A Discovery of Witches

In several chapters, Harkness changes the narrative point of view from Diana’s first person to the third person. Why? What is the effect of this change on the reader? What ties these chapters together?

When Diana learns about the covenant, she thinks that Ysabeau and Sarah are not “bigots” (275), but instead simply following its rules. Diana believes this makes it easier to forgive their prejudices. Do you agree? Why or why not?

Consider the title of the novel. What do you think the “discovery” refers to? What is discovered or revealed over the course of the novel? What remains hidden?

The de Clermonts, the Bishops, and the Wilsons are very different, but unite against the Congregation. What brings these families together, despite prejudices and past wrongs? What values do the different families share? How are the families similar? How do they differ?

At the beginning of the novel, Diana lives like a human, denying her magic. By the end, Diana accepts her birthright. Describe Diana’s journey to self-discovery. How does she change over the course of the novel?

The Congregation enforces a centuries-old promise that mandates creature species self-segregate. What are the effects of the covenant on different creatures? Do you think the Congregation is justified in enforcing the covenant? Why or why not?

Ysabeau tells Diana that Matthew “always loved fragile things” (301), but Diana is strong-willed and independent. What does Matthew love about Diana? Describe Diana’s strengths and weaknesses. Does Diana have a fragile or vulnerable side?

Matthew and Diana share a powerful, predestined love. But their relationship still faces all the challenges of a modern marriage. What issues could threaten their bond? What do Diana and Matthew each need to do to help make their relationship succeed?