Between Two Fires

In what ways does Buehlman blend the genres of historical fiction, horror, and fantasy? What function does this serve in terms of the novel’s overarching meaning?

Describe the role of Jehan and Annette in the plot. What is the irony in Jehan’s occupation? Why does Annette feel so protective of Delphine? What is the significance of their deaths?

What is the significance of the interaction between Delphine and Sister Broom? Why does Sister Broom hate the Mother Superior? Why does Delphine tell Sister Broom that she pities her?

Describe the significance of dreams in the narrative. What horror elements are present in the characters’ dreams? Is there any dream that suggests hope for the characters? Do the dreams reveal the characters’ true natures?

Describe the narrative role of Robert. What was his relationship with Matthieu like? Why does he think of Matthieu as his “boring” brother? Does the novel suggest that Robert experienced redemption after his death? Why or why not?

Buehlman sketches a complex picture of the medieval Catholic Church. Is his overall portrayal positive or negative? If there is ambiguity, why do you think Buehlman includes this in the narrative?

What role do flashback and memory have in the novel? How does the past continue to haunt the main characters? How do they break free from the hold the past has over their lives?

What is the significance of the chapter about Rutger and the Penitents? How does Rutger manipulate people into following him? Why does Delphine feel that she needs to intervene? What human trait(s) do Rutger and the Penitents represent?