36 pages • 1 hour read
Joy HarjoA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
The epigraph describes the south as the direction of release and notes, “Birds migrate south for winter” (134). It is the direction of flowers, fire, and creativity. It is an “eternal transformation.”
When Harjo lived in Tahlequah, she would reflect on her situation, wondering why she walked away from her dreams and let her people down. Her ancestors scold her in her mind for giving up on her ambitions. In Tulsa, she is becoming frustrated and bored with her situation, living for survival with a husband who cannot grow up. Her husband agrees with her, and they move back to Santa Fe to revive their earlier artistic dreams.
In Santa Fe, things remain the same, and Harjo gets a job pumping gas in a miniskirt at a local gas station. She finds a love letter from her husband to the babysitter and leaves him. Later she realizes this betrayal set her free. She then goes to the University of New Mexico in Albuquerque to study pre-med and then studio art, taking her son with her. Her ex-husband does not let her adopt her stepdaughter. Meanwhile, her brother Boyd is banished from her stepfather’s house and comes to live with her. When she writes to her mother venting about her stepfather’s abuse, he banishes her from their house.
American Indian peoples had begun to organize, especially at the university, inspired by the civil rights movement led by black Americans. Indians, however, wanted to maintain their own tribal identities rather than become full Americans. Feminism was rising at the same time. Harjo participates in the National Indian Youth Council (NIYC) and the Kiva Club, fighting for American Indian rights.
One of the NIYC leaders, a confident womanizer, flirts with Harjo and recites poetry to her on the phone the next morning. She begins a relationship with the poet, and they move in together. He drinks excessively, and eventually he hits her and becomes self-destructive. One night he starts a bar fight, and he nearly explodes their house with the gas stove and a cigarette the next morning. Harjo remembers her father’s alcoholism, and her friends struggle to convince her to leave him. She makes excuses for him.
One night when he drunkenly wanders naked into a motel pool, she feels their daughter for the first time inside her and realizes she is pregnant. She has just had a dream of a daughter who wanted to be born, and she names her daughter Rainy Dawn. She begins painting again and connects with her grandmother, who died before she was born and was a painter. She feels her ancestors within her, warriors like Osceola, who refused to surrender to the United States government. She recognizes herself and other Indian women as modern warriors, sacrificing for the well-being of their people.
She panics while returning from the university one day, having an intense feeling that she will die, which her daughter’s father ignores. This feeling continues for months. A psychic native woman confirms her suspicions that she is in danger. One night she has a vision of a story of a shaman on a Pacific island who heals by singing and dancing. Harjo realizes she “must become the poem, the music, and the dancer” (154).
Harjo begins to write poetry and realizes she must leave the father of her child. She has violent dreams about him. She finally makes him move out. Weeks later he returns drunk, and she has two friends with her for protection. He bangs on the door, screams, and cuts the electrical wires to the house. He kicks in the window and crawls in the house as the police show up. This time she does not take him back or help him out of jail. She realizes why she has put up with the abuse for so long, but now she breaks the cycle. She helps her friends whose partners were beating them, using her own house as a safe house. She notes that in the context of the fight for justice for American Indian nations, native women experiencing abuse at the hands of their alcoholic husbands have nowhere to go and feel they have no right to fight for their own safety. They are not supposed to talk about it.
She continues to party and drink, and eventually her knowing makes her realize that she can either continue down that path or take a better path. She advances in the university and begins publishing her poetry in the student magazine, but her panic attacks continue. She has a dream in which the monster that has been chasing her all her life catches her, but then it disappears, and she is free. She wakes and writes a poem in which she releases her “beautiful and terrible fear” (161). She realizes she creates the fear, and it is up to her to release it and free herself. The spirit of poetry comes to her and gives her the gift of language of the sacred.
Part 4, “South,” is defined by release, transformation, and creativity. Harjo transforms gradually throughout Part 4, first by moving with her husband to Santa Fe, then by finding work, then by leaving her husband for cheating. She further transforms by moving to Albuquerque and attending the University of New Mexico, as well as becoming involved in Native American activist groups such as the Kiva Club and the NIYC. While her relationship with the alcoholic poet sends her temporarily back into the same destructive cycle, she breaks out of this cycle by reconnecting with her spiritual side and having a momentous vision. After this vision, she learns to release her fear and transform herself into an activated woman, poet, and artist by releasing herself from her past and focusing on spirituality and poetry.
Harjo indicates the beginnings of her transformation by noting that she hears the scolding of her ancestors, who are counting on her to tell their stories. As she accepts that she has let her ancestors down by giving up on her dreams, she begins the steep journey to reclaim her life. Later, parts of her past are ripped away from her, first by her husband’s betrayal, which causes her to leave him, and then by her banishment from her mother’s house. These seemingly devastating events actually serve to propel her transformation forward by releasing her from her past.
Harjo gradually finds both her spirituality and her creativity again throughout the rest of Part 4, through her studies, through painting, and by meditating on the sacrifices of her grandmothers and her ancestors. Harjo reflects this change in her characterization by incorporating more spiritual language and dreams as the narrative progresses, culminating in her dream of the shaman.
Before Harjo reaches the end of her character arc, she begins a relationship with another charming, alcoholic man, indicating that her tragic flaw has not yet been overcome. Narratively, this represents Harjo’s final major test before her character arc can be completed. This relationship is even more tumultuous, as the poet is violently alcoholic, exhibiting severely destructive behavior. The panic attacks she experiences, while not explicitly connected to her new abusive boyfriend, begin soon after his behavior becomes overtly violent. After she grows enough to leave him through her rediscovery of poetry, his drunken break-in acts as a sort of climax of the memoir.
Once she overcomes this experience, her personal growth finally culminates in the dream of the shaman, in which she learns how to heal herself through poetry by releasing herself from her past. After struggling through most of the memoir to maintain her spirituality and creativity while having it suppressed by the destructive men in her life, now her spirituality and creativity emerge as her saving grace. By turning the destructive cycle inside-out in this way, Harjo turns her tragedy into her salvation, completing her arc.
Harjo also continues to integrate the themes of sexism, racism, and American Indian rights through her experiences with Indigenous activist groups. She also notes the hidden, destructive underbelly of this movement. First, the poet who is a leader of the NIYC turns out to be as destructive as any man in her life, and he nearly drags her back into misery. Second, after Harjo frees herself from this man, she describes how Indigenous women feel disempowered to speak out about or even acknowledge the domestic abuse they experience in their relationships, for fear that doing so will damage the broader Indigenous rights movement. Harjo does not shy away from exploring the nuances and unpleasant facets of this outwardly beneficial movement.
By Joy Harjo