logo

55 pages 1 hour read

Lisa Graff

A Tangle of Knots

Fiction | Novel | Middle Grade | Published in 2013

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 37-48Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 37 Summary: “Cady”

When Cady joins Toby in his truck, she hears “an odd sort of clatter” (160) in the truck bed. Toby dismisses the noise as a squirrel and says that he wants to leave for the bakeoff early to avoid traffic. Cady senses that there is something off about his smile but can’t identify the cause.

Chapter 38 Summary: “The Owner”

Toby leaves with Cady before the Owner can stop him. He feels “frustrated, but not worried” (161) about this development because he is certain that he will obtain her Talent eventually. The Owner’s phone rings, and a “meek, kind” (162) voice introduces herself as Jennifer Mallory and asks if Toby and Cady have left for the convention center.

Chapter 39 Summary: “Will”

Will boards a train to New York because he hears a distinctive “click-click-clack!” (164) that reminds him of his ferret. By the time he realizes that the sound is coming from the conductor’s hole punch, it’s too late for him to get off the train. Will curls into a ball in the luggage rack, feeling lost “[f]or the first time in his life” (165).

Chapter 40 Summary: “Cady”

Cady and Toby arrive at the packed event center in New York, where the Annual Sunshine Bakeoff is being held. She overhears some fans of hers: “‘There she is, that’s the little orphan!’ ‘Look, it’s Cadence! She’ll win again this year for sure’” (167). Although there is no sign of Miss Mallory, Cady tries to assure herself that she will come and declare the adoption official. The girl is extremely nervous and wonders if everyone feels that way “right before they got everything they’d ever wanted” (167).

Chapter 41 Summary: “Marigold”

Marigold goes to a wooded area near the highway to test out different possible Talents. She is interrupted by Zane, who is on a stolen bicycle laden with four powder blue suitcases. She correctly infers that he is on his way to Louie’s pawn shop to sell stolen objects and accuses him of taking her Talent bracelet. Zane denies stealing the bracelet, but Marigold doesn’t believe him. When she says that he should go to boarding school, he calls her “Mari the Middling” (170). Marigold is filled with “a rage that welled up from deep inside her” (170), and she pushes her brother and the bicycle into the path of an oncoming car.

Chapter 42 Summary: “V”

V hides in Toby’s truck bed. Although she doesn’t have much of a plan, she wants to confront him because he is a chameleon, like the man who “charmed her Caroline right out from underneath her” (171). She clutches the photograph she tore from Marigold’s book, which depicts a mother and a father with their infant daughter. She disembarks at the convention center, which she recognizes from the many talks she’s given there. She drops the photograph as she squeezes past a man who is rolling a barrel of flour and reading one of her novels.

Chapter 43 Summary: “Mrs. Asher”

Mrs. Asher rolls down her window, and Sally jumps onto her face. When she disentangles herself from the frightened ferret, she sympathetically observes that Sally must miss Will, too. She speculates that the ferret would know where to look because she accompanies the boy on all of his adventures. This gives her an idea, and she gets back on the highway.

Chapter 44 Summary: “Zane”

The Owner hits Zane’s bicycle with his car, scattering the suitcases’ contents and sending the boy careening face first into the dirt. Marigold apologizes profusely to her brother. A gray mist rises from the shattered jars, and squirrels absorb the released Talents. The Owner curses at the children and throws the bicycle at Marigold. Zane shouts, “You leave my sister alone!” (177) and lunges at him. Zane feels a sudden and sharp chill, and then the Owner is holding “a small rock of ice” (177).

Chapter 45 Summary: “Cady”

A woman informs Cady that there will be five judges at the bakeoff this year rather than one. She frets over this news, and the woman tells her, “You’re never going to be able to please every person every time” (179). The woman advises Cady to bake her favorite cake, but the girl has never given the question much thought because she didn’t plan to bake her own perfect cake until she was adopted. Cady is so distracted by her anxious thoughts that she doesn’t notice the “fist-size slip of paper that had found its way into her flour bin” (180).

Chapter 46 Summary: “Marigold”

Marigold attacks the Owner for hurting Zane. In the scuffle, the ice cube in the Owner’s hand slips under Marigold’s Talent bracelet and melts into her skin. The Owner throws the girl to the ground and drives away. Zane realizes that his sister now has his Talent. Marigold suggests they go to the police, and, to her astonishment, Zane agrees. As the children wonder how they are going to get to the police station, “a thick length of rope with knots tied into it, expertly” (183) suddenly falls from the sky. Looking up, they see the red and blue hot air balloon that crashed into their apartment. A man in a gray suit asks, “You kids need a lift?” (183).

Chapter 47 Summary: “Toby”

Toby sees the man distributing flour while reading Victoria Valence’s mystery novel about a chameleon and frets: “What if someone figured out the truth about Toby before he had a chance to explain it to Cady for himself?” (184). After the chapter, there’s a recipe for Zane’s Garlic Cake, “a cake that’s not as terrible as it seems, on the surface, to be” (185).

Chapter 48 Summary: “Zane”

Watching the man in the gray suit steer the balloon, Zane feels as though he shouldn’t have had any difficulty evading “a spit attack from an eleven-year-old boy out a twelfth-floor window” (188). Zane feels as though he’s been ruining things all his life, and this dismal self-belief is reinforced when the man tells him that the shattered jars contained Talents. Zane explains that he planned to sell the stolen jars but didn’t know what they contained. The man knows about Zane’s involvement in the hot air balloon accident, but he isn’t angry with the boy. The man compares Zane’s well-intentioned nature to spitting, which he says is healthy but “can sometimes take a bad direction” (191). Zane apologizes. To the children’s surprise, the man lowers the hot air balloon at Cady’s bakeoff, not the police station. He explains that they may be needed there. Even though Zane didn’t mention where he went to school, the man assures him that his next year at McDermott Elementary will be much smoother because there will be a new principal.

Chapters 37-48 Analysis

In the novel’s fourth section, Cady faces an identity crisis at the bakeoff, and Marigold and Zane repair their relationship. Chapter 40 underlines Cady’s great desire for Family Connections: If the adoption becomes official, she’ll have achieved her greatest dream. However, the happiness and hope she feels toward her chances of being adopted by Toby are tempered by her love for Miss Mallory and the dreary realization that the bakeoff is “[p]robably the last time [she’ll] ever see her” (178). Cady’s feelings become even more turbulent due to the changes in the bakeoff’s judging system. The woman offers sage advice when she tells the young baker, “You’re never going to be able to please every person every time” (179).

Her words of wisdom apply to more than just cake. Cady consistently puts herself last. Throughout the story, cakes serve as a motif of the theme of Identity and Self-Discovery. Cady doesn’t know which cake is her favorite because she’s been waiting for a family to give her a sense of identity. Cady may be the bakeoff’s undefeated defending champion, but she is also a lost little girl struggling with her identity.

V’s efforts to unmask Toby also connect to the theme of Identity and Self-Discovery. In Chapter 37, the clatter Cady hears is V hiding in Toby’s truck bed. A picture of Toby’s true self begins to take shape. He is Caroline’s husband and V’s son-in-law, as well as the fellow volunteer who worked with Mrs. Asher in Madagascar. Chapter 42 fulfills some of the novel’s foreshadowing by confirming that V is Victoria Valence, the author who wrote the mystery novel about a chameleon treasure hunter. In Chapter 47, Toby reflects on his identity. He wants to be the one to explain that he’s a chameleon to Cady and worries someone else will find out the truth first. This is an instance of dramatic irony because someone at the convention center has already learned the truth—V.

Meanwhile, Marigold and Zane take steps to mend their rocky relationship. In Chapter 41, the siblings needle each other about their deepest insecurities, namely, the threat of boarding school looming over Zane and Marigold’s lack of Talent. Zane brings his sister’s rage to the boiling point when he calls her “Mari the Middling” (170). The insult cuts deep and connects to the themes of Family and Identity because Marigold fears that she will always be an overlooked, unappreciated, Talentless middle child. She retaliates by shoving Zane into the road, an impulsive decision that could have killed him and instead sparks the start of their healing. In Chapter 44, the familial connections between the siblings grow stronger than ever. The Owner helps to unite the siblings by giving them a common enemy. As Marigold physically attacks the Owner in retaliation for the theft of Zane’s Talent, she defies her limiting label as the “good” and “responsible” child in her family: “Marigold was typically the type of girl who refrained from whacking surly old men in the shins as hard as she could. But today was not a typical day” (181). While defending Zane, Marigold inadvertently gains his Talent, which connects to the theme of Destiny Versus Chance because the accidental absorption plays an important role in the climax.

The traveling salesman’s reappearance also develops the theme of Destiny Versus Chance. In Chapter 48, the evidence that there is something supernatural about the man is compounded by his clairvoyance. He somehow knows without being told where Zane goes to school and that he’s been in trouble with the principal. He uses this remarkable knowledge to ease Zane’s persistent feelings of worthlessness: “‘I have a feeling, in fact,’ the man in the gray suit told him, leaning farther over the basket to talk to Zane in conspiratorial tones, ‘that you might just find [the next school year] to be very…worthwhile’” (194). These comforting words help Zane develop a healthier self-image and make better choices as the story continues. The traveling salesman alludes to both destiny and chance when he explains why he took the Asher siblings to the bakeoff rather than the police station: “Well, ballooning is not an exact science, you know. Besides, you might be needed here” (192). As this section draws to a close, the novel’s cast of characters converge on the bakeoff for the climax.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text