63 pages • 2 hours read
A.S KingA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Eleven-year-old Mac lives in a small town in Pennsylvania with his mom and grandad. Mac is an observant and precocious preteen. His mom and grandad encourage him to question things and engage in critical thinking, which sometimes brings him into conflict with authority figures. He insists that it is better to know the truth, even if it is upsetting, than to be ignorant.
At the beginning of the book, Mac feels a lot of anger and confusion at adults who lie or try to hide the truth from kids. His mom, grandad, and two best friends support him as he learns to deal with his anger and confusion. Over the course of the novel, he learns healthy and productive ways to channel his anger and sees that he can make a difference.
In addition to learning about how to manage his emotions, Mac begins to feel attraction toward his friend Marci. He realizes that he has a crush on her and is anxious about spending time with her and what she thinks of him. Eventually, he becomes more comfortable around her and asks her to the dance. However, Mac and Marci, in their continuous coming-of-age journey, decide that they aren't ready to date since they are only 11, but their friendship has grown deeper and stronger.
Marci is one of Mac’s two best friends and is part of the campaign against censorship. She is intelligent and mature and teaches Denis and Mac about feminism. She gets along well with Mac’s grandad and participates in the protests that he and Mac join on weekends. Grandad fondly calls her a “firecracker” because of her confidence and intelligence. Mac is attracted to her for these same traits and pursues a relationship with her before reverting back to friends due to their young age.
Marci serves as a catalyst for the book’s events when she finds the black rectangles in The Devil’s Arithmetic. She explains to Mac and Denis that the fact that the word “breasts” is blacked out is sexist because it implies that a word for a female body part is inappropriate and that boys are too immature to read it. This is especially insulting because the word appears in a scene about the Holocaust, where even young readers would know by the context to be mature about the use of the word.
Denis is Mac’s other best friend who also becomes involved in protesting censorship. He is anxious and sensitive, and Mac often tries to help him calm down about the things he’s worried about. Mac introduces comic relief within the narrative and represents differing sexualities as he shares his lack of romantic interest in others. After attending the dance with Hoa under the impression of going as friends, Denis quickly ends the night when he realizes Hoa is attracted to him as more than friends. His concern about the development illustrates his thoughtful character. Mac struggles at times to see Denis’s thoughtfulness, as he doesn’t always agree with how Denis goes about things. For example, Denis tells Marci about Mac’s feelings for her without Mac’s consent, spurring their relationship development on further. Ultimately, Denis is an understanding friend and positive influence in Mac’s life who supports him in his protest against the restriction of their intellectual freedoms.
Ms. Sett teaches sixth grade and frequently publishes her opinions in letters to the local newspaper’s editors. Ms. Sett’s blacking out of passages in the book the literature circle group reads begins the conflict of the novel and lends the book its name. Before Mac even enters Ms. Sett's classroom, he is aware of her reputation for being a major proponent of the town’s strict rules. She is known for defending rules like the curfew and only white paint being allowed for houses. He reflects on his first interaction with her when, on a field trip to Philadelphia, he asked how many of the Declaration of Independence signers enslaved people and she tried to get him to be quiet. Given these circumstances, Mac is skeptical of Ms. Sett in the beginning of the narrative.
When Mac is placed in Ms. Sett’s class, he is surprised that she treats them like adults. Ms. Sett’s censorship sparks Mac’s character development as he confronts her about her dishonest portrayal of Christopher Columbus. During these contentious interactions between Ms. Sett and Mac, her attitude is unbothered and condescending; she maintains that she knows what’s best for her students.
Mac’s mother is characterized by her strength and grace as Mac observes her hard work in hospice care as well as navigating her relationship with Mac’s father. She is patient and kind and gives people the benefit of the doubt. During her confrontation with Mike, Mac’s father, she maintains composure and grace through her feelings of distress. Mac notices and appreciates these qualities in his mom. Additionally, she also has an affinity for social justice like Grandad. A shift in her character changes after Mac’s father leaves, and she becomes more involved with protesting the censorship Mac faces. His mother’s expanded support provides Mac with additional encouragement as he faces the school board again, and her concerns about the issue importantly validate Mac’s feelings.
Mac’s grandad serves as Mac’s father figure in the novel and guides him through every challenging aspect of Mac’s life in sixth grade. He is a Vietnam War veteran who uses wellness practices like yoga and meditation to cope after having fought in a war at a young age. Grandad introduces Mac to the countercultural elements of the 1960s and 1970s, such as civil disobedience, protesting, and punk music, to help him channel his anger productively. He also encourages him to vent his anger and sadness freely. Mac realizes that even though his dad is absent, he still has a father figure because Grandad is there for him.
When Mac was eight, Mike moved out of the house. Mac does not fully understand why his father had to leave, but he still sees him on Saturdays when Mike comes over for dinner and works on Grandad’s car. Mike serves as a character who inspires Mac’s own character development through their differences. Mike tells Mac that he is an alien and that Grandad’s car is his spacecraft. While Mac attempts to entertain these stories to maintain his relationship with his father, Mike’s admission that he cannot love like most people do upsets Mac. Additionally, Mike’s presence and absence cause inner turmoil for Mac, who tries to conceal his family struggles from his friends. As Mac doesn’t believe in lies of omission, this causes a character conflict that Mac must overcome throughout the narrative. In the novel’s resolution, Mac reveals that he and his mother have ceased communicating with Mike, who has begun to go to therapy.
Aaron is a member of Mac’s literature circle group who represents the ignorance and small-mindedness that make Mac so angry. Aaron agrees that “breast” is a bad word, proving Marci’s point that censoring a word of female anatomy, making it a taboo topic, is sexist. His response to the censorship also proves Ms. Sett’s justification that boys aren’t mature enough to read the word. When Mac, Denis, Marci, and Hoa teach Aaron about censorship by appealing to his love of personal freedoms, Aaron is receptive and shows a gradual change of attitude. His character development is highlighted by his speaking more respectfully to and about his classmates, attending and participating in the school board meeting, and growing interest in borrowing books from Mac.
Appearance Versus Reality
View Collection
Banned Books Week
View Collection
Books & Literature
View Collection
Books on Justice & Injustice
View Collection
Childhood & Youth
View Collection
Coming-of-Age Journeys
View Collection
Community
View Collection
Daughters & Sons
View Collection
Education
View Collection
Equality
View Collection
Family
View Collection
Fathers
View Collection
Fear
View Collection
Friendship
View Collection
Grief
View Collection
Guilt
View Collection
Hate & Anger
View Collection
Juvenile Literature
View Collection
Mothers
View Collection
Realistic Fiction (Middle Grade)
View Collection
Safety & Danger
View Collection
The Best of "Best Book" Lists
View Collection
Trust & Doubt
View Collection
Truth & Lies
View Collection