logo

73 pages 2 hours read

William Wells Brown

Clotel

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 1853

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 19- 21Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 19 Summary: “Escape of Clotel”

Brown writes of the ingenuity of slaves escaping to free states, how they disguise themselves and concoct stories to deceive passersby. He writes that Mr. Cooper, the man who had purchased Clotel from the Frenches in Vicksburg, “treated her with respectful gentleness” (141) and bought her expensive presents in the hopes of “win[ning] her favour” (141). Clotel fears her situation can change at any time. She avoids Mr. Cooper’s attentions by telling him she remains loyal to her husband in Virginia.

William, another slave in Mr. Cooper’s home, lets himself out from Mr. Cooper and has saved enough money to someday buy his freedom. However, sympathizing with Clotel’s story, he gives her his money so she can escape. Clotel tells him she will only escape if he escapes with her.

With her hair still relatively short, and her fair complexion, Clotel disguises herself as a white man, taking the name Mr. Johnson; William pretends to be her servant. The two board a steamboat. Clotel wears a handkerchief across her face, professing to be ill, and she stays in her room to avoid speaking with people. William puts on a convincing act with the other servants on board. The two grow nervous when they spend seven days in a hotel in Louisville in which John C. Calhoun, a statesman and slave owner, is also a guest. Clotel is made even more nervous when she must convince the captain of the next steamboat that William is her slave. Once she and William safely arrive in the free state of Ohio, Clotel, despite Williams’s pleading, tells him that while he goes to Canada, she intends to seek out Mary in Virginia. Meanwhile, advertisements are taken out seeking information about the two escaped slaves.

William finds that prejudice also exists in the free states when he is made to sit in the luggage compartment of a train. Appalled, he argues with the conductor, eventually convincing him that he should only have to pay luggage fare. Brown writes of several incidents of prejudice and discrimination in free states and how even darker-skinned white politicians have been refused service until their identities are known. Black people are even discriminated against in churches and are either turned away or segregated from white churchgoers.

Chapter 20 Summary: “A True Democrat”

Henry, having been “[e]ducated in a free state” (151) and having married a woman “who had been a victim to the institution of slavery” (151), is staunchly against slavery, and he sends his two daughters to be educated in the North. He frequently “made himself obnoxious” (151) when speaking with people about his condemnation of slavery. One night at a party he delivers a passionate speech in which he states that slavery will “be the ruin of the Union” (151). He claims that Americans’ mere “boast of freedom” (151) will not lead to their being “respected abroad” (151), for Americans’ actions “will be scrutinised by the people of other countries” (151). He notes that “[d]espotism does not depend on the number of the rulers, or the number of the subjects” (152), for “Rome was a despotism under Nero” (152). In America, he says, “the free white citizens are the rulers” (152), and “[a]ll others are subjects” (152).

Henry goes on, stating that black people in America have “no voice in the laws” (152) to which they are subject; their lives are in the hands of “rulers whom [they] never chose” (152). White people, he says, are despots, for they “fasten iron chains, and rivet manacles on four millions of our fellowmen” (153). He fears that Americans “are fast losing our reputation for honest dealing” (153) and that once a nation’s reputation is destroyed, its “destruction” (153) soon follows. Again comparing America to Rome, he reminds his listeners that that city once was a proud empire and now is nothing.

He concludes by commenting that New Orleans, which has extremely “stringent laws […] against Negroes” (154), recently passed a law that a white man can marry a black woman because a white man desired to marry a wealthy black woman. He alludes to the hypocrisy in the fact that “the law prohibiting marriage between blacks and whites was laid aside for the occasion” (154).

Althesa is proud of her husband for speaking out against slavery.

Chapter 21 Summary: The Christian’s Death”

Brown compares two ships that arrived in America in November of 1620—the Mayflower, which contained good Christians who believed in “[j]ustice, mercy, humanity, [and] respect for the rights of all” (155), and a ship carrying African slaves. The ships represent “good and evil in the New World” (156).

Georgiana’s belief “that all men are by nature equal” (156) is “founded in the school of Christianity” (156). When she learns she is dying of consumption, she gathers the slaves around her and frees them, telling them that if they “are temperate, industrious, peaceable, and pious” (157), they “will show to the world that slaves can be emancipated without danger” (157). She says they must behave “better than whites” (157) in order to serve as an example. She also encourages them to follow Jesus Christ and to educate themselves and their children. She arranges for them to be sent to Ohio. Though some of the slaves ask to stay on the farm and work for wages, they are not by law allowed, “under penalty of again being sold into slavery” (158). Georgiana’s friends have tried to convince her to send them to Liberia, but Georgiana finds the Colonization Society, which advances this deporting of freed slaves, to have “originated in hatred of the free coloured people” (158), stating, “Its pretenses are false, its doctrines odious, its means contemptible” (158).

The slaves weep over and kneel to Georgiana. When they leave for the steamboat, they beg Sam to take care of Georgiana and Carlton. Georgiana dies less than a week later, leaving Carlton distraught over the loss of the woman who “had converted him from infidelity to Christianity; from the mere theory of liberty to practical freedom” (158).

Brown writes that “if departed spirits are permitted to note the occurrences of this world” (160), Georgiana would lament how so many people seek to put an end to the abolitionist movement. He prays that more people like Georgiana will “take the whip-scarred Negro by the hand, and raise him to a level with our common humanity!” (160).

Chapters 19-21 Analysis

Throughout Clotel, slaves demonstrate perception and shrewdness in order to survive. Just as Sam, in Chapter 16, is able to toggle between identities, in Chapter 19, William takes on different personas when needed. When he and Clotel escape on the steamboat, William plays “his part well in the servants’ hall” (143) by deliberately speaking in dialect and bragging about his “master’s” wealth. Clotel, all too aware of how a slave’s happy circumstances can change in an instant, does not grow complacent in her master’s evident kindness; she “tremble[s] at every footfall” (141), and she suspects even William, at first worrying that his kindness is a trick “to try her fidelity to her owner” (141). Clotel is right to worry over her situation despite her master’s “respectful gentleness” (141): Mr. Cooper tries “to win her favour by flattery and presents, knowing that whatever he gave her he could take back again” (141). Mr. Cooper is aware of, and ready to use, his power over her. Like many slaves, Clotel has learned to be wary and nimble of mind.

These chapters demonstrate that where Georgiana defends the true principles of Christianity, Henry defends the true ideals of America. Georgiana’s belief that “all men are by nature equal” (156) is “founded in the school of Christianity” (156). Upon her death, she asks the freed slaves to “[m]ake the Lord Jesus Christ your refuge and exemplar” (157). Her distaste for the Colonization Society, which she claims “originated in hatred of the free coloured people” (158), shows her defiance of those who exclude slaves as “other.” Henry delivers a passionate speech in which he warns it is not enough merely to talk loudly “in favour of liberty” (131)—Americans’ “boast of freedom” (131) is empty if the nation enacts “despotism” (131). He asserts that “[i]n this government the subject has no rights” (152) but rather “is governed, bought, sold, punished, [and] executed, by laws to which he never gave his assent, and by rulers whom he never chose” (153). Both Georgiana and Henry, though they never meet, demonstrate the hypocrisy of the institutions that support slavery. These Christian and American hypocrisies intertwine at the end of Chapter 19, when escaped slave William finds “that liberty in the so-called Free States was more a name than a reality” (150). Like many anecdotes in the novel, William’s experiences are based in reality: Brown relates that in a church in New York, slaves are segregated from white people, forced to occupy “a dark, dismal” (150) corner that is “grated in front like a hen-coop” (150). America is not, Brown notes, the land of freedom, nor does Christianity include all God’s creations.

Brown once again imparts credibility to his tale by blending fact and fiction. Clotel stays in a hotel in which John C. Calhoun is a guest. After William refuses to pay full fare when he is forced to ride in the luggage compartment of the train, Brown writes that the story “is no fiction” (148), that “it actually occurred in the railway above described” (148). His mention of how Daniel Webster and Thomas Corwin were ill-treated when assumed to be black further is evidence that his descriptions of discrimination are accurate. Even his naming William after himself—Brown himself escaped on a steamboat to Cincinnati—Brown suggests his novel, though fictional, is grounded in truth.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text