barred from joining or participating in certain social clubs and organizations, restricting their opportunities for networking and advancement in society. The exclusivity of these clubs further isolated Jewish communities and perpetuated a sense of being marginalized. Despite their significant contributions to British society, the Jewish community endured challenges in various aspects of life, from education and employment to social integration and religious identity.
Historical Context: Early Zionist Movements
The 19th century witnessed the emergence of Zionism, a political and ideological movement seeking to establish a Jewish homeland in the Middle East. This movement was a response to the challenges faced by Jewish communities in various parts of the world, particularly in Europe, where they experienced persecution, discrimination, and antisemitism. The 19th-century Zionist movements led to the eventual realization of the State of Israel in the 20th century. The roots of modern Zionism can be traced back to several early precursors in the 19th century. Among these was the Jewish Enlightenment, known as the Haskalah, which emerged in the late 18th and early 19th centuries. During this time figures such as Moses Mendelssohn promoted the idea of Jewish integration into European society while preserving Jewish cultural identity.
Moses Hess, a philosopher and socialist thinker, is considered one of the pioneers of Zionist thought. In his work Rome and Jerusalem (1862), Hess argued that the plight of Jewish people could only be resolved by establishing a socialist Jewish state in Palestine. His ideas laid the groundwork for the connection between Zionism and socialist ideologies. The pivotal figure in the development of modern political Zionism was Theodor Herzl, an Austro-Hungarian journalist and playwright. Herzl’s experiences as a journalist covering the infamous Dreyfus Affair in France in 1894 exposed him to the rampant antisemitism of the time. In response, he published Der Judenstaat (The Jewish State) in 1896, in which he advocated for the establishment of a Jewish state as the solution to antisemitism and Jewish assimilation. This work marked the official beginning of the Zionist movement. In August 1897, Herzl convened the First Zionist Congress in Basel, Switzerland. This historic gathering brought together Jewish representatives from various countries to discuss and advance the idea of a Jewish homeland. They established the World Zionist Organization (WZO) as the movement’s governing body.
Zionist efforts in the late 19th century focused on purchasing land and establishing agricultural settlements in Palestine, then part of the Ottoman Empire. The establishment of the first modern Jewish settlement, Petah Tikva, in 1878, and later the establishment of Rishon LeZion in 1882, marked significant milestones in the practical implementation of Zionist ideals. At the Sixth Zionist Congress in 1903, the British government offered a temporary homeland for Jews in East Africa (Uganda) as a potential solution to the Jewish question. The proposal created a deep divide within the Zionist movement, with Herzl advocating for serious consideration of the offer, and others, like Chaim Weizmann, vehemently opposing it. Ultimately, the proposal was rejected in favor of the original focus on Palestine. In Daniel Deronda, Mordecai has thought long and hard about Zionism. He desperately wants a homeland for his people and, though he dies at the end of the novel, his ambitions and dreams live on through Daniel. The disagreements among various Jewish characters regarding the feasibility and sensibility of Zionism reflect the real-life debates between Jewish intellectuals at the time of publication.
The 19th-century Zionist movements were marked by diverse ideas, ideologies, and approaches, all centered around the aspiration of creating a Jewish homeland in Palestine. The efforts of early Zionist thinkers such as Moses Hess, Theodor Herzl, and Ahad Ha’am laid the ideological foundation for the establishment of the modern State of Israel in 1948, making Zionism one of the most significant political and social movements of the 20th century.
Related Titles
By George Eliot
