72 pages • 2 hours read
P. Djèlí ClarkA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Fatma arranges an audience with the reclusive angels by dropping the words “Seal of Sulayman” in her request. Along the way, the agents re-read notes from Rami to remind themselves of the confounding spell. Hadia points out that true angels have no free will and live with God; these “angels” are something else.
The angels’ leadership reside in an old medieval building, al-Gawhara Palace. A female djinn named Azmuri is the agents’ escort. After completing nine exhaustive forms for the bureaucratic angels, the agents follow Azmuri through the palace. In one room, they pass “a great machine of rotating gears with men and women moving about frantically to maintain it” (281). Azmuri jokes that this machine “keeps the world going” (281).
Finally, Azmuri delivers them to a private room, where four angels sit around a wide table, their ethereal forms housed in complex clockwork bodies. One introduces himself as Leader. The others are Harmony, Discord, and Defender—then the fifth angel arrives, and Fatma pulls her pistol, recognizing her as Maker. Leader clarifies that this is another Maker, a replacement for the one Fatma killed. Fatma uneasily accepts this explanation, and they begin to discuss the Seal of Sulayman.
The confounding spell is real, but Leader created it at the request of the djinn. Maker begins to explain the spell’s structural dangers and weak points, but Leader cuts her off. The impostor has thwarted the spell and wields Sulayman’s ring, he explains, which was stolen on the same day that Siwa, who worked in the angels’ employ, smuggled out the sword of al-Jahiz. The angels initially thought the seal went to Worthington, but then his brotherhood was murdered.
The angels produce records of Worthington’s holdings. Despite the man’s calls for peace, Worthington’s business invested heavily in weapons. Together, the angels and the agents deduce that Lord Worthington did not make these decisions; it was the likely work of someone close to him who had control of the business and access to Siwa. Leader tasks Fatma and Hadia with reclaiming the ring.
Before accepting the task, Fatma demands they stop abducting the bookseller and release her and Hadia from the confoundment spell. Leader agrees to the former, but he cannot undo the spell without violating a contract with other beings from beyond this realm. A loophole in the contract, though, allows for djinn outside the agreement to renegotiate it. The angels suggest the agents locate a sleeping djinn, and Fatma realizes she must waken the djinn she sealed in the bottle.
At the ministry, the agents take the bottle to the prison cells, hoping the wards will hold the djinn. When released, the djinn immediately attempts to kill Fatma—only to pause when her pocket watch alarm rings, reminding her to mention the Seal of Sulayman. Fatma explains that a mortal possesses the ring and could easily enslave him.
This mollifies the djinn, though he doubts the angels’ story. Angels possess far greater power than mortal thieves, so they must have allowed the ring to be taken, then charmed the agents’ minds to accept the far-fetched story. The seal, explains the djinn, is a near-sentient object; it would only allow a non-magical mortal “of exceptionally strong will” (297) to wield it. That said, the ring is likely withholding its full power, which it will offer only to a wielder ”whose want is pure” (298).
The djinn demands a price for renegotiating their contract, but Fatma appeals to his sense of self-preservation, citing the Nine Lords. The djinn, alarmed, agrees to her request free of charge. However, as she did not specify otherwise, he makes his removal of the confounding spell terribly painful.
The agents return to the Cemetery, combing through Portendorf’s ledger on the way. They remain uncertain why the angels were hoarding items related to al-Jahiz. Fatma leads them to Layla, the leader of the Forty Leopards, who has agreed to meet them thanks to Khalid—the coffee shop bookie is also Fatma’s contact in Cairo’s underground.
Layla is no ally of the impostor, but she is still angry over the police riot. She demands the agents pray with her, then takes them outside to a gathering of children. The Forty Leopards steal to provide for these children. The agents, thoroughly chastised by Layla, help serve food.
Layla confesses that the Forty Leopards plundered the angels’ vault on Siwa’s behalf, but notes that the jobs were suspiciously easy. In the last job, Layla recalls stealing the sword of al-Jahiz but can’t remember the other item. Ill omens have haunted her dreams ever since. Fatma feels satisfied with the information, but Layla insists they finish feeding the children.
Fatma and Hadia return to Siwa. Deciding resistance is useless, he lets them inside and dispels his illusion, revealing the grand apartment as a small room, dingy and disorderly. Fatma tries to question him, but at the mention of Alexander Worthington, the djinn pulls out a knife and again cuts off his tongue. He places the severed tongue in a basket with several more, all still wriggling, as a new tongue regrows.
Fatma suspects another spell has been placed to prevent him from discussing the impostor; instead, he spouts what Fatma takes for gibberish. However, Hadia recognizes the random phrases as passages from literature—a possible attempt to communicate through the spell. Sure enough, Siwa produces a set of papers, each with a single word written on it before becoming illegible. He has attempted to confess, but is only capable of writing a single word before the spell makes him sever his tongue.
Ashamed, Siwa confesses his gambling addiction. Fatma infers that he stole Portendorf’s list to fund his habit, and despite knowing the angels had tricked him, he continued the thefts. The agents work to interpret the passages he gives in response to their questions, learning that the impostor discovered the ring on his own, exploiting Siwa’s gambling addiction as the angels did. The impostor, they decide, is indeed the AW who appeared in Portendorf’s ledger, who Fatma assumes is Alexander.
The agents vow to obtain the ring and turn to leave, but Siwa begins repeating the question, “How does it suit you to be tested by the lion of the forest?” (338). He searches furiously for a book titled The Tale of the Lady Dhat al-Himma, which he gives them. They don’t understand but hope someone at the ministry can help.
At the ministry, Dr. Hoda has weakened the spell on the lock of hair, but Fatma must do the rest, mentally overcoming the illusion. Fatma persists, eager for additional evidence that Amir can’t ignore. Finally, the hair’s illusion breaks—it isn’t black but blond.
Clark drops a few key details from angelic lore here. The number of wings an angel has denotes its rank, also called its choir, with the highest choir, the seraphim, possessing six wings and the cherubim one rank below possessing four. The nine forms that they require Fatma to fill out likely references the holy number of angels—since the trinity is divine in Christianity, then three times three is thought to be holy as well, and angelic lore describes nine choirs—different forms—of angels.
However, this chapter provides many details, most of which cast suspicion on the angels. The presence of an angel identical to the one Fatma previously defeated bears little impact on the immediate plot save to put the agent on edge, setting up the distrust Clark wants to impose on the reader. Upon entering their headquarters, Fatma immediately takes note of a clockwork device, something which—save for the watch she carries herself—has commonly represented a collapse or a weakness within the story. By claiming the device keeps the world moving, Azmuri has potentially revealed another apocalypse waiting to happen, either at the failure or the intention of the angels, although Fatma cannot know this for certain because of the ambiguous statements from the djinn.
The angels also withhold their true names, identifying themselves by their profession or function instead. By linking this chapter with the djinn from chapter two, Clark reminds readers of the significance of a person giving others their name; the angel’s blanket refusal to even speak theirs hints at a level of power over the other sentient races that surpasses the superiority of any other character or race in the novel. Although Clark seems to be signaling a sequel, at the time of this writing A Master of Djinn remains the only full-length novel in the Dead Djinn series, and the nature of the angels’ secrecy cannot be interpreted beyond the bounds of the book. Since racial superiority is a recurring theme, they likely possess a sense of dominance over the other races. They have elevated themselves to the status of angel, belonging in actuality to some unnamed race of beings. This draws a connection between them and the English colonial powers even while suggesting their dominance over the Europeans.
Likely, this suggests that racial supremacy is relative. Even while the English believe themselves to be better than others, beings exist who subjugate them and manipulate them to further their own ends.
This chapter builds on themes explored earlier in the book. Most notably, the marid djinn casts more doubt on the angels’ involvement. Though the al-Jahiz impostor has acted as antagonist for the majority of the book, her status as the primary conflict appears to slip. While previously appearing as more than a match for Fatma, she will, throughout the remainder of the novel, slip more and more into erratic behavior, until she unleashes the 11th-hour villain in the Nine Lords. The djinn discusses all of this—the impostor’s weakened position, the cause of her erratic behavior, and the Nine Lords—suggesting a connection between them. Most notably, common to fantasy, the ring of Sulayman is nearly sentient, independently willed, and acts as a corrupting influence on its bearer. The effects of this corruption begin to surface shortly after this chapter, culminating in Abigail’s complete loss of control over the Nine Lords.
Furthermore, Fatma’s watch plays a small but significant role in confounding, then swaying the djinn. This again reveals a weakness, as the enraged creature’s plans fade quickly at the sound of the alarm, which itself rings to reveal the periodic weakness in the angels’ spell.
In her meeting with Layla, head of the Forty Leopards, Clark brings together themes of illusion and social justice. Despite their reputation as a gang of thieves, their intentions lie solely in the benefit of children—a class of people hard-coded into fiction and society as representing virtue and purity. She raises the issue of police trauma, horrors that the lower-class children will remember as they age, likely perpetuating the current distrust of authority. This serves as a reminder that in the slums, the impostor was a failed solution to a problem, not the problem itself, further cementing the villain’s loss of status in the novel and raising social problems to the forefront, pointing out that the true issues at stake may not be ones that law enforcement can deal with.
In his first appearance, Siwa served as a stand-in for formerly enslaved people struggling with social issues. Here, his basket of tongues stands out as the most grotesque and powerful image in the book. Though he cannot speak about the seal, finding a voice is so vital to him that he does it one word at a time, at great pain to himself. A strong component of social justice involves giving disadvantaged populations a voice, as there are many ways to silence their interests, be it through political means, such as voter suppression and gerrymandering political districts; news media, which can opt to produce, censor, or ignore issues depending on their own business interests; or something such as suppressing education, the way antebellum enslavers outlawed Black literacy, or how disadvantaged school districts are given tightly restricted funding to much the same effect. The fact that Siwa collects his spent tongues with no practical purpose for doing so strongly suggests the symbolism in the great pains taken to speak out in his own interests, and the difficulty in doing so.
The connection of voice with literacy is strengthened by the breakthrough in communication. As interpretive literature is apparently a loophole in the silencing spell, it works to eventually break through to Fatma that the impostor is Abigail, not Alexander. Interpretation is a notoriously unreliable method for clear communication, and so having a shared cultural background between the two characters is essential for Siwa to express his message, calling to mind the extreme efforts that the white elite of the United States took to stamp out Black culture, Indigenous American culture, and any foreign perspective they found threatening.
Regardless, Fatma doesn’t immediately understand the message, as the detective genre demands the villain’s unmasking at a later story beat—for pure detective fiction, this usually occurs at the denouement at the end of the book, but since this genre blends with fantasy, this will happen shortly to leave room for the final conflict.
By P. Djèlí Clark
Appearance Versus Reality
View Collection
Black History Month Reads
View Collection
Challenging Authority
View Collection
Fantasy
View Collection
Historical Fiction
View Collection
LGBTQ Literature
View Collection
Mystery & Crime
View Collection
Power
View Collection
Science Fiction & Dystopian Fiction
View Collection
The Best of "Best Book" Lists
View Collection